Table 1.
Type | Extrusion (FDM, FFF, TPE) | Light Polymerization (SLA, DLP, CLIP) | Powder Bed (Binder Jet) | Powder Bed (Heat/ Laser Melting/ Sintering) | Lamination |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Method | Material (often molten plastic filament) is extruded through a nozzle that follows a path in x and y dimensions | Liquid resin is cured with laser light or with a projected image | Liquid binding material is selectively deposited across a layer of powdered substrate | Powdered material is selectively sintered or melted with a laser or electron beam | Layers of paper or film are adhered together and cut to shape with a knife or laser; may incorporate standard inkjet printing methods |
Layer height | 0.050–0.400 | 0.010–0.200 | ~0.100a | ~0.100a | ~0.100a |
Materials | Various thermoplastics (ABS, PLA, PVA, HIPS, PC, nylon, etc.); molten glass or sugar, clay, wax, edible materials (chocolate, icing, pancake batter, etc.) | Various acrylic photopolymers; properties can be rigid, flexible, castable, or transparent | Powdered plaster, sugar | Almost any metal alloy, titanium, thermoplastic, or ceramic powder | Paper, metal foil, plastic film |
Printer cost | Start as low as $350 for small-volume printers and printer kits; can cost upward of $4000 | Desktop models $2500+; commercial printers can range from $20,000 to upward of $200,000 | $15,000–$30,000 | Typically $200,000+ | $30,000+ |
Support structures required? | Dependent on materials and geometry; dissolvable supports can be used | Dependent on printer type and model geometry | No | No | No |
Pros | Wide variety of affordable materials; with two or more extruders, can print in multiple colors and materials, print dissolvable support structures | Can achieve very fine detail and complexity, quiet operation | Capable of print at high resolution with full color; does not require support structures | Strong, durable parts; does not require support structures | Capable of printing in full color; does not require support structures |
Cons | Complex geometries and overhangs require support material; limiting for single-extruder printers | Materials are limited and typically less durable consumables; messy postprocessing | Higher material cost; messy postprocessing; relatively fragile | Printer and material costs are expensive, highly specialized | Limitations in 3D geometry, better for solid structures |
ABS, acrylonitrile butadiene styrene; CLIP, continuous liquid interface production; DLP, digital light processing; FDM, fused deposition modeling; FFF, fused filament fabrication; HIPS, high-impact polystyrene; PC, polycarbonate; PLA, polylactic acid; PVA, polyvinyl alcohol; SLA, stereolithography; TPE, thermoplastic extrusion.
Resolution may be dependent on the thickness of the powder substrate or laminated material.