Skip to main content
. 2017 Mar 14;12(3):e0173378. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0173378

Table 2. Effects of Si and SAR on root phenotypic traits of rice seedlings.

SAR(pH) Si(mM) TRL (cm) RSA (cm2) RV (cm3) AD (cm) RTN
6.5 0 60.605±2.328 de(100.00) 10.042±0.233 fgh(100.00) 0.265±0.013 hi(100.00) 0.621±0.010 fg(100.00) 181.40±7.27 ef(100.00)
1 67.207±2.202 c(110.89) 12.307±0.723 de(122.56) 0.302±0.019 fg(113.96) 0.644±0.031 defg(103.70) 226.90±10.14 cd (125.08)
2 66.596±2.557 c(109.89) 11.183±0.805 ef(111.36) 0.280±0.017 gh(105.66) 0.654±0.011 cde(105.31) 244.42±15.04 bc(134.74)
4 46.280±1.688 g(76.36) 7.820±0.414 ij(77.87) 0.203±0.011 l(76.60) 0.745±0.023 a(119.97) 142.67±15.41 g (78.65)
4.0 0 70.375±2.198 c(116.12) 13.313±1.601 cd(132.57) 0.365±0.015 d(137.74) 0.647±0.009 gef(104.19) 217.07±12.39 d(119.66)
1 93.057±1.096 a(153.55) 18.332±1.151 a(192.55) 0.507±0.028 a(191.32) 0.675±0.022 bc(108.70) 308.90±12.15 a (170.29)
2 90.005±3.931 a(148.51) 17.424±0.242 a(173.51) 0.476±0.017 b(179.62) 0.683±0.011 b(109.98) 325.56±15.98 a(179.47)
4 62.607±3.432 d(103.30) 10.155±0.800 fgh(101.13) 0.305±0.018 fg(115.09) 0.666±0.028 bcd(107.25) 189.86±18.46 e (104.66)
3.0 0 60.753±2.609 de(100.24) 11.457±0.678 def(114.09) 0.333±0.012 e(125.66) 0.636±0.007 efg(102.42) 176.20±17.12 ef(97.13)
1 81.491±2.491 b(134.46) 15.123±1.054 b(150.60) 0.421±0.011 c(158.87) 0.654±0.019 cde(105.31) 235.67±11.23 cd(129.92)
2 78.540±4.330 b(129.59) 14.078±1.001 bc(140.19) 0.396±0.014 c(149.43) 0.663±0.011 bcd(106.76) 262.06±17.54 b(144.47)
4 58.261±2.308 ef(96.13) 10.259±0.625 fjh(102.16) 0.309±0.017 ef(116.60) 0.657±0.010 bcde(105.80) 170.76±13.52ef(94.13)
2.0 0 40.327±1.416 h(66.54) 6.485±0.663 j(64.58) 0.207±0.009 l(78.11) 0.720±0.013 a(115.94) 159.97±13.47 fg(88.19)
1 57.525±2.629 ef(94.92) 9.454±0.826 gh(94.14) 0.233±0.013 jk(87.92) 0.633±0.005 fg(101.93) 184.57±16.96 e(101.75)
2 60.281±1.583 de(99.47) 9.624±0.362 gh(95.84) 0.253±0.017 ij(95.47) 0.641±0.009 defg(103.22) 190.36±17.64 e(104.94)
4 54.100±2.101 f(89.27) 9.130±0.687 hi(90.92) 0.211±0.003 kl(79.62) 0.617±0.006 g(99.36) 166.74±13.14 efg(91.92)
F 46.277 34.623 62.362 0.640 35.923
p 0.000* 0.000* 0.000* 0.698 0.000*

Abbreviations: SAR, simulated acid rain; Si, silicon; TRL, total root length; RSA, root surface area; RV, root volume; AD, average diameter; RTN, root tip number.

The values represent the means ± standard deviation, n = 3. The value in brackets is relative percentage (the ratio of absolute value to the control).

Significant differences (p<0.05) are indicated by different letters in the same column.

* Significant at the 0.05 level.