Table 2.
Author | Compared radiotracers | Study type (year) | Study group number | Inclusion criteria | PSA level, mean (±SD) | Time window between PET/CT scans | Detection rate |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Schwenck [46] | 68Ga-PSMA vs. 11C-choline | retrospective (2016) | 103 | BCR | 2.7 (median) | 24 hours | lymph nodes: 94% vs. 71% bones: 98% vs. 64% overall: 83% vs. 79% |
Bluemel [44] | 68Ga-PSMA vs. 18F-choline | retrospective (2016) | 125 | BCR | 5.4 (±12.73) | 51 days | 18F-choline: 74.4% 68Ga-PSMA in 18F-choline(-) scans: 43.8% overall: 85.6% |
Pfister [45] | 68Ga-PSMA vs. 18F-choline | retrospective (2016) | 66 | BCR | 2.7 and 2.35 (median) | n/a |
per-patient analysis: PPV: 78.9% vs. 82.1% per-lesion analysis: PPV: 67.3% vs. 75.7% NPV: 88.8% vs. 96.6% ACC: 82.5% vs. 91.9% |
Morigi [11] | 68Ga-PSMA vs. 18F-choline | prospective (2015) | 38 | BCR | 1.72 (±2.54) | 30 days | PSA level <0.5: 50% vs. 12.5% PSA level 0.5-2.0: 71% vs. 36% PSA level >2.0: 88% vs. 63% overall: 66% vs. 32% |
Afshar-Oromieh [43] | 68Ga-PSMA vs. 18F-choline | retrospective (2014) | 37 | BCR | 11.1 (±24.1) | 30 days | PSA level ≤2.82: 68.8% vs. 43.5% PSA level >2.82: 100% vs. 90.5% overall: 86.5% vs. 70.3% |
ACC – accuracy; BCR – biochemical recurrence; NPV – negative predictive value; PPV – positive predictive value
All PSA levels are given in ng/ml