Table 5.
Results summary for NRT and reproduction/development—gestational age/small for gestational age
CAF no.a | References | Comparisonb | Endpoint | Statistic (95 % CI)c |
---|---|---|---|---|
13 | Pollak et al. (2007) | Any NRT + CBT versus CBT only | Diff. in gestational age (wks) | −0.7 (–1.6 to 0.2)d |
Small for gestational age | 4.64 (0.25–84.7)e | |||
14 | Oncken et al. (2008) | Nicotine versus placebo gum | Diff. in gestational age (wks) | 0.9 (0.1–1.7)d |
16 | Coleman et al. (2012b) | Nicotine versus placebo patch | Diff. in gestational age (wks) | 0.0 (−0.2 to 0.3)f |
17 | El-Mohandes et al. (2013) | Nicotine patch + CBT versus CBT only | Diff. in gestational age (wks) | 1.0 (0.16 to 1.84)d |
18 | Berlin et al. (2014) | Nicotine versus placebo patch | Diff. in gestational age (wks) | −0.22 (−0.82 to 0.38)f |
Weighted analysis of difference in gestational age (wks) | Mean | 0.1 (−0.5 to 0.6) | ||
Heterogeneity p | p = 0.34 |
a CAF critical assessment form. All studies are clinical trials
b CBT cognitive behavioural therapy
cFor difference in gestational age the mean difference is shown, and for small for gestational age the relative risk (RR)
dUnadjusted mean difference estimated from data provided
eUnadjusted RR estimated from data provided; based on 4 exposed and 0 unexposed cases
fUnadjusted mean difference