Table 3.
Author | Img. | Experimental task | Control task |
---|---|---|---|
False belief | |||
Saxe [49] | fMRI n = 21 | Read a short vignette involving a person holding a false belief. Answer a question about her belief. For example, “John told Emily that he had a Porsche. Actually, his car is a Ford. Emily doesn't know anything about cars so she believed John. When Emily sees John's car, she thinks it is a …?” (Porsche or Ford). | Read a false-photograph vignette. Answer a question concerning the outdated content in the photo. For example, “A photograph was taken of an apple hanging on a tree branch. The film took half an hour to develop. In the meantime, a strong wind blew the apple to the ground. The developed photograph shows the apple on the…? (tree or ground).” |
| |||
Trait judgments | |||
Mitchell [50] | fMRI n = 34 | Read an adjective. Indicate whether it can be true for a hypothetical person. For example, “ ‘nervous'…can it be true for ‘David?'?” | Read an adjective. Indicate whether it can be true for an object. For example, “ ‘sundried'…can it be true for ‘grape'?” |
| |||
Strategic games | |||
Assaf [51] | fMRI n = 18 | Play a “domino game” with a human opponent (you get feedback about her moves). You and your opponent hold some domino chips in your hands (undisclosed). On each turn, you must play out a domino chip with a particular number to get a game point. You play out your chips face-down (undisclosed), so you can pretend having the required number even if you have not. After you played out a chip, your opponent can decide whether or not to check the number on it (simplified description). | Play a “domino game” with a computer. |
| |||
Social animation | |||
Castelli [52] | PET N = 6 | Watch a video animation of two interacting triangles (e.g., mother and child are playing). Explain verbally what was happening (after fMRI). | Watch video animation of two randomly moving triangles. Explain verbally what was happening (after fMRI). |
| |||
Mind in the eyes | |||
Baron-Cohen [53] | fMRI n = 12 | View photographs of eyes. Indicate which of two words (e.g., concerned versus unconcerned) describes the mental state of that person. | View photographs of eyes. Indicate if the person is male or female. See Baron-Cohen 1999. |
| |||
Rational action | |||
Brunet [54] | fMRI n = 8 | View a cartoon story and predict what will happen based on intentions of a character (no false belief). Choose a logical story ending from several options shown in pictures. For example, a prisoner is in his cell. First, he breaks the bars of his prison window. Then he walks to his bed. Participants must indicate what will happen next…the prisoner ties a rope from the sheets on his bed/the prisoner shouts out loud. | View a cartoon story and predict what will happen based on physical causality. Choose a logical story ending from several options shown in pictures. For example, a person is standing in front of a slide. A large ball is coming down this slide, heading towards the person standing there. Participants must indicate what will happen next…the ball is knocking over the person/the ball is resting on the ground and the person is standing next to it. |