Skip to main content
. 2017 Mar 23;5(3):e38. doi: 10.2196/mhealth.7185

Table 1.

Overview of included studies.

Name of intervention




Authors (Year) Number
of
articles

Study design Country Health domain Target group Type of mCDSSa
m4Changeb




McNabb et al (2015) [25] 1

Quantitative pre-post study Nigeria Maternal health Community health
(extension) workers
Decision algorithms for
antenatal care incorporating clients’ data. Includes audio clips for counseling.
DESIRE (Decision
Support and Integrated Record-Keeping)

Vedanthan et al (2015) [26] 1



Qualitative
usability and feasibility study
Kenya Hypertension Nurses and
clinical officers
Electronic records system coupled with algorithm-based decision support with alerts and reminders.
CommCare




Svoronos et al (2010) [27] 1



Qualitative and descriptive Tanzania Maternal health Community health workers Decision support protocols with reminders and
checklists. Incorporates clients’ data for pregnancy monitoring and supervisory oversight.
mPneumonia




Ginsburg et al (2015) [28] 1



Mixed methods usability and feasibility
testing
Ghana Childhood
illnesses
Lesser trained health care
professionals
Algorithms for managing childhood illnesses
integrated with “intelligent” breath counter and pulse oximeter.
Bacis (Basic Antenatal Care Information
System)

Horner et al (2013) [29] 1



Before and after cohort study South Africa Maternal health Nurses Electronic patient
information system with protocols to support providers’ action. Includes reminders, alerts, and checklists.
TB Tech

Catalani et al (2014) [30]

1



Mixed methods human-centered design Kenya Tuberculosis and HIV Clinicians Electronic patient records used to generate
individualized reminders and decision support for provider action, education, and behavior change.
txt2MEDLINE

Armstrong et al (2012) [31]

1



Pre-post utility evaluation Botswana Different
domains
Clinicians of varying cadres Two-way short messaging service (SMS) of clinical guidelines with MEDLINE query function.
ALMANACH (New
Algorithm for Managing Childhood Illness Using Mobile Technology)

Shao et al (2015a, 2015b) [32,33] 2



Controlled
noninferiority trial and
qualitative study
Tanzania Childhood
illnesses

Clinicians Diagnostic and treatment
algorithm supported by point-of-care tests and
simple clinical assessments.
eIMCI (electronic
Integrated Management of Childhood Illness)

Mitchell et al (2012, 2013);
DeRenzi et al (2008) [34-36]
3



Mixed methods before-after cluster trial Tanzania Childhood
illnesses
Health care
professionals
Electronic protocols for the Integrated Management of Childhood Illnesses (IMCI) for stepwise examination, diagnosis, and management.
Text Messaging of Malaria Guidelines

Jones et al (2012);
Zurovac et al (2011, 2012) [37-39]
3



Cluster
randomized controlled trial
Kenya Malaria Health
workers
One-way text messaging on malaria management,
supported by unique
motivational quotes.
QUALMAT (Quality of Maternal and Prenatal Care)

Blank et al (2013);
Dalaba et al (2014, 2015);
Mensah et al (2015);
Saronga et al (2015);
Zakane et al (2014);
Duysburgh et al (2016) [40-46]
7



Mixed methods quasi-
experimental study
Tanzania; Ghana; Burkina Faso Maternal and prenatal health Health
professionals (nonphysicians)
Electronic decision support algorithm with data
integration. Includes training materials and an electronic partograph.

amCDSS: mobile clinical decision support system.

bAlthough the m4Change study also used the CommCare app, we decided to treat them as independent studies because the interventions were only similar on a technical level and not part of an integrated multicountry study.