Table 4.
Variables with no missing data | 1–3 variables with missing data | 4 or more variables with missing data | Mantel Haenszel estimates weighted across missing patterns (MNAR) | Model 3 - Mulitvariable model for associations with mortality on imputed data including interaction terms for malaria endemicity (MAR) | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
OR (95% CI) | OR (95% CI) | OR (95% CI) | OR (95% CI) | OR (95% CI) | ||
Age groupa | ||||||
2_6 months and high malaria prevalence | ref | ref | ref | ref | ref | |
7 _11 months in high malaria prevalence | 0·43(0·29–0·63) | 0·48(0·27–0·86) | 0·47(0·29–0·77) | 0·48(0·28–0·81) | 0·43(0·29–0·63) | |
12_59 months in high malaria prevalence | 0·37(0·27–0·5) | 0·53(0·34–0·84) | 0·35(0·23–0·54) | 0·37(0·26–0·51) | 0·37(0·27–0·50) | |
7 _11 months in Low malaria prevalence | 0·34(0·15–0·75) | 0·54(0·17–1·68) | 0·09(0·02–0·35) | 0·41(0·14–1·21) | 0·33(0·19–0·57) | |
12_59 months in Low malaria prevalence | 0·29(·14-·62) | 0·59(0·21–1·72) | 0·07(0·02–0·25) | 0·39(0·15–1·07) | 0·29(0·17–0·49) | |
Child sex | ||||||
Female | ref | ref | ref | ref | ref | |
Male | 0·67(0·57–0·79) | 0·7(0·56–0·88) | 0·82(0·63–1·05) | 0·71(0·58–0·87) | 0·67(0·57–0·79) | |
WAZ scorea | ||||||
0 or > = 1 SD in high malaria prevalence | ref | ref | ref | ref | ref | |
Minus 1 SD in high malaria prevalence | 1·19(0·85–1·67) | 1·96(1·25–3·09) | 1·54(0·91–2·58) | 1·46(0·96–2·23) | 1·19(0·85–1·67) | |
Minus 2 SD in high malaria prevalence | 1·50(1·03–2·17) | 1·43(0·81–2·54) | 0·89(0·47–1·7) | 1·29(0·79–2·12) | 1·50(1·03–2·17) | |
Minus 3 SD in high malaria prevalence | 3·01(2·09–4·35) | 5·23(3·21–8·54) | 1·76(0·95–3·25) | 3·20(2·10–4·91) | 3·01(2·09–4·35) | |
Minus 1 SD in Low malaria prevalence | 0·93(·45–1·94) | 2·20(0·8–6·01) | 0·29(0·07–1·18) | 1·20(0·50–2·95) | 1·06(0·61–1·82) | |
Minus 2 SD in Low malaria prevalence | 1·17(·56–2·44) | 1·61(0·55–4·69) | 0·17(·04–0·67) | 1·18(0·50–2·83) | 0·88(0·52–1·51) | |
Minus 3 SD in Low malaria prevalence | 2·36(1·13–4·94) | 5·85(2·07–16·53) | 0·33(0·08–1·33) | 3·06(1·26–7·65) | 2·09(1·22–3·56) | |
Number of comorbidities | ||||||
0 | ref | ref | ref | ref | ref | |
1 | 1·08(0·86–1·37) | 1·21(0·89–1·65) | 0·78(0·57–1·08) | 0·98(0·75–1·28) | 1·08(0·86–1·37) | |
2 | 1·27(0·98–1·64) | 1·26(0·89–1·79) | 0·67(0·45–0·99) | 1·19(0·88–1·62) | 1·27(0·98–1·64) | |
> = 3 | 1·68(1·25–2·25) | 1·22(0·78–1·89) | 0·92(0·56–1·53) | 1·20(0·80–1·82) | 1·68(1·25–2·25) | |
History of fever | ||||||
No | ref | ref | ref | ref | ref | |
Yes | 0·76(0·62–0·92) | 0·79(0·6–1·05) | 0·76(0·5–1·17) | 0·77(0·59–1·00) | 0·76(0·62–0·92) | |
History of diarrhoea | ||||||
No | ref | ref | ref | ref | ref | |
Yes | 1·45(1·2–1·76) | 1·05(0·8–1·39) | 1·36(0·92–2) | 1·32(1·02–1·71) | 1·45(1·20–1·76) | |
convulsions | ||||||
No | ref | ref | ref | ref | ref | |
Yes | 1·35(1·09–1·67) | 1·73(1·29–2·33) | 1·67(1·13–2·47) | 1·53(1·15–2·06) | 1·35(1·09–1·67) | |
Vomitting everything | ||||||
No | ref | ref | ref | ref | ref | |
Yes | 1·03(0·86–1·24) | 1·07(0·81–1·41) | 1·11(0·79–1·57) | 1·06(0·83–1·36) | 1·03(0·86–1·24) | |
Indrawing | ||||||
No | ref | ref | ref | ref | ref | |
Yes | 2·48(2·08–2·96) | 2·91(2·27–3·73) | 2·58(1·82–3·64) | 2·61(2·07–3·31) | 2·48(2·08–2·96) | |
Pallor | ||||||
None | ref | ref | ref | ref | ref | |
Some/severe | 2·32(1·92–2·81) | 2·22(1·71–2·87) | 1·98(1·45–2·69) | 2·19(1·73–2·79) | 2·32(1·92–2·81) | |
Central cyanosis | ||||||
No | ref | ref | ref | ref | ref | |
Yes | 3·25(1·91–5·53) | 2·37(1·1–5·11) | 2·3(0·52–10·21) | 2·77(1·36–6·33) | 3·25(1·91–5·53) | |
AVPU | ||||||
Alert | ref | ref | ref | ref | ref | |
Not alert (VPU) | 3·95(3·16–4·95) | 3·94(2·87–5·41) | 4·42(2·53–7·73) | 4·06(2·93–5·73) | 3·95(3·16–4·95) | |
Ability to drinka | ||||||
Ability to drink no in high malaria prevalence | ref | ref | ref | ref | ref | |
Ability to drink yes in high malaria prevalence | 0·65(0·48–0·87) | 0·76(0·5–1·15) | 0·58(0·33–1·01) | 0·66(0·45–0·98) | 0·65(0·48–0·87) | |
Ability to drink yes in Low malaria prevalence | 0·51(0·24–1·08) | 0·85(0·31–2·34) | 0·11(0·02–0·48) | 0·57(0·23–1·43) | 0·44(0·25–0·78) | |
Stiff necka | ||||||
Stiff neck no in high malaria prevalence | ref | ref | ref | ref | ref | |
Stiff neck yes in high malaria prevalence | 3·92(2·15–7·16) | 2·24(0·94–5·31) | 0·81(0·28–2·31) | 2·70(1·36–5·49) | 3·92(2·15–7·16) | |
Stiff neck yes in low malaria prevalence | 3·07(1·31–7·17) | 2·51(0·72–8·78) | 0·15(0·03–0·76) | 2·52(0·97–6·81) | 1·53(0·81–2·90) | |
Skin pinch | ||||||
Immediate | ref | ref | ref | ref | ref | |
1–2 s | 1·17(0·94–1·44) | 1·5(1·12–2·02) | 1·26(0·83–1·93) | 1·29(0·99–1·69) | 1·17(0·94–1·44) | |
> 2 s | 1·47(1·09–1·98) | 2·54(1·67–3·86) | 2·28(1·16–4·46) | 1·96(1·25–3·15) | 1·47(1·09–1·98) | |
Capillary refill time | ||||||
<=2 scs | ref | ref | ref | ref | ref | |
>3 s | 1·68(1·32–2·13) | 1·08(0·67–1·76) | 1·41(0·85–2·32) | 1·39(0·95–2·07) | 1·68(1·32–2·13) | |
Indeterminate | 1·83(1·12–2·99) | 1·01(0·43–2·35) | na | 1·27(0·51–1·75) | 1·83(1·12–2·99) | |
Sunken eyes | ||||||
No | ref | ref | ref | ref | ref | |
Yes | 1·24(1–1·55) | 0·96(0·69–1·34) | 1·04(0·74–1·46) | 1·11(0·84–1·47) | 1·24(1·00–1·55) | |
Jaundice | ||||||
None | ref | ref | ref | ref | ref | |
Moderate/severe | 1·64(1·01–2·65) | 1·72(0·96–3·1) | 1·78(0·97–3·27) | 1·71(0·98–2·98) | 1·64(1·01–2·65) | |
Severe wastinga | ||||||
Severe wasting no in high malaria prevalence | ref | ref | ref | ref | ref | |
Severe wasting yes in high malaria prevalence | 2·54(1·7–3·82) | 2·41(1·27–4·58) | 2·39(1·23–4·62) | 2·46(1·44–4·26) | 2·54(1·70–3·82) | |
Severe wasting yes in low malaria prevalence | 2·45(1·17–5·13) | 3·27(1·09–9·79) | 0·32(0·08–1·27) | 2·29(0·94–5·79) | 1·66(0·95–2·87) | |
Oedema of malnutritiona | ||||||
Oedema none in high malaria prevalence | ref | ref | ref | ref | ref | |
Oedema mild/moderate in high malaria prevalence | 3·13(1·95–5·02) | 2·92(1·44–5·92) | 1·66(0·67–4·13) | 2·78(1·55–5·10) | 3·13(1·95–5·02) | |
Oedema mild/moderate in Low malaria prevalence | 1·94(0·96–3·90) | 2·70(0·98–7·47) | 0·45(0·11–1·91) | 2·02(0·88–4·81) | 1·88(1·08–3·25) | |
Malaria endemicity | ||||||
High | ref | ref | ref | ref | ref | |
Low | 0·78(0·43–1·42) | 1·12(0·49–2·53) | 0·19(0·06–0·63) | 0·76(0·38–1·58) | 0·78(0·43–1·42) |
Model 3 stratified by number of missing variables and weighted estimates across the missing patterns (assumes MNAR) compared to pooled model 3 data (assumes MAR)
aVariables with significant interactions with malaria endemicity