TABLE 2.
Baseline study characteristics of multiple-micronutrient, protein, and food-based interventions in children ≥2 y of age1
| Study | Year | Country | Subjects, n | Mean initial age, mo | Form | Duration, mo | Mean initial HAZ | Quality |
| Multiple micronutrient | ||||||||
| Ash et al. (57) | 2003 | Tanzania | 750 | 120 | 5.4 mg Fe, 1750 IU vitamin A, 45 μg I, 5.25 mg Zn, 72 mg vitamin C, 0.6 mg riboflavin, 0.15 mg folic acid, 3 μg vitamin B-12, 0.7 mg pyridoxal, 10.5 mg vitamin E | 6 | −2.1 | Medium |
| Hall et al. (58) | 2007 | Vietnam | 1080 | 83 | Biscuits fortified with 18 vitamins and minerals; supplemented food provided 1400 IU retinol, 60 μg I, 5 mg Fe, 6 mg Zn | 17 | −1.47 | Low |
| Hettiarachchi et al. (16) | 2008 | Sri Lanka | 380 | 159 | 50 mg Fe, 14 mg Zn | 6 | −1.08 | Medium |
| Hyder et al. (59) | 2007 | Bangladesh | 837 | 144 | 7 mg Fe, 1296 IU vitamin A, 75 μg I, 7.5 mg Zn, 120 mg vitamin C, 0.91 mg riboflavin, 120 μg folic acid, 1 μg vitamin B-12, 1 mg vitamin B-6, 10 mg vitamin E, 5 mg niacin | 12 | −1.97 | High |
| Vinod Kumar and Rajagopalan (60) | 2006 | India | 159 | 90 | 3,000 IU vitamin A, 1 mg vitamin B-12, 1 mg Ca, 15 mg niacin, 1 mg pyridoxal, 100 μg folic acid, 1 μg vitamin B-12, 30 IU vitamin E, 30 mg vitamin C, 10 mg Fe, 250 mg lysine | 9 | −1.23 | Low |
| Lopriore et al. (61) | 2004 | Algeria | 209 | 50 | 1000 mg Ca, 1134 mg K, 635 mg P, 156 mg Mg, 42 mg Fe, 41 mg Zn, 2 mg Cu, 2000 μg vitamin A, 50 μg vitamin D, 20 mg vitamin E, 125 mg vitamin C, 4 mg thiamin, 4 mg riboflavin, 4 mg pyridoxal, 4 μg vitamin B-12, 500 μg folate, 25 mg pantothenic acid, 60 mg niacin | 6 | −2.85 | Medium |
| Manger et al. (62) | 2008 | Thailand | 563 | 111 | 5 mg Fe, 5 mg Zn, 50 μg I, 270 μg vitamin A | 7 | −1 | High |
| Muthayya et al. (63) | 2009 | India | 277 | 104 | 500 μg vitamin A, 0.9 mg riboflavin, 1 mg pyridoxal, 1.8 μg vitamin B-12, 300 μg folate, 227.1 mg vitamin C, 231 mg Ca, 100 μg I, 18 mg Fe, 10.5 mg Zn, 0.93 g α-linolenic acid, 0.10 g docosahexaenoic acid | 12 | −1.32 | High |
| Mwanri et al. (19) | 2000 | Tanzania | 68 | 143 | 5,000 IU vitamin A, 200 mg Fe | 3 | −1.9 | High |
| Ronaghy et al. (32) | 1969 | Iran | 30 | 156 | 10 g dried egg white, 6,000 IU vitamin A, 500 IU vitamin D, 50 IU α-tocopherol, 2 mg thiamin, 2.5 mg riboflavin, 25 mg niacin, 20 mg panthothenic acid, 0.3 mg biotin, 4 mg pyridoxal, 10 μg vitamin B-12, 90 mg vitamin C, 0.1 mg folic acid, 100 mg Ca, 100 mg Fe, 5 mg Mn, 0.1 mg Co, 1.1 mg Cu, 0.15 Cr, 2 mg Mb, 0.5 mg Ni, 0.1 mg Se, 0.15 mg I, 1 mg F | 20 | −2.96 | Low |
| Ronaghy et al. (33) | 1974 | Iran | 25 | 156 | 6,000 IU vitamin A, 500 IU vitamin D, 50 IU vitamin E, 2 mg thiamin, 2.5 mg riboflavin, 25 mg niacin, 20 mg panthothenic acid, 0.1 mg folic acid, 0.3 mg biotin, 4 mg pyridoxal, 10 μg vitamin B-12, 90 mg vitamin C, 100 mg Ca, 120 mg Mg, 100 mg Fe, 5 mg Mn, 0.1 mg Co, 40 mg Zn, 1.1 mg Cu, 0.15 mg Cr, 2 mg Mb, 0.5 mg Ni, 0.1 mg Se, 0.15 mg I, 1 mg F | 5 | −2.74 | Low |
| Rosado et al. (34) | 1997 | Mexico | 96 | 29 | 20 mg Fe, 20 mg Zn | 12 | −1.65 | High |
| Sarma et al. (64) | 2006 | India | 695 | 122 | 7.3 g protein, 2 g fat, 576 mg Ca, 14 mg Fe, 1.6 mg riboflavin, 2 mg pyridoxal, 1 μg vitamin B-12, 200 μg folic acid, 80 mg vitamin C, 400 μg vitamin A, 2.5 μg vitamin D, 0.7 mg thiamin, 0.9 mg niacin, 75 μg I, 2.3 mg Zn | 14 | −0.62 | High |
| Shatrugna et al. (65) | 2006 | India | 184 | 138 | 14 mg Fe, 1.6 mg riboflavin, 2 mg pyridoxal, 1 μg vitamin B-12, 200 μg folic acid, 80 mg vitamin C, 400 μg vitamin A, 2.5 μg vitamin D, 0.7 mg thiamin, 0.9 mg niacin, 400 mg Ca, 75 μg I, 2.3 mg Zn | 14 | −0.86 | High |
| Solon et al. (66) | 2003 | Philippines | 831 | 119 | 4.8 mg Fe, 700 IU vitamin A, 48 μg I, 3.75 mg Zn, 75 mg vitamin C, 0.46 mg riboflavin, 0.06 mg folic acid, 0.5 μg vitamin B-12, 0.5 mg pyridoxal, 2.5 mg vitamin E, 2.5 mg niacin | 4 | −1.81 | Medium |
| Zadik et al. (67) | 2004 | Israel | 37 | 173 | 10 mg Fe, 11 mg Zn, 10,000 IU vitamin A | 6 | −2.65 | Medium |
| Zadik et al. (68) | 2010 | Israel | 37 | 77 | 12 mg Fe, 6,000 IU vitamin A | 6 | −2.75 | Medium |
| Protein | ||||||||
| Grillenberger et al. 1 (69) | 2003 | Kenya | 178 | 91 | Ground beef added to githeri | 24 | −1.4 | Medium |
| Grillenberger et al. 2 (69) | 2003 | Kenya | 190 | 88 | Cow milk | 24 | −1.3 | Medium |
| Kabir et al. (70) | 1998 | Bangladesh | 69 | 33 | Protein-supplemented diet | 1 | −1.87 | Low |
| Lampl et al. 1 (71) | 1978 | New Guinea | 45 | 124 | Skim milk powder added to diet | 8 | −3.85 | Low |
| Lampl et al. 2 (71) | 1978 | New Guinea | 41 | 124 | Skim milk powder added to diet | 8 | −3.95 | Low |
| Larnkjær et al. 1 (72) | 2014 | Denmark | 61 | 161 | Skim milk | 3 | 0.84 | High |
| Larnkjær et al. 2 (72) | 2014 | Denmark | 53 | 161 | Casein protein | 3 | 0.78 | High |
| Larnkjær et al. 3 (72) | 2014 | Denmark | 59 | 160 | Whey protein | 3 | 0.89 | High |
| Malcolm 1 (73) | 1970 | New Guinea | 43 | 94 | Skim milk powder | 2 | −3.75 | Low |
| Malcolm 2 (73) | 1970 | New Guinea | 66 | 97 | Skim milk powder | 3 | −3.64 | Low |
| Pereira et al. (74) | 1969 | India | 35 | 42 | Rice supplemented with lysine and threonine | 6 | −2.07 | Medium |
| Pereira et al. 1 (75) | 1973 | India | 63 | 42 | Rice supplemented with lysine and threonine | 6 | −2.22 | Low |
| Pereira et al. 2 (75) | 1973 | India | 46 | 42 | Wheat supplemented with lysine | 6 | −1.88 | Low |
| Food | ||||||||
| Alarcon et al. (76) | 2003 | Philippines and Taiwan | 91 | 49 | Pediasure (Abbott Laboratories) | 3 | −1.38 | Low |
| Grillenberger et al. (69) | 2003 | Kenya | 246 | 87 | Fat added to githeri | 24 | −1.35 | Medium |
| Malcolm (73) | 1970 | New Guinea | 57 | 126 | 5 meals of taro and sweet potato instead of 3 | 3 | −3.6 | Low |
| Maleta et al. (77) | 2004 | Malawi | 61 | 51 | RTUF (high in micronutrient) or maize or soy flour | 23 | −3.1 | Low |
| Prasad Mp et al. 1 (78) | 2016 | India | 137 | 134 | Sorghum supplementation | 8 | −1.64 | Low |
| Prasad Mp et al. 2 (78) | 2016 | India | 125 | 119 | Sorghum supplementation | 8 | −1.2 | Low |
HAZ, height-for-age z score; RTUF, ready to use food; IU, international unit.