Table 4. Sensitivities and specificities corresponding to the suggested risk thresholds for the investigated risk prediction models and the National Lung Screening Trial criteria for 6-y lung cancer incidence in the Prostate, Lung, Colorectal and Ovarian Cancer Screening Trial chest radiography arm.
Measure | NLST criteria | Bach model | LLP model | Simplified LLP model | PLCOm2012 model | Simplified PLCOm2012 model | TSCE incidence model | Knoke model | TSCE CPS lung cancer death model | TSCE NHS/HPFS lung cancer death model |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Sensitivity | 71.4% (68.0%–74.6%) | 80.0% (76.9%–82.8%) | 73.9% (70.6%–77.0%) | 74.0% (70.7%–77.1%) | 83.0% (80.2%–85.6%) | 80.0% (76.9%–82.8%) | 79.8% (76.8%–82.6%) | 78.1% (75.0%–81.0%) | 72.7% (69.3%–75.8%) | 78.5% (75.4%–81.4%) |
Specificity | 62.2% (61.7%–62.7%) | 62.4% (61.9%–62.8%) | 62.2% (61.8%–62.7%) | 62.6% (62.1%–63.1%) | 62.5% (61.9%–62.8%) | 62.4% (61.9%–62.8%) | 62.3% (61.9%–62.8%) | 62.2% (61.7%–62.7%) | 62.2% (61.7%–62.7%) | 62.3% (61.8%–62.8%) |
Data given as percent (95% confidence interval).
CPS, Cancer Prevention Study; HPFS, Health Professionals Follow-up Study; LLP, Liverpool Lung Project; NHS, Nurses’ Health Study; NLST, National Lung Screening Trial; TSCE, Two-Stage Clonal Expansion.