Table 4.
Year | Treatments | Grain yield (kg ha−1) | Biomass yield (kg ha−1) | HI | ET (mm) | WUE (kg ha−1 mm−1) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2013 | FCM | 16200a | 24422ab | 0.67a | 522.02a | 31.09a |
FLM | 12957c | 22769b | 0.57b | 509.66a | 25.42b | |
FLSM | 15896a | 25271a | 0.63ab | 505.38a | 31.11a | |
PM | 14976b | 25031ab | 0.60ab | 450.17b | 33.27a | |
CK | 13470c | 23432ab | 0.58b | 490.91a | 27.44b | |
2014 | FCM | 13509a | 24359ab | 0.46d | 475.86bc | 28.39a |
FLM | 13421a | 23761ab | 0.57b | 478.90ab | 28.12a | |
FLSM | 13671a | 26242a | 0.53bc | 496.12ab | 27.55a | |
PM | 11169b | 20986bc | 0.64a | 500.59a | 22.32b | |
CK | 9594b | 19917c | 0.48cd | 457.06c | 21.01b |
CK, the control, conventional flat planting without plastic film mulch; PM, flat planting with maize rows (60 cm spacing) on plastic film mulch (70 cm wide); FCM, furrow planting of maize (60 cm spacing), separated by consecutive plastic film-mulched ridges (each 50 cm wide and 15 cm tall); FLSM, furrow planting of maize (60 cm spacing), separated by alternating large and small plastic film-mulched ridges (large ridges: 70 cm wide and 15 cm tall, small ridges 50 cm wide and 10 cm tall); FLM, furrow-flat planting of maize (60 cm spacing) with a large plastic film-mulched ridge (60 cm wide and 15 cm tall) alternating with a flat plastic film-mulched space (60 cm wide). Values followed by the different lowercase letter in the same row indicate significant differences among treatments for each year (Tukey HSD test, p < 0.05).