Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2017 Mar 19.
Published in final edited form as: Curr HIV/AIDS Rep. 2016 Oct;13(5):241–255. doi: 10.1007/s11904-016-0325-9

Table 1.

Table of included studies

Study Type Age-median
(years)
Countries
included
Duration
of study
Sample size
(n)
Participants/health care
service description
Intervention Comparator Intervention Comparator
Chang et al. [21] Cluster-randomized
trial
35.5 34.0 South Africa 27 months; May
2006–July 2008
1336 Patients with
Community-
based peer health
workers
Control group-
accessing
standard of care
Fatti et al. [45] Cohort 35.1 34.6 South Africa 69 months; January 2004–
September 2010
66,953 Patients who received
community-based
adherence support
Patients without
community-
based adherence
support
Fatti et al. [46] Cohort 6.3 6.6 South Africa 69 months; January 2004–
September 2010
4,853 Patients who received
community-based
adherence support
Patients without
community-
based adherence
support
Franke et al. [47] Prospective cohort 37.0 37.0 Rwanda 15 months; June
2007 to August
2008
610 Community-Based
Accompaniment
Clinic-Based Care
Grimsrud et al. [48] Cohort 33.9 33.2 South Africa 20 months; May
2012–December
2013
8,150 Community based
adherence club
Community Health
Centre
Grimwood et al. [49•] Cohort 6.8 6.2 South Africa 57 months; January 2004–
September 2009
3,563 Children with patient
advocates
Children without
patient
advocates
Jaffar et al. [25] Cluster-randomized
equivalence trial
37.0 38.0 Uganda 48 months; February 2005–
January 2009
1,453 Home-based care Facility based care
Johnston et al. [50] Retrospective cohort 36.0 43.0 South Africa 75 months; January 2003–
March 2010
417 Community cohort Workplace cohort
Kipp et al. [51] Cohort 36.8 34.8 Uganda 15 months; March
2006–May 2007
385 Centre/Community-
based cohort
Hospital-based cohort
Kiweewa et al. [39] Randomized
controlled trial
27.0 27.8 Uganda 29 months; May
2007–September 2009
92 Nurse-Peer model Doctor-Counsellor
model
Luque-Fernandez et al. [27] Cohort Not
reported
Not
reported
South Africa 40 months; November 2007–
February
2011
2,834 Adherence clubs Traditional clinic-based
care
Massavon et al. [52•] Retrospective
cohort
91.0 months 45.9 months Uganda 2003–2010 1,623 Community home-
based
care approach
Facility-based family-
centred approach
Mfinanga et al. [40•] Open-label,
randomized
controlled trial
38.0
35.0
37.0
35.0
Tanzania Zambia 19 months; February,
2012–September,
2013
1,999 Clinic plus
community
support
Standard care
Nachega et al. [29] Open-label, randomized
controlled trial
35.7 36.7 South Africa 42 months; February
2005–July 2008
274 Directly observed
therapy
(DOT-ART) arm
Self-administered ART
(Self-ART arm)
Selke et al. [41] Cluster randomized
controlled clinical
trial
38.7 37.5 Kenya 26 months; March 2006–
April 2008.
208 Community Care
Coordinators arm
patients
Standard of Care arm
patients
Taiwo et al. [42] Randomized controlled
trial
Not
reported
Not
reported
Nigeria 19 months; June 2006–
December 2007
499 Treatment partner-
assisted ART
Patient-administered
standard of care
ART
Gross et al. [44] Randomized controlled
trial
38 37 Botswana, Brazil,
Haiti,
Peru, South
Africa,
Uganda,
Zambia,
Zimbabwe
30 months; April 2009–
September 2011
259 Partner-based
modified
directly observed
therapy
Standard of care
Nakigozi et al. [30] Randomized controlled
trial
37.6 37 Uganda 15 months; October 2010–
January 2012
1,209 Patient-selected care
buddy
Standard of care
Kaihin et al. [53] Cohort 18.2 19.4 Thailand 4 months; April-July 2011 46 Experimental Group
(Empowerment
Intervention)
Control
Kunutsor et al. [26] Randomized controlled
trial
39.1 39.2 Uganda 8 months; March-
September 2010
174 Standard adherence
intervention
package
plus treatment
supporter
intervention
Standard intervention
package
Munoz et al. [54] Cohort 31.7 31.9 Peru 17 months; December 2005–
April 2007
120 Community-based
accompaniment
with
supervised
antiretrovirals
Control
Coker et al. [43]a Randomized controlled
trial
Not
reported
Not
reported
Nigeria 18 months; August 2006–January
2008
400 Peer educators arm Standard of care
Coker et al. [43]b Randomized controlled
trial
Not
reported
Not
reported
Nigeria 18 months; August
2006–January 2008
400 Home visits and peer
educators arm
Standard of care