Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2018 Apr 1.
Published in final edited form as: Clin Trials. 2016 Nov 15;14(2):180–186. doi: 10.1177/1740774516677276

Table 2. Exception From Informed Consent Acceptance by Participant Clinical Baseline Characteristics and Outcomes (NTotal = 74).

Patient Outcomes General trial inclusion Personal EFIC enrollment General EFIC enrollment
NAgree (% Agree) p NAgree (% Agree) p NAgree (% Agree) p
Overall 61 (82) 57 (77) 54 (73)

Initial injury severity based on GCS score x
 Severe 8 (89) 0.457a 9 (100) 0.040a 9 (100) 0.034a
 Moderate-Severe 35 (83) 33 (79) 31 (74)
 Moderate 18 (78) 15 (65) 14 (61)
Initial injury severity based on ISS score y
 1-15: Less severe 10 (83) 1.000b,c 11 (92) 0.274b 9 (75) 1.000b,c
 16-75: More severe 51 (82) 46 (74) 45 (73)
6-month outcome based on GOS-E score* z
 1-2: Death/Vegetative state 4 (100) 0.263a 2 (50) 0.066a 3 (75) 0.575a
 3-4: Severe disability 13 (68) 13 (68) 13 (68)
 5-6: Moderate disability 22 (81) 21 (78) 19 (70)
 7-8: Good recovery 21 (91) 20 (87) 18 (78)
6-month outcome relative to initial injury severity*
 Favorable 38 (86) 0.251d 39 (89) 0.003d 35 (80) 0.101d
 Unfavorable 22 (76) 17 (59) 18 (62)

EFIC= exception from informed consent.

a

Simple logistic regression

b

Fisher's exact test

c

Two-sided p value for Fisher exact test is 1.000 due to rounding and corresponds to the probability of observing the given difference or any more extreme differences with the same fixed marginal

d

Chi-Square test

*

6-month GOS-E score not available for 1 participant, n=73

x

Index Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS), defined as the highest reliable GCS score documented prior to randomization, ranges from 3 to 15. Lower scores indicate lower level of consciousness. The overall GCS score is the sum of scores given for motor (range 1-6), verbal, and eye-opening components.

y

The Injury Severity Score ranges from 0 to 75. Higher scores suggest greater injury severity.

z

An Extended Glasgow Outcome Scale (GOS-E) score of 1 indicates death, and 2, vegetative state; 3 or 4 severe disability; 5 or 6 moderate disability; and 7 or 8 good recovery.