Skip to main content
. 2017 Mar 24;205(4):1353–1364. doi: 10.1534/genetics.116.196956

Table 1. Abridged list of different propositions for a definition of the gene in the current era given by different authors.

Essential Content or Character of the Proposition Classification Author(s)
These three first operational definitions give criteria, formal, experimental and computational, for identifying genes in the DNA sequences of genomes, annotation of genomes, and for specifying the function of genes Operational Snyder and Gerstein (2003)
Operational Pesole (2008)
Operational Stadler et al. (2009)
In these three following definitions, classified as molecular, the structural and the functional gene are conceptually distinguished and separated Molecular Scherrer and Jost (2007)
Molecular Keller and Harel (2007)
Molecular Burian (2004)
In this definition two gene concepts, “gene-P (preformationist)” and “gene-D (developmental)”, are distinguished Complex Moss (2003)
This definition presents three different concepts of the gene: instrumental, nominal and postgenomic Complex Griffiths and Stotz (2006)
This definition aims at to define the gene on the basis of its products and separates it from DNA A new kind of redefinition Waters (1994)