Table I. Criteria Used for Evaluating Strength of Evidence for a Positive Association Between Styrene Exposure and NMRD-Related Morbidity or Mortality.
Strong (+++) | Intermediate (++) | Suggestive (+) | |
---|---|---|---|
Cross-sectional studies | (1) Inclusion of styrene-exposed and comparison groups,a AND | (1) Inclusion of styrene-exposed and comparison groups,a AND | (1) Inclusion of styrene-exposed and comparison groupsa and non-statistically significantb higher prevalence for ≥1 respiratory symptom or ≥1 NMRD, or airflow limitation on spirometry, OR |
(2) exposure group had statistically significantb higher prevalence for ≥1 respiratory symptom or NMRD, AND | (2) exposure group had statistically significantb higher prevalence for ≥1 respiratory symptom or ≥1 NMRD, or airflow limitation on spirometry | (2) no comparison groupa and the presence of exposed workers with respiratory symptoms or ≥1 NMRD, or airflow limitation on spirometry | |
(3) exposure group had statistically significant higher prevalenceb for airflow limitation on spirometry | |||
Mortality studies | (1) Analysis of workers by level of styrene exposure, AND | All workers or a subset of workers had statistically significantb higher SMR for ≥1 NMRD | All workers or a subset of workers had non-statistically significantb higher SMR for ≥1 NMRD |
(2) workers with high exposure had statistically significantb higher SMR for ≥1 NMRD |
NMRD, non-malignant respiratory disease; SMR, standardized mortality ratio.
Comparison groups determined by environmental exposure data at factories and include groups with either no or comparatively low styrene exposure.
P < 0.05.