Table A1.
Authors | Year | Country | Sample (Intervention) | Sample (Control) | Setting | Timing |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Brotons et al.8 | 2009 | Spain | 144 | 139 | After discharge | 12 months |
Cordisco et al.9 | 1999 | US | 30 | 51 | After discharge | 1 year |
Domingues et al.10 | 2011 | Brazil | 48 | 63 | During hospitalization | 3 months |
After discharge | ||||||
Gambetta et al.11 | 2007 | US | 158 | 124 | After discharge | 7 months |
Grundtvig et al.12 | 2011 | Norway | 1169 | N/A | After discharge | 12 months |
Hagglund et al.13 | 2015 | Sweden | 32 | 40 | After discharge | 3 months |
Hudson et al.14 | 2005 | US | 91 | N/A | After discharge | 6 months |
Linden et al.15 | 2014 | US | 128 | 129 | During hospitalization | 30, 90 days |
After discharge | ||||||
Bailón et al.16 | 2007 | Spain | 51 | 131 | During discharge | 90 days |
Miller & Cox17 | 2005 | US | 68 | N/A | After discharge | 90 days, 1 year |
Stewart et al.18 | 1998 | Australia | 49 | 48 | After discharge | 6 months |
Belardinelli et al.19 | 1999 | US | 50 | 49 | After discharge | 14 months |
Dracup et al.20 | 2007 | US | 86 | 87 | After discharge | 3, 6, 12 months |
Evangelista et al.21 | 2006 | US | 48 | 51 | After discharge | 6 months |
Zeitler et al.22 | 2015 | US | 1159 | 1172 | After discharge | Every 3 months for 2 years |
Heisler et al.23 | 2013 | US | 135 | 131 | During hospitalization | 12 months |
After discharge | ||||||
Li et al.24 | 2012 | US | 202 | 205 | During hospitalization | 60 days |
Dekker et al.25 | 2012 | US | 21 | 20 | During hospitalization | 3 months |
After discharge | ||||||
Jayadevappa et al.26 | 2006 | US | 13 | 10 | After discharge | 6 months |
Albert et al.27 | 2013 | US | 20 | 26 | After discharge | 60 days |
Parrinello et al.28 | 2009 | Italy | A=87 | N/A | After discharge | 12 months |
B=86 | ||||||
Paterna et al.29 | 2009 | Italy | A=52, B=51, C=51, D=51, E=52, F=50, G=52, H=51 | N/A | After discharge | 6 months |
Kashem et al.30 | 2008 | US | 24 | 24 | After discharge | 12 months |
Witham et al.31 | 2005 | UK | 41 | 41 | After discharge | 6 months |
Bull et al.32 | 2000 | US | 40 | 71 | During hospitalization | 2 weeks, 2 months |
After discharge | ||||||
Cline et al.33 | 1998 | Sweden | 80 | 110 | During hospitalization | 12 months |
After discharge | ||||||
Saleh et al.34 | 2012 | US | 173 | 160 | During discharge | 12 months |
After discharge | ||||||
Wu et al.35 | 2012 | US | A=27 | 28 | After discharge | 9 months |
B=27 | ||||||
Ekman et al.36 | 2012 | Sweden | 125 | 123 | During hospitalization | 6 months |
Aldamiz-Echevarria Iraúrgui et al.37 | 2007 | Spain | 137 | 142 | After discharge | 12 months |
Benatar et al.38 | 2003 | US | 108 | 108 | After discharge | 3 months |
Brandon et al.39 | 2009 | US | 10 | 10 | After discharge | 12 weeks |
Chen et al.40 | 2010 | Taiwan | 275 | 275 | After discharge | 6 months |
DeWalt et al.41 | 2006 | US | 59 | 64 | After discharge | 12 months |
Dunagan et al.42 | 2005 | US | 76 | 75 | After discharge | 6, 12 months |
Falces et al.43 | 2008 | Spain | 53 | 50 | During discharge | 6, 12 months |
Gattis et al.44 | 1999 | US | 90 | 91 | After discharge | 2, 12, 24 weeks |
Giordano et al.45 | 2009 | Italy | 230 | 230 | During hospitalization | 12 months |
After discharge | ||||||
Goldberg et al.46 | 2003 | US | 138 | 142 | During discharge | 6 months |
After discharge | ||||||
Ho et al.47 | 2007 | Taiwan | 247 | N/A | After discharge | 139 ± 96 days |
Jaarsma et al.48 | 2008 | Netherlands | A=340 | 339 | After discharge | 18 months |
B=344 | ||||||
Jurgens et al.49 | 2013 | US | 48 | 51 | During discharge | 90 days |
After discharge | ||||||
Korajkic et al.50 | 2011 | Australia | 35 | 35 | After discharge | 3 months |
Koelling et al.51 | 2005 | US | 107 | 116 | During discharge | 180 days |
Lee et al.52 | 2013 | US | 23 | 21 | After discharge | 3 months |
McDonald et al.53 | 2002 | Ireland | 51 | 47 | During hospitalization | 3 months |
After discharge | ||||||
Mejhert et al.54 | 2004 | Sweden | 103 | 105 | After discharge | 18 months |
Piepoli et al.55 | 2006 | Italy | 509 | N/A | After discharge | 12 months |
Roig et al.56 | 2006 | Spain | 61 | N/A | After discharge | 11±10 months |
Roth et al.57 | 2004 | Israel | 118 | N/A | After discharge | 12 months |
Sales et al.58 | 2013 | US | 70 | 67 | During hospitalization | 30 days |
After discharge | ||||||
Sethares & Elliott59 | 2004 | US | 33 | 37 | During hospitalization | 3 months |
After discharge | ||||||
Shao & Yeh60 | 2010 | Taiwan, China | 93 | N/A | After discharge | 1 month |
Sisk et al.61 | 2006 | US | 203 | 203 | After discharge | 12 months |
Slater et al.62 | 2008 | US | 612 | N/A | During hospitalization | 6 months |
After discharge | ||||||
Wang et al.63 | 2014 | China | 32 | 34 | During hospitalization | 6 months |
After discharge | ||||||
West et al.64 | 1997 | US | 51 | N/A | After discharge | 94-182 days |
Wheeler & Waterhouse65 | 2006 | US | 20 | 20 | After discharge | 14 weeks |
Jiang66 | 2008 | China | 101 | 89 | During hospitalization | 6 months |
After discharge | ||||||
Tully et al.67 | 2014 | Australia | A=15 | N/A | After discharge | 6 months |
B=14 | ||||||
Davidson et al.68 | 2010 | Australia | 52 | 53 | After discharge | 12 months |
Aguado et al.69 | 2010 | Spain | 42 | 64 | After discharge | 24 months |
Anderson et al.70 | 2005 | US | 44 | 77 | During hospitalization | 6 months |
During discharge | ||||||
After discharge | ||||||
Andryukhin et al.71 | 2010 | Russia | 44 | 41 | After discharge | 6, 18 months |
Dahl & Penque72 | 2001 | US | 381 | 203 | During hospitalization | 90 days |
After discharge | ||||||
Doughty et al.73 | 2002 | New Zealand | 100 | 97 | After discharge | 12 months |
Ferrante et al.74 | 2010 | Argentina | 760 | 758 | After discharge | 1, 3 years |
Gámez-López et al.75 | 2012 | Spain | A=25 | 35 | After discharge | 10.8 ± 3.2 months |
B=28 | ||||||
C=28 | ||||||
Gau et al.76 | 2008 | Taiwan, China | 30 | 30 | During hospitalization | 1 month |
After discharge | ||||||
Hershberger et al.77 | 2001 | US | 108 | N/A | After discharge | 6 months |
Houchen et al.78 | 2012 | UK | 17 | N/A | After discharge | 12 months |
Lee et al.79 | 2014 | US | 473 | 475 | During hospitalization | 30 days |
Liou et al.80 | 2015 | Taiwan | 56 | 75 | During hospitalization | 30, 90 days |
After discharge | ||||||
Pugh et al.81 | 2001 | US | 27 | 31 | During hospitalization | 12 months |
After discharge | ||||||
Riegel et al.82 | 2002 | US | 126 | 226 | After discharge | 3, 6 months |
Riegel & Carlson83 | 2004 | US | 45 | 43 | After discharge | 30 days, 3 months |
Smith et al.84 | 2015 | US | 92 | 106 | After discharge | 12 months |
Stewart et al.85 | 1999 | Australia | 100 | 100 | After discharge | 6 months |
Sun et al.86 | 2013 | China | 433 | 288 | After discharge | 4 years |
Szkiladz et al.87 | 2013 | US | 86 | 94 | During discharge | 30 days |
After discharge | ||||||
Tsuyuki et al.88 | 2004 | Canada | 140 | 136 | During hospitalization | 6 months |
After discharge | ||||||
Vavouranakis et al.89 | 2003 | Greece | 28 | N/A | After discharge | 12 months |
Wright et al.90 | 2003 | New Zealand | 100 | 97 | After discharge | 12 months |
Dracup et al.91 | 2014 | US | A=200 | 209 | After discharge | 2 years |
B=193 | ||||||
Howlett et al.92 | 2009 | Canada | 990 | 7741 | After discharge | 12 months |
Jaarsma et al.93 | 1999 | Netherlands | 84 | 95 | During hospitalization | 9 months |
After discharge | ||||||
López Cabezas et al.94 | 2006 | Spain | 70 | 64 | During discharge | 12 months |
After discharge | ||||||
Naylor et al.95 | 2004 | US | 118 | 121 | During hospitalization | 52 weeks |
After discharge | ||||||
Piamjariyakul et al.96 | 2015 | US | 20 | N/A | After discharge | 6 months |
Jerant et al.97 | 2001 | US | A=12 | 12 | After discharge | 6 months |
B=13 | ||||||
Shao et al.98 | 2013 | Taiwan | 47 | 46 | After discharge | 12 weeks |
Varma et al.99 | 1999 | UK | 42 | 41 | After discharge | 12 months |
Atienza et al.100 | 2004 | Spain | 164 | 174 | During hospitalization | 12 months |
Fonarow et al.101 | 1997 | US | 214 | N/A | During hospitalization | 6 months |
After discharge | ||||||
Holst et al.102 | 2001 | Australia | 42 | N/A | During hospitalization | 6 months |
After discharge | ||||||
Kanoksilp et al.103 | 2009 | Thailand | 50 | 50 | After discharge | 12 months |
Morcillo et al.104 | 2005 | Spain | 34 | 36 | After discharge | 6 months |
Ojeda et al.105 | 2005 | Spain | 76 | 77 | After discharge | 16 ± 8 months |
Wang et al.106 | 2011 | Taiwan, China | 14 | 13 | During hospitalization | 3 months |
After discharge | ||||||
White & Hill107 | 2014 | US | 59 | N/A | During hospitalization | 2 months |
After discharge | ||||||
Davis et al.108 | 2012 | US | 63 | 62 | During hospitalization | 30 days |
After discharge | ||||||
Delaney & Apostolidis109 | 2010 | US | 12 | 12 | After discharge | 90 days |
Mao et al.110 | 2015 | Taiwan | 174 | 175 | After discharge | Median 2 years |
Byszewski et al.111 | 2010 | Canada | 45 | 46 | After discharge | 6 weeks |
Domingo et al.112 | 2011 | Spain | A=48 | N/A | After discharge | 12 months |
B=44 | ||||||
Harrison et al.113 | 2002 | Canada | 92 | 100 | After discharge | 12 weeks |
Löfvenmark et al.114 | 2011 | Sweden | 65 | 63 | After discharge | 18 months |
Otsu & Moriyama115 | 2012 | Japan | 47 | 47 | After discharge | 7-12, 24 months |
Rich et al.116 | 1993 | US | 63 | 35 | During hospitalization | 90 days |
During discharge | ||||||
After discharge | ||||||
Rich et al.117 | 1995 | US | 142 | 140 | During hospitalization | 90 days |
During discharge | ||||||
After discharge | ||||||
Stewart et al.118 | 2012 | Australia | 143 | 137 | After discharge | 18 months |
Stewart et al.119 | 2014 | Australia | 137 | 143 | After discharge | 12-18 months |
Sullivan et al.120 | 2009 | US | 108 | 100 | After discharge | 12 months |
Abbreviation: NA, not available.