Table 2.
|
ΔΔGatt | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
forward FEP | −315 | −259 | −458 | 116 | 2 | ||||
backward FEP | −312 | −259 | −458 | 113 | −1 | ||||
TI | −311 | −260 | −457 | 114 | −1 | ||||
LRT | −325 | −267 | −480 | 112 | −2 | ||||
SSP λ = 0 | −165 | −143 | −218 | 89 | −25 | ||||
SSP λ = 1 | −485 | −392 | −742 | 135 | 21 | ||||
ΔΔGel | |||||||||
forward FEP | −1385 | −1556 | −2449 | 492 | −17 | ||||
backward FEP | −1387 | −1558 | −2443 | 501 | −9 | ||||
TI | −1388 | −1562 | −2448 | 501 | −9 | ||||
LRT | −1517 | −1694 | −2691 | 520 | 10 | ||||
SSP λ = 1 | −1528 | −1670 | −2678 | 520 | 10 |
These energies were obtained by forward and backward free energy perturbation (FEP), thermodynamic integration (TI), linear response theory (LRT), and single-step perturbation (SSP) from either the beginning (λ = 0) or ends (λ = 1) of the integration. All energies are in units of kcal/mol.