Skip to main content
. 2017 Mar 7;7(5):1303–1329. doi: 10.7150/thno.18650

Table 3.

Summary of ultrasound elastography studies assessing malignancy of masses in the liver, breast, thyroid, kidney, prostate, and lymph nodes.

No. Sensitivity Specificity
Patients Lesions Malignant Technique Parameter (%) (%) Author
Liver 384 448 228 1D-TE
pSWE
__ 85 84 Ma et al., 2013
134 134 41 pSWE SWV (m/s) 83.3 77.9 Guo et al., 2015
SWV ratio 59.6 77.3
373 373 290 pSWE Stif. value 74 84 Lu et al., 2015
Stif. ratio 82 28
117 117 __ pSWE SWV (m/s) 97 66 Goya et al., 2015
140 154 112 pSWE SWV (m/s) 81.3 92.9 Zhang et al., 2015
81 62 24 pSWE SWV (m/s) no stat. dif. no stat. dif. Heide et al., 2010
75 79 36 pSWE SWV (m/s) no stat. dif. no stat. dif. Frulio et al., 2013
Breast 143 143 48 SE EI/B-mode ratio 98 87 Barr, 2015
100 114 33 SE ES 69.7 95.1 Mohey et al., 2014
370 401 155 SE ES 72.3 91.9 Zhi et al., 2012
1874 2087 667 SE SR 88 83 Sadigh et al., 2012
395 450 131 SE EI/B-mode ratio 98 72
4266 4713 __ SE ES 83 84 Gong et al., 2011
SR 88 81
201 201 116 SE SR 95 74 Fischer et al., 2011
208 251 54 SE EI/B-mode ratio 100 95 Barr, 2010
135 111 52 SE ES 86.5 89.8 Itoh et al., 2006
143 143 48 SWI SWV (m/s) 93 89 Barr, 2015
82 83 38 SWI max. stif. 94 73 Feldmann et al., 2015
2424 2584 1244 SWI max. stif. (kPa) 93 81 Chen et al., 2014
mean stif. (kPa) 94 71
Thyroid 530 639 153 SE ES and/or stif. index 92 90 Bojunga et al., 2010
676 703 217 SE ES (4 point) 65.4 58.2 Moon et al., 2012
ES (5 point) 15.7 95.3
706 912 86 SE ES 80.2 70.3 Azizi et al., 2013
446 498 126 SE ES 81 62 Trimboli et al., 2012
2147 2436 745 pSWE SWV (m/s) 80 85 Zhan et al., 2015
1451 1617 __ pSWE YM (kPa) 86.3 89.5 Dong et al., 2015
35 35 11 2D-SWE YM (kPa) 82 88 Samir et al., 2015
Kidney 60 60 36 SWI SWV (m/s) 88 54 Goya et al., 2015
42 42 12 SWI SWV (m/s) no stat. dif. no stat. dif. Guo et al., 2014
71 71 42 SE Strain Index Value 82.9 82.7 Onur, et al., 2015
47 47 19 SE SR 95 100 Tan et al.,2013
Prostate 184 1040* 129* SWI YM (kPa) 96 85 Correas et al., 2015
87 1058* 79* SWI YM (kPa) 43 80.8 Woo et al., 2014
53 318* 26* SWI YM (kPa) 96.2 96.2 Barr et al., 2012
60 703* 141** SWI YM (kPa) 80.9 69.1 Boehm et al., 2015
50 __ 33** SWI YM (kPa) 90 (PSA<20) 88 (PSA<20) Ahmad et al.,2103
93(PSA>20) 93(PSA>20)
508 __ __ SE __ 72 76 Zhang et al., 2014
229 1374* 894* SE Color pattern pattern 51 72 Brock et al., 2011
527 __ __ SE Color pattern/SI 62 79 Teng et al., 2012
2278 __ __ SE __ 71-82 60-95 Aboumarzouk et al., 2012
Lymph nodes 545 835 440 SE ES 74 90 Ying et al., 2012
SR 88 81
89 89 52 SE ES 88.4 35.1 Teng et al., 2012
SR 98.1 64.9
37 85 53 SE ES 83 100 Alam et al., 2008
50 53 23 SE SR 83 96 Paterson et al., 2012
46 55 31 2D-SWE YM (kPa) 41.9 100 Bhatia et al., 2012
100 100 57 pSWE SWV (m/s) 78.9 74.4 Cheng et al., 2016

Elasticity score (ES), Strain ratio (SR), Shear Wave Imaging (SWI), Strain Index (SI), Young's Modulus (YM), Strain Elastography (SE)

* Peripheral zone sextants

** Number of patients

No data available = '—'.