Skip to main content
. 2017 Apr 5;17:99. doi: 10.1186/s12887-017-0850-8

Table 4.

Sensitivity analysis for imputation based on the MAR versus MNAR assumption high malaria prevalence strata

Variables with no missing data 1–3 variables with missing data 4 or more variables with missing data Mantel Haenszel estimates weighted across missing patterns (MNAR) Model 3 - Mulitvariable model for associations with mortality on imputed data including interaction terms for malaria endemicity (MAR)
OR (95% CI) OR (95% CI) OR (95% CI) OR (95% CI) OR (95% CI)
Age groupa
2_6 months and high malaria prevalence ref ref ref ref ref
7 _11 months in high malaria prevalence 0·43(0·29–0·63) 0·48(0·27–0·86) 0·47(0·29–0·77) 0·48(0·28–0·81) 0·43(0·29–0·63)
12_59 months in high malaria prevalence 0·37(0·27–0·5) 0·53(0·34–0·84) 0·35(0·23–0·54) 0·37(0·26–0·51) 0·37(0·27–0·50)
7 _11 months in Low malaria prevalence 0·34(0·15–0·75) 0·54(0·17–1·68) 0·09(0·02–0·35) 0·41(0·14–1·21) 0·33(0·19–0·57)
12_59 months in Low malaria prevalence 0·29(·14-·62) 0·59(0·21–1·72) 0·07(0·02–0·25) 0·39(0·15–1·07) 0·29(0·17–0·49)
Child sex
Female ref ref ref ref ref
Male 0·67(0·57–0·79) 0·7(0·56–0·88) 0·82(0·63–1·05) 0·71(0·58–0·87) 0·67(0·57–0·79)
WAZ scorea
0 or > = 1 SD in high malaria prevalence ref ref ref ref ref
Minus 1 SD in high malaria prevalence 1·19(0·85–1·67) 1·96(1·25–3·09) 1·54(0·91–2·58) 1·46(0·96–2·23) 1·19(0·85–1·67)
Minus 2 SD in high malaria prevalence 1·50(1·03–2·17) 1·43(0·81–2·54) 0·89(0·47–1·7) 1·29(0·79–2·12) 1·50(1·03–2·17)
Minus 3 SD in high malaria prevalence 3·01(2·09–4·35) 5·23(3·21–8·54) 1·76(0·95–3·25) 3·20(2·10–4·91) 3·01(2·09–4·35)
Minus 1 SD in Low malaria prevalence 0·93(·45–1·94) 2·20(0·8–6·01) 0·29(0·07–1·18) 1·20(0·50–2·95) 1·06(0·61–1·82)
Minus 2 SD in Low malaria prevalence 1·17(·56–2·44) 1·61(0·55–4·69) 0·17(·04–0·67) 1·18(0·50–2·83) 0·88(0·52–1·51)
Minus 3 SD in Low malaria prevalence 2·36(1·13–4·94) 5·85(2·07–16·53) 0·33(0·08–1·33) 3·06(1·26–7·65) 2·09(1·22–3·56)
Number of comorbidities
0 ref ref ref ref ref
1 1·08(0·86–1·37) 1·21(0·89–1·65) 0·78(0·57–1·08) 0·98(0·75–1·28) 1·08(0·86–1·37)
2 1·27(0·98–1·64) 1·26(0·89–1·79) 0·67(0·45–0·99) 1·19(0·88–1·62) 1·27(0·98–1·64)
> = 3 1·68(1·25–2·25) 1·22(0·78–1·89) 0·92(0·56–1·53) 1·20(0·80–1·82) 1·68(1·25–2·25)
History of fever
No ref ref ref ref ref
Yes 0·76(0·62–0·92) 0·79(0·6–1·05) 0·76(0·5–1·17) 0·77(0·59–1·00) 0·76(0·62–0·92)
History of diarrhoea
No ref ref ref ref ref
Yes 1·45(1·2–1·76) 1·05(0·8–1·39) 1·36(0·92–2) 1·32(1·02–1·71) 1·45(1·20–1·76)
convulsions
No ref ref ref ref ref
Yes 1·35(1·09–1·67) 1·73(1·29–2·33) 1·67(1·13–2·47) 1·53(1·15–2·06) 1·35(1·09–1·67)
Vomitting everything
No ref ref ref ref ref
Yes 1·03(0·86–1·24) 1·07(0·81–1·41) 1·11(0·79–1·57) 1·06(0·83–1·36) 1·03(0·86–1·24)
Indrawing
No ref ref ref ref ref
Yes 2·48(2·08–2·96) 2·91(2·27–3·73) 2·58(1·82–3·64) 2·61(2·07–3·31) 2·48(2·08–2·96)
Pallor
None ref ref ref ref ref
Some/severe 2·32(1·92–2·81) 2·22(1·71–2·87) 1·98(1·45–2·69) 2·19(1·73–2·79) 2·32(1·92–2·81)
Central cyanosis
No ref ref ref ref ref
Yes 3·25(1·91–5·53) 2·37(1·1–5·11) 2·3(0·52–10·21) 2·77(1·36–6·33) 3·25(1·91–5·53)
AVPU
Alert ref ref ref ref ref
Not alert (VPU) 3·95(3·16–4·95) 3·94(2·87–5·41) 4·42(2·53–7·73) 4·06(2·93–5·73) 3·95(3·16–4·95)
Ability to drinka
Ability to drink no in high malaria prevalence ref ref ref ref ref
Ability to drink yes in high malaria prevalence 0·65(0·48–0·87) 0·76(0·5–1·15) 0·58(0·33–1·01) 0·66(0·45–0·98) 0·65(0·48–0·87)
Ability to drink yes in Low malaria prevalence 0·51(0·24–1·08) 0·85(0·31–2·34) 0·11(0·02–0·48) 0·57(0·23–1·43) 0·44(0·25–0·78)
Stiff necka
Stiff neck no in high malaria prevalence ref ref ref ref ref
Stiff neck yes in high malaria prevalence 3·92(2·15–7·16) 2·24(0·94–5·31) 0·81(0·28–2·31) 2·70(1·36–5·49) 3·92(2·15–7·16)
Stiff neck yes in low malaria prevalence 3·07(1·31–7·17) 2·51(0·72–8·78) 0·15(0·03–0·76) 2·52(0·97–6·81) 1·53(0·81–2·90)
Skin pinch
Immediate ref ref ref ref ref
1–2 s 1·17(0·94–1·44) 1·5(1·12–2·02) 1·26(0·83–1·93) 1·29(0·99–1·69) 1·17(0·94–1·44)
> 2 s 1·47(1·09–1·98) 2·54(1·67–3·86) 2·28(1·16–4·46) 1·96(1·25–3·15) 1·47(1·09–1·98)
Capillary refill time
<=2 scs ref ref ref ref ref
>3 s 1·68(1·32–2·13) 1·08(0·67–1·76) 1·41(0·85–2·32) 1·39(0·95–2·07) 1·68(1·32–2·13)
Indeterminate 1·83(1·12–2·99) 1·01(0·43–2·35) na 1·27(0·51–1·75) 1·83(1·12–2·99)
Sunken eyes
No ref ref ref ref ref
Yes 1·24(1–1·55) 0·96(0·69–1·34) 1·04(0·74–1·46) 1·11(0·84–1·47) 1·24(1·00–1·55)
Jaundice
None ref ref ref ref ref
Moderate/severe 1·64(1·01–2·65) 1·72(0·96–3·1) 1·78(0·97–3·27) 1·71(0·98–2·98) 1·64(1·01–2·65)
Severe wastinga
Severe wasting no in high malaria prevalence ref ref ref ref ref
Severe wasting yes in high malaria prevalence 2·54(1·7–3·82) 2·41(1·27–4·58) 2·39(1·23–4·62) 2·46(1·44–4·26) 2·54(1·70–3·82)
Severe wasting yes in low malaria prevalence 2·45(1·17–5·13) 3·27(1·09–9·79) 0·32(0·08–1·27) 2·29(0·94–5·79) 1·66(0·95–2·87)
Oedema of malnutritiona
Oedema none in high malaria prevalence ref ref ref ref ref
Oedema mild/moderate in high malaria prevalence 3·13(1·95–5·02) 2·92(1·44–5·92) 1·66(0·67–4·13) 2·78(1·55–5·10) 3·13(1·95–5·02)
Oedema mild/moderate in Low malaria prevalence 1·94(0·96–3·90) 2·70(0·98–7·47) 0·45(0·11–1·91) 2·02(0·88–4·81) 1·88(1·08–3·25)
Malaria endemicity
High ref ref ref ref ref
Low 0·78(0·43–1·42) 1·12(0·49–2·53) 0·19(0·06–0·63) 0·76(0·38–1·58) 0·78(0·43–1·42)

Model 3 stratified by number of missing variables and weighted estimates across the missing patterns (assumes MNAR) compared to pooled model 3 data (assumes MAR)

aVariables with significant interactions with malaria endemicity