Skip to main content
. 2017 Mar 9;12(3):e0172591. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0172591

Table 1. Honey bee colony winter mortalities calculated for the different clusters during EPILOBEE 2012–2014 with the features of each cluster.

Cluster (number of apiaries)   W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7
(n = 403) (n = 695) (n = 1324) (n = 258) (n = 710) (n = 944) (n = 424)
Winter mortality (%)   14.04 8.11 9.50 9.74 11.46 8.66 12.57
Typology   hobby professional hobby Hobby hobby part time part time
Size (apiary & operation)   size 1 size 3 size 1 size 1 size 1 size 3 size 2
Age of the beekeeper (years)   Over 65 30–45 Over 65 Less than 30 30–45 45–65 45–65
Beekeeper background Training No Yes Yes No No Yes Yes
Apiarist book No Yes Yes No No Yes Yes
Qualification No Yes Yes No No Yes Yes
Member of bkp org No Yes Yes No No Yes Yes
Bkp experience (years) 2 to 5 > 5 > 5 < 2 2 to 5 > 5 > 5
Cooperative treatment against Varroa   No No Yes NCOR No Yes No
Apiary management Q & S production No information More than 10 No information No More than 10
Q & S bought No information No No information No No
Management No information Lvstk No information Production + HC + Lvstk Lvstk
Subspecies Buckfast / Hybrid / A. m. lig A. m. iberiensis / A. m. ccm Buckfast / Hybrid / A. m. lig. Local bees / A. m. carnica A. m. iberiensis /A. m. ccm
Environment Farmland / Town / Wood Floral Farmland / Town / Wood Diverse Floral
Production Queens Diverse Queens Honey Diverse
Colonies merged NCOR Yes NCOR No Yes
Migration No information Crops & Diverse No information No information Crops & Diverse
Clinical disease observed   Varroosis No clinical disease observed No clinical disease observed NCOR No clinical disease observed No clinical disease observed AFB & Varrosis
Health events   No No Yes NCOR Yes Yes No

The mortality rates of all the clusters were significantly different from each other (p<0.05) except between the clusters W3 and W4 (p = 0.18). Q & S = queens and swarms; HC = Health Conditions; Lvstk = Livestock; A. m. = Apis melifera; lig. = ligustica; ccm = carpatica, caucasia or macedonia; bkp = beekeeper; org = organisation; size 1 = operation ≤50 colonies and apiary ≤ 20 colonies; size 2 = operation ≤50 and apiary between 21 and 50; size 3 = operation between 51 and 300 and apiary >50; Diverse environment = apiary surroundings composed of two or more different types of environment; Farmland/Town/Wood environment = apiary surroundings either composed of only farmland or only town or only wood environment. Diverse production = honey, queens and pollen. Diverse migration = migration targeted locations mixing crops and wildflowers. NCOR = No Category Over Represented, i.e. for a given variable and a given cluster, among all the categories, none was over represented. No information = no information provided for these apiaries. For further details on clusters and categories, please refer to the text.