Skip to main content
. 2017 Mar 10;8(2):308–322. doi: 10.3945/an.116.013748

TABLE 1.

Review inclusion and exclusion criteria

Inclusion criteria Exclusion criteria
All reports Reports including a smartphone application with a nutrition-improvement focus Reports including an application with no specific nutrition-improvement focus [e.g., fitness applications or dietary tracking only with no within-application feedback or nutrition education delivery (controlled self-monitoring trials excluded)]
Reports providing data regarding a relevant smartphone application characteristic as identified by the subobjectives Reports with inadequate descriptions of all application characteristics
Participants and target users living independently within a community Participants and target users that are preschool-aged children (aged <12 y) or clinical populations with dietary treatments that extend beyond national healthy eating guidelines (for example, coeliac disease, allergy) but including overweight and obese, hypertensive, cardiovascular disease, and diabetic populations
Applications intended for use in the community setting Applications intended for use in a primary, clinical, or acute care setting
Any published peer-reviewed literature Review articles, commentaries, and theses or dissertations
Full reports published in English language after 2008 in which data were collected after 2008 Abstracts or brief reports, those not in English, or those with pre-2008 data collection or publication date
Additional criteria for reports of controlled trials Reports describing programs using a smartphone application as a primary or complementary program delivery tool Reports of social media, eHealth, text messaging, or other online programs not specifying the use of a smartphone application
Reports describing programs with nutrition content delivery via a smartphone application as a primary or complementary component, or studies assessing the impact of dietary self-monitoring by using a smartphone application on dietary improvement Reports of programs with no nutrition content delivered via the application, in which applications were used to record dietary intake without responsive in-application–generated feedback/education, or in which applications were used only for research data collection without an explicit participant self-monitoring objective
Reports describing programs delivered in the community setting Reports describing interventions or programs delivered in a primary, clinical, or acute care setting