Skip to main content
. 2004 Dec 16;101(52):17946–17951. doi: 10.1073/pnas.0405919102

Table 4. Standardized reconstructed differential selection vectors describing the selection needed to produce the Homo face from the gracile australopith face, the robust australopith face from the gracile australopith face, and a later robust australopith face from an earlier one.

Nasal NA—NSL Orbit NA—FM Nasal NSL—ANS Nasal NSL—ZS Oral ANS—IS Nasal ANS—ZS Orbit FMN—ZS Orbit/Zyg ZS—FM
Homo-Gracile
    Difference vector -0.37 1.30 0.82 0.77 0.35 0.35 0.37 0.28
    vc -1.36 20.53 28.94 20.70 -2.76 -21.40 -4.75 5.55
    vh -0.30 29.38 9.69 2.77 -2.18 -13.47 -2.86 -13.37
    vg -2.77 5.57 35.54 38.54 -4.13 -37.43 -2.81 3.97
Robust-Gracile
    Difference vector 0.37 0.94 0.43 0.74 0.41 0.62 -0.12 0.68
    vc -0.65 6.93 16.43 22.85 -1.79 -11.05 -8.92 15.30
    vh -6.20 -1.37 -7.27 20.10 0.86 9.51 -16.51 30.14
    vg -1.79 3.53 14.52 20.70 -3.06 -17.67 -4.14 7.77
Boisei/Robustus-Aethiopicus
    Difference vector 0.37 0.46 -0.56 -0.05 -0.46 -0.33 -0.73 -1.24
    vc 10.52 30.22 -10.51 -17.54 0.56 3.47 -11.22 -49.88
    vh 27.29 62.82 24.26 -16.32 -4.63 -42.76 -5.72 -100.93
    vg 4.96 10.94 -11.93 -7.92 -2.74 5.75 -4.65 -17.26

Selection is relative, strongly negative and strongly positive selection are shown in bold and underlined, respectively. For each comparison, the difference vector between the two groups is given, as is the selection vector required to produce that difference, based on chimpanzee (vc), human (vh), and gorilla (vg) V/CV matrices.