Table I.
Study ID | First author | Year | Age (range/average) | Gender (M/F) | Study sizea | Type of lung cancer | Design | Patient enrollment | Blind | Reference standard | B-value (s/mm2) | DT of ADC (mm2/s) | Field strength | Type of scanner | Refs. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Chen | 2010 | 35–76/51 | 35/21 | 56/135 | NSCLC | UN | Cons | Yes | Pathology and/or follow-up | 1,000 | UN | 1.5 T | Siemens | (14) |
2 | Nakayama | 2010 | 48–82/68 | 38/32 | 70/56 | NSCLC | Retro | UN | UN | Pathology | 1,000 | 1.54×10−3 | 1.5 T | Siemens | (20) |
3 | Nomori | 2008 | 38–82/70 | 47/41 | 88/734 | NSCLC | Pros | UN | UN | Pathology | 1,000 | 1.60×10−3 | 1.5 T | Phillips | (11) |
4 | Usuda | 2013 | 37–83/68 | 94/64 | 158/705 | Lung cancer | UN | UN | UN | Pathology | 800 | 1.70×10−3 | 1.5 T | Siemens | (18) |
5 | Xu (ELN) | 2014 | 42–78/55 | 27/15 | 42/33 | NSCLC | Pros | Cons | Yes | Pathology | 1,000 | 1.98×10−3 | 1.5 T | Phillips | (15) |
6 | Xu (NLN) | 2014 | 42–78/55 | 27/15 | 42/86 | NSCLC | Pros | Cons | Yes | Pathology | 1,000 | 2.04×10−3 | 1.5 T | Phillips | (15) |
7 | Ohno | 2011 | 61–83/73 | 136/114 | 250/270 | NSCLC | Pros | Cons | Yes | Pathology | 1,000 | 2.50×10−3 | 1.5 T | Phillips | (19) |
8 | Bai | 2013 | 27–72/59 | 16/10 | 26/62 | NSCLC | UN | UN | UN | Pathology and/or follow-up | 600 | 1.92×10−3 | 1.5 T | Phillips | (21) |
9 | He | 2013 | 33–77/58 | 27/9 | 36/206 | Lung cancer | UN | UN | UN | Pathology | 500 | 3.19×10−3 | 1.5 T | GE | (16) |
10 | Zhang | 2013 | 41–72/59 | 17/8 | 25/78 | NSCLC | UN | UN | Yes | Pathology | 800 | 2.21×10−3 | 3.0 T | Siemens | (17) |
11 | Zeng | 2012 | 48–69/58 | 35/10 | 45/68 | NSCLC | UN | UN | Yes | Pathology | 600 | 2.32×10−3 | 1.5 T | GE | (22) |
Number of enrolled patients and lymph nodes. NSCLC, non-small cell lung cancer; ELN, enlarged lymph nodes; NLN, normal-sized lymph nodes; DT, diagnostic threshold; ADC, apparent diffusion coefficient; UN, unclear; Retro, retrospective; Pros, prospective; Cons, consecutive; GE, General Electric.