Skip to main content
. 2017 Mar 31;7:45412. doi: 10.1038/srep45412

Table 1. Linear mixed models of phenological variables in relation to sex and methylation at Clock poly-Q or 5′-UTR.

  poly-Q 5′-UTR
χ21 F df P Coefficient (SE) χ21 F df P Coefficient (SE)
Departure date from wintering area
Year 0.00         0.00a        
Area 0.00         0.00a        
Sex   10.79 1,62 0.002     0.81a 1,61 0.371  
Methylation   17.43 1,62 <0.001     0.13a 1,61 0.717  
Sex × Methylation   10.20 1,62 0.002     1.54 1,60 0.219  
Males         −0.29 (0.24)         0.57 (0.56)
Females         −2.15 (0.53)***         −0.58 (0.75)
Arrival date to breeding site
Year 9.30**         5.40a,*        
Area 3.00         3.70a        
Sex   4.38 1,57 0.041     2.16a 1,57 0.147  
Methylation   17.64 1,57 <0.001     0.60a 1,57 0.440  
Sex × Methylation   3.74 1,57 0.058     0.00 1,56 0.997  
Males         −0.59 (0.22)**         −0.31 (0.52)
Females         −1.61 (0.50)**         −0.31 (0.67)
Breeding date
Year 7.70**         7.70a,**        
Area 4.30*         4.30a,*        
Sex   3.67 1,77 0.059     6.39a 1,78 0.014  
Methylation   4.97 1,77 0.029     2.65a 1,78 0.108  
Sex × Methylation   4.60 1,77 0.035     1.45 1,77 0.232  
Males         −0.02 (0.19)         −0.95 (0.47)
Females         −0.97 (0.40)*         0.14 (0.77)

*0.05 > P > 0.01; **0.01 ≥ P ≥ 0.001; ***P < 0.001. aEstimated from a model excluding the interaction term. χ21: likelihood ratio test for the random effect of year or area. Methylation (percentage of 5-methyl-cytosine) is included as a covariate. Year and area are included as random factors; sex as a fixed-effect factor. Sample sizes for the analyses of poly-Q were as follows (males, females): departure date from wintering area: 49, 20; arrival date to breeding site: 45, 19; breeding date: 58, 26. The corresponding values for the analyses of 5′-UTR were: 48, 19; 45, 18; 59, 25; 61, 25.