Table 2.
Authors | Journal | Year | No. of patients | Technique | Age | Follow up | Preoperative functional measurements | Postoperative functional measurements |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
El-Azab et al. | J bone Joint Surg Am | 2015 | 93 | Gerber | 56 years (40-72) | 111,6 months (79,2-132) | 44% relative CS 30 ASES score |
71% relative CS 70 ASES score |
De casa et al. | J Orth Surg Res | 2014 | 14 | Arthroscopy assisted | 59 years (52-66) | 52 months (36-77) | 33 CS | 59 CS |
Castricini et al. | J bone Joint Surg Am | 2014 | 27 | Arthroscopy assisted | 60 years (46-67) | 27 months (24-36) | 36 CS | 74 CS |
Villacis et al. | Arthrosc Tech | 2013 | 8 | Arthroscopy assisted | 54 years (49- 60) | Mean 14 months | 63 SSI | 70 SSI |
Gerber et al. | J bone Joint Surg Am | 2013 | 45 | Gerber | 56 years (37-67) | 146.6 months (122-184) | 47,3 CS 29% SSV |
63,8 CS 70,1% SSV |
Debeer et al. | Acta Orthop Belg | 2010 | 26 | Gerber | 56,5 years (42-66) | 43,3 months (13-124) | 39 CS | 60 CS |
Weening et al. | Int Orthop | 2010 | 16 | Gerber | 60 years (49-71) | 26 months (7-73) | 32,5 CS | 50,3 CS |
Moursy et al. | J bone Joint Surg Am | 2009 | 42 | Gerber (n =22) Bone chip (n=20) |
58 years (50-75) | Mean 47 months | 43,4 (Gerber technique) 40,2 (bone chip) |
64,8 ASES score 74,2 ASES score |
Nové – Josserand et al. | Orthop Traumatol Surg Res | 2009 | 26 | Gerber | 55,5 years (36-71) | 34 months (24-62) | 50 CS | 74 CS |
Habermayer et al. | J bone Joint Surg Br | 2006 | 14 | Single incision | 61 years (47- 76) | 32 months (19-42) | 46,5 CS | 74,6 CS |
Gerber et al. | J bone Joint Surg Am | 2006 | 69 | Gerber | 61 years (49- 72) | 59 months (24 – 126) | 55% CS | 73% CS |
Ianotti et al. | J bone Joint Surg Am | 2006 | 20 | Gerber | 54,8 years (44-68) | 39 months (24- 85) | 40 PENN score | 66 PENN score |
Miniaci et al. | J bone Joint Surg Am | 1999 | 17 | Gerber | 55 years (32-77) | 51 months (24-72) | 6,8 UCLA score | 16,4 UCLA score |
Aoki et al. | J bone Joint Surg Br | 1996 | 12 | Gerber | 64 years (48- 82) | 35,6 months (26-42) | 11,8 UCLA score | 28 UCLA score |