Skip to main content
. 2017 Mar 10;3:20. doi: 10.1051/sicotj/2017010

Table 4.

Functional outcome following sarcoma resection.

Paper Patient population Comparison Outcome measure Impact on functional outcome
Davis et al. [58] Lower extremity STS Function of patients with limb salvage
  • MSTS 87

  • MSTS 93

  • TESS

  • SF-36

Large tumor size:
  • Lower extremity MSTS 1987, MSTS 1993, TESS

Motor nerve resection (femoral, obturator, sciatic, peroneal, and posterior tibial nerves):
  • Lower MSTS 1987, MSTS 1993, TESS

Postoperative complications”
  • Lower MSTS 1987

High-grade tumors:
  • Lower MSTS 1993 and TESS

Bone resection:
  • Lower MSTS 1993

Davis et al. [32] Extremity STS Pre- vs. Postoperative radiotherapy
  • MSTS

  • TESS

  • SF-36

Postoperative radiotherapy:
  • Improved MSTS, TESS, and SF-36 at 6 weeks postoperative only

SF-36 compared to normative data:
  • Lower for both treatment arms across all time points

Wound complications:
  • Lower MSTS at 6 weeks, 3, 6, 12, and 24 months

  • Increased disability compared to baseline TESS

Large tumor size (>10 cm):
  • Lower MSTS scores at 6, 12, and 24 months

Motor nerve resection:
  • Lower MSTS scores

Previous unplanned excision:
  • Lower TESS score at 3, 6, 12, and 24 months

Davis et al. [31] Extremity STS Late morbidity:
  • Pre- (50 Gy) vs. Postoperative (66 Gy) radiotherapy

  • MSTS

  • TESS

Subcutaneous fibrosis:
  • Decreased MSTS and TESS

Joint stiffness:
  • Decreased MSTS and TESS

Extremity lymphedema:
  • Decreased MSTS and TESS

Pre- vs. Postoperative radiotherapy:
  • No difference in MSTS or TESS

  • Trend toward greater fibrosis with postoperative radiotherapy

Payne et al. [63] Upper extremity STS with flap coverage Pedicled vs. Free flap for wound coverage
  • MSTS 87

  • MSTS 93

  • TESS

Pedicled vs. free flaps:
  • Decreased MSTS 87 from pre- to postoperative in patients with either pedicled or free flap

  • Decreased MSTS 93 for free flaps

  • No difference in TESS between groups

  • Patients rated their function better compared to the actual rated impairment

Davis et al. [66] Lower extremity limb salvage sarcoma patients Relationship of symptoms to function during 1st year postoperative
  • Stiffness

  • Fatigue

  • Pain

  • Weakness

  • Limited range of motion

  • TESS

Stiffness:
  • Plateaus at 3 months

  • Remains constant over the year

Fatigue:
  • Plateaus at 3 months

  • Remains constant over the year

Pain:
  • Constant for 3 months then declines over study

Weakness:
  • Constant for 3 months then declines over study

  • Limited Range of Motion:

  • Constant decline over study

TESS:
  • Presence of pain, stiffness, weakness, and limited range of motion were predictors of worse outcome

Gerrand et al. [59] Lower Extremity Limb Salvage Sarcoma patients Sarcoma location and functional outcome:
  • Groin/Femoral triangle

  • Buttock

  • Anterior thigh

  • Medial thigh

  • Posterior thigh

  • Popliteal fossa

  • Posterior calf

  • Anterolateral leg

  • Foot and ankle

  • MSTS 93

  • TESS

Deep vs. superficial:
  • Superficial tumors have improved MSTS and TESS scores

Superficial tumors:
  • No decrease in MSTS or TESS from to pre- to postoperative

Deep Tumors:
  • No difference in MSTS or TESS based on tumor location

Groin/Femoral triangle tumors:
  • Increased pain based on the MSTS compared to other anatomic areas

  • Decreased ability to sit, put on socks, getting in and out of bath, bending to pick up items

  • More likely to have a limp or gait handicap

Buttock/Posterior thigh:
  • Decreased ability to sit

Ghert et al. [46] Lower extremity limb salvage sarcoma patients Vascular reconstruction and functional outcome:
  • Femoral

  • Iliofemoral

  • Popliteal

  • Tibial/Peroneal

  • TESS

Vascular reconstruction:
  • More likely to need a muscle flap, have a wound complication, sustain a deep vein thrombosis (DVT), suffer from edema of the limb, and require an amputation

  • No difference in the postoperative TESS

Jones et al. [45] Lower extremity limb salvage sarcoma patients Nerve resection and functional outcome:
  • Femoral

  • Sciatic

Comparison of femoral nerve resection and location:
  • Gender-matched large anterior thigh

  • All large anterior thigh

  • MSTS 87

  • MSTS 93

  • TESS

Femoral nerve resection:
  • No difference in MSTS 87, MSTS 93, or TESS between patients with sciatic nerve resection, gender-matched large anterior thigh tumors, or all patients with large anterior thigh tumors

  • Long-term risk of falling which could lead to fracture

Pradhan et al. [67] Patients with STS of the adductor compartment Outcome of treatment of adductor compartment STS
  • TESS

Impact on TESS:
  • Wound complications and high-grade tumors had lower TESS

  • Timing of radiotherapy (pre- vs. postoperative) had no effect on TESS

  • Need for a muscle flap; had no effect on TESS

Riad et al. [62] Patients with radiation induced STS Outcome of treatment in patients with a radiation-induced STS compared to patients with a sporadic STS
  • MSTS 87

  • TESS

Radiation induced vs. Sporadic STS:
  • No difference in the MSTS 87 or TESS

MSTS 87 = Musculoskeletal Tumor Society Functional Rating System 1987, a measure of impairment; MSTS 93 = Musculoskeletal Tumor Society Functional Rating System 1993, a measure of impairment; TESS = Toronto Extremity Sarcoma Salvage Score, a measure of functional disability; SF-36 = 36-Item Short Form Health Survey, a quality of life measure.