Table 1.
Study | n | Mean age | Design | Factor | Subj | Obj | Time before testing | Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Burke TA et al 2015 [40] | 6 | 26.8 | 28 hour sleep/wake cycle, tested upon awakening and every 2 hours | Awakening time | KSS | PVT, ADD, SDST, SVA, VST, Stroop | immediate | Cognition differentially affected by circadian, homeostatic, and SI effects. SI effect largest on SVA |
Scheer FA et al 2008 [41] | 12 | 24 | 28 hour sleep/wake cycles, with three awakenings during each sleep | Awakening time, preceding sleep amount | ADD | 1–2 min | SI worsened performance 17%, most severe during biological night. No effect of stage at awakening; modest effect of % sleep stage | |
Silva EJ and Duffy JF 2008 [42] | 10 | 64.9 | 20 hour sleep/wake cycles; data excluded if >10 min wake during last hour | Awakening time | SDST | 1–9 min | Performance worst when waking during biological night. Better performance when waking from REM than N1 or N2 |
Abbreviations: ADD=addition, KSS=Karolinska sleepiness scale, min=minutes, n=number analyzed, N1=state N1 sleep, N2=stage N2 sleep, obj=objective measures, PVT=psychomotor vigilance task, SDST=symbol digit substitution task, SI=sleep inertia, subj=subjective measures, SVA=selective visual attention, VST=visual search task