Skip to main content
. 2017 Mar 24;5:59. doi: 10.3389/fped.2017.00059

Table 1.

Overview of selected studies on neuropsychological and psychiatric outcomes for patients with d-TGA.

Reference n, age (years), diagnosis Neurocognitive or psychiatric assessment Main results
Children
Bellinger et al. (12) n = 158, 4 years, d-TGA
  • WPPSI revised,

  • Peabody Developmental Motor Scales,

  • Grooved pegboard,

  • Test for auditory comprehension of language,

  • Receptive one-word picture vocabulary test,

  • Expressive one-word picture vocabulary test,

  • Illinois test of psycholinguistic abilities.

  • Lower than expected mean scores in general intelligence (IQ), expressive language, visual-motor integration, motor function, and oromotor control.


Bellinger et al. (13) n = 155, 8 years, d-TGA
  • WISC III,

  • WIAT,

  • Wide range assessment of memory and learning,

  • Developmental test of visual–motor integration,

  • Test of variables of attention,

  • Rey–Osterrieth complex figure,

  • Verbal fluency,

  • Wisconsin card sorting test,

  • Trail making test,

  • Formulated sentences subtest of the clinical evaluation of language fundamentals,

  • Controlled oral word association test,

  • Grooved pegboard.

  • Lower than expected scores in academic achievement, memory, visual-spatial skills, sustained attention, and higher order language skills.

  • Higher than expected proportion with scores >1SD below normative values in executive functions (e.g., planning, cognitive flexibility).


Calderon et al. (24) n = 21, 7 years, d-TGA
  • Columbia Mental Maturity Scale,

  • Animal Stroop test,

  • Statue subtest from the NEPSY,

  • Tower of London,

  • Digit span,

  • Corsi block-tapping task,

  • False belief tasks (1st and 2nd order).

  • Patients’ mean IQ scores within the normal range.

  • Compared to a control group, patients with d-TGA had lower scores in executive functions (i.e., inhibition, working memory, planning) and social cognition (i.e., theory of mind).


Calderon et al. (25) n = 45, 5/7 years, d-TGA
  • Columbia Mental Maturity Scale,

  • Comprehension subtest from the NEPSY,

  • Digit span,

  • Spatial span,

  • The hand game,

  • Hearts and flowers incongruent and mixed conditions,

  • Day and night,

  • Animal Stroop test,

  • Dimensional change card sorting test.

  • Patients’ mean scores lower than controls’ mean scores in receptive language, attention, and executive functions (i.e., inhibition, cognitive flexibility).

  • Persistent impairments in cognitive inhibition and cognitive flexibility from ages 5 to 7.


Freed et al. (8) n = 82, 1.5–2 years, d-TGA BSID II
  • Most patients with scores > 1SD below normative values in cognitive, motor, and language function.


Hicks et al. (11) n = 91, 2 years, d-TGA BSID III
  • Higher than expected proportion of patients with scores >1SD or >2SD below normative values in language function.


Hövels-Gürich et al. (32) n = 77, 3–9 years, d-TGA
  • K-ABC,

  • Vocabulary subtest of the K-ABC,

  • Kiphard and Schilling body coordination test,

  • Denver developmental screening test,

  • Frostig developmental test of visual perception.

  • Patients’ mean IQ scores within the normal range.

  • Lower than expected scores in motor function, vocabulary, and acquired abilities.


Hövels-Gürich et al. (17) n = 60, 7–14 years, d-TGA
  • K-ABC,

  • Kiphard and Schilling body coordination test,

  • Oral and speech motor control test,

  • Mayo tests of speech and oral apraxia,

  • Illinois test of psycholinguistic abilities,

  • Test of auditory analysis skills.

  • Speech, motor, and developmental impairments more frequent compared to the general population.

  • Lower than expected scores in acquired abilities and language.


Hövels-Gürich et al. (42) n = 60, 7–14 years, d-TGA Achenbach child behavior checklist
  • Parent-reported psychosocial maladjustment more frequent than in the general population on all domains (i.e., internalizing, externalizing, social, and attention problems, and competences).


Karl et al. (19) n = 74, 4–14 years, d-TGA
  • WPPSI,

  • WISC III,

  • Movement Assessment Battery,

  • Achenbach child development checklist,

  • Achenbach teacher report form.

  • Patients’ mean IQ scores within the normal range.

  • Lower scores in motor function.

  • Parent- and teacher-reported psychosocial maladjustment more frequent than in a control group on domains including behavioral, speech, language, and learning ability problems.


McGrath et al. (16) n = 135, 1/8 years, d-TGA Evaluation at 1 year
  • BSID,

  • Fagan test of infant intelligence.


Evaluation at 8 years
  • WISC III,

  • WIAT.

  • Most 1-year test scores were statistically but modestly associated with 8-year test scores.

  • The majority of patients with scores >1SD below normative values at 8 years had displayed scores >1SD at 1 year.


Adolescents

Bellinger et al. (14) n = 139, 16 years, d-TGA
  • WIAT II,

  • General Memory Index of the Children’s Memory Scale,

  • Test of visual–perceptual skills,

  • Rey–Osterrieth complex figure,

  • Delis–Kaplan executive function system,

  • Behavior rating inventory of executive function (child, parent, and teacher versions),

  • Connors attention-deficit and hyperactivity disorder (parent version),

  • Reading the mind in the eyes test, revised.

  • Lower than expected scores on academic skills, visuo-spatial skills, memory, executive functions, and social cognition.

  • Higher than expected proportion of patients with scores >1SD or >2SD below normative values in academic skills, memory and visuo-spatial skills.

  • By parent reports, about 1 in 5 had attention or executive impairments in daily life.


Cassidy et al. (22) n = 139, 8/16 years, d-TGA
  • WISC III,

  • WIAT II,

  • Trail making test,

  • Test of variables of attention.

  • Processing speed associated with executive functions (i.e., working memory, inhibition, and shifting) and academic skills at 8 and 16 years.


DeMaso et al. (45) n = 139, 16 years, d-TGA
  • Schedule for affective disorders and schizophrenia for school-aged children,

  • Children’s Global Assessment Scale,

  • Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale for Children,

  • Children’s Depression Inventory,

  • Revised Children’s Manifest Anxiety Scale,

  • Child stress disorders checklist,

  • Posttraumatic Stress Diagnostic Scale,

  • Conners’ attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder rating scales,

  • Conduct Disorder Scale.

  • Patients were more likely than controls to meet criteria for a lifetime psychiatric diagnosis.

  • Higher lifetime and current prevalence of attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder.

  • Psychosocial functioning was within a pathological range for 15% of patients.

  • Parent- and self-reports identified high depressive, anxiety, and posttraumatic stress symptoms.


Heinrichs et al. (31) n = 60, 14–21 years, d-TGA
  • Hamburg-Wechsler intelligence test,

  • Analytical thinking subtests of the Leistungsprüfsytem nach Horn,

  • Mannheimer Rechtschreib test.

  • Patients’ mean IQ scores within the normal range.

  • Higher than expected proportion of patients with IQ scores ≥2.

  • Lower than expected scores on orthography.


Adults

Klouda et al. (53) Total mixed cohort, n = 48, 18–49 years
  • n = 24, moderate CHD,

  • n = 24, complex CHD (including d-TGA, n = 9).

CNS vital signs
  • Patients with critical CHD had lower than expected scores on multiple domains: psychomotor speed, processing speed, sustained and executive attention, and on the overall, neurocognitive index.


Tyagi et al. (54) Total mixed cohort, n = 310, 18–76 years
  • n = 80, d-TGA,

  • n = 81, TOF,

  • n = 65, SV anatomy,

  • n = 84, mild CHD.

  • Controlled oral word association test,

  • Grooved pegboard,

  • Rey auditory verbal learning test,

  • Stroop test,

  • Symbol digit modalities test,

  • Trail making test,

  • Wisconsin card sorting test,

  • Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale.

  • d-TGA patients scored worse than those with mild CHD on an overall neuropsychological index.

  • Proportion with scores >1.5 SD below normative values on at least 3 tests was higher in the d-TGA group compared to both the mild CHD group and the expected frequency in the general population.


van Rijen et al. (56) Total mixed cohort, n = 349, 20–46 years,
  • n = 55, d-TGA,

  • n = 72, TOF,

  • n = 37 pulmonary stenosis,

  • n = 185, mild CHD.

  • Young adult self-report,

  • Young adult behavior checklist.

  • Diagnosis of d-TGA was associated with higher risks of behavioral problems, particularly externalizing problems (e.g., intrusive and aggressive behavior).

BSID, Bayley Scales of Infant Development; CHD, congenital heart defects; d-TGA, dextro-transposition of the great arteries; IQ, intelligence quotient; K-ABC, Kaufman assessment battery for children; SV, single ventricle; TOF, tetralogy of Fallot; WIAT, Wechsler individual achievement test; WISC, Wechsler intelligence scale for children; WPPSI, Wechsler preschool and primary scale of intelligence.