Skip to main content
. 2017 Apr 27;12(4):e0176357. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0176357

Table 1. Effect of four aluminum concentrations on relative root length (%) of 24 rice genotypes at 12, 24 and 48 h in the hydroponic assay.

Rice varieties Al(μM) Relative root length (%)
12h 24h 48h
Disang 0 100.00±1.30 100.00±1.57 100.00±1.85
25 98.71±1.99 97.35±1.77* 97.01±1.82*
50 98.18±1.43 96.64±1.79* 96.41±1.22*
100 97.21±1.38 96.17±1.54* 95.81±1.93*
Swarna sub 1C 0 100.00±1.26 100.00±1.23 100.00±1.42
25 99.32±1.62 98.22±1.53 97.57±1.43*
50 98.04±1.45 97.03±1.67 96.23±1.71*
100 97.12±1.61 96.01±1.20 95.06±1.03*
Naveen 0 100.00±1.40 100.00±1.54 100.00±2.16
25 99.26±1.52 98.96±1.96 98.88±1.22
50 96.00±1.42 95.93±1.11 96.48±1.93
100 95.22±1.38 94.98±1.30 94.84±1.26*
KMJ-6-1-1 0 100.00±1.51 100.00±1.87 100.00±1.77
25 96.18±1.81 95.69±1.38* 95.55±1.72
50 95.49±1.86 94.51±1.94* 93.54±1.97*
100 95.05±1.24 93.68±1.71* 93.13±1.85*
Tapaswini 0 100.00±1.30 100.00±1.50 100.00±1.75
25 98.34±2.14 97.79±1.02 97.47±1.70
50 96.86±1.54 96.83±1.92* 95.55±1.34*
100 93.41±1.51 93.25±1.10* 92.74±1.46*
Badsahbhog 0 100.00±1.98 100.00±1.94 100.00±1.49
25 98.60±1.96 98.33±2.09 97.13±1.37
50 97.20±1.70 96.84±1.12 94.74±1.50*
100 92.91±1.67 92.67±2.02* 92.39±1.51*
Ranjit 0 100.00±1.73 100.00±2.10 100.00±2.15
25 95.87±1.88 95.79±1.57 95.73±1.39*
50 94.25±1.90 94.33±1.99 93.99±1.90*
100 92.83±1.81 92.57±1.88 92.15±1.98*
Lachit 0 100.00±1.76 100.00±1.99 100.00±1.57
25 95.60±1.88 95.58±1.79 95.36±1.67*
50 93.14±1.97 93.07±1.74* 92.58±1.55*
100 92.63±1.76 92.57±1.75* 91.94±1.81*
KMJ-6-1-2 0 100.00±1.90 100.00±1.93 100.00±1.21
25 98.24±1.59 98.19±1.13 97.64±1.31*
50 95.49±1.22 95.45±1.51 93.61±1.42*
100 93.43±1.27 93.39±1.17 91.51±1.38*
Aijung 0 100.00±1.97 100.00±1.81 100.00±1.35
25 99.77±2.04 99.50±1.72 98.89±1.22
50 97.85±1.76 96.55±1.54* 97.50±1.73
100 90.96±1.52* 90.89±1.44* 90.74±1.86*
Kola Joha 0 100.00±1.23 100.00±1.28 100.00±1.21
25 94.19±1.19 92.98±1.56* 90.15±1.38*
50 91.39±1.84 90.57±1.24* 89.28±1.99*
100 90.42±1.23 90.09±1.42* 88.47±1.98*
Sahbhagi Dhan 0 100.00±2.07 100.00±1.10 100.00±1.54
25 96.44±1.90 96.43±1.43 95.92±1.79
50 91.66±1.15 91.64±1.65 91.16±1.59
100 88.46±1.92 88.07±1.52 87.20±1.90
Cauveri 0 100.00±1.48 100.00±1.37 100.00±1.87
25 99.30±1.40 95.48±1.35* 95.35±1.84*
50 95.00±1.79 92.95±1.24* 87.44±1.46*
100 92.50±1.58 87.40±1.44* 86.80±1.57*
Gautam 0 100.00±1.32 100.00±1.75 100.00±1.74
25 97.67±1.68 96.68±1.54* 96.66±1.27*
50 97.25±1.95 96.26±1.78* 95.71±2.02*
100 86.93±1.53 86.88±1.66* 86.64±1.35*
Swarna 0 100.00±1.84 100.00±1.32 100.00±1.91
25 98.44±1.12 98.43±2.01* 98.41±1.17*
50 96.82±1.32 96.74±1.21* 96.69±1.48*
100 86.62±1.34 86.27±1.26* 86.20±1.13*
Kapilee 0 100.00±1.76 100.00±1.57 100.00±1.37
25 94.78±1.54 94.77±1.43* 93.81±1.94*
50 94.07±1.71 89.53±1.87* 89.49±2.32*
100 86.29±1.25* 86.26±1.40* 85.78±1.19*
KMJ -2-1-4 0 100.00±1.47 100.00±1.29 100.00±1.12
25 97.79±1.90 96.20±1.26 95.63±1.90*
50 96.39±1.37 91.48±1.82 88.23±1.29*
100 93.12±1.58 87.80±1.96 85.13±1.76*
Bahadur 0 100.00±1.64 100.00±1.16 100.00±1.94
25 98.90±1.45 98.87±1.99 98.40±1.59*
50 93.35±1.81 93.24±1.75* 92.93±1.37*
100 84.46±1.16 84.17±1.26* 81.77±1.51*
Mashuri 0 100.00±1.61 100.00±1.07 100.00±1.89
25 90.37±1.32 88.95±1.37* 88.25±1.60*
50 81.88±2.12 81.64±2.04* 81.55±1.47*
100 79.96±1.37* 79.49±1.72* 79.26±1.55*
Chandrama 0 100.00±1.23 100.00±1.42 100.00±1.74
25 96.89±1.56 96.88±1.69 96.79±1.68
50 79.87±1.63 79.43±1.96* 92.49±1.85*
100 79.24±1.48* 79.18±1.16* 79.09±1.49*
KMJ-10-1-4 0 100.00±1.02 100.00±1.33 100.00±1.20
25 95.93±1.45 95.90±2.66* 93.44±1.98*
50 83.51±1.48* 83.27±1.57* 83.19±2.15*
100 78.97±1.57* 78.92±1.67* 78.82±1.96*
CR Dhan 601 0 100.00±1.87 100.00±1.65 100.00±1.31
25 92.98±2.04 91.13±1.35* 89.65±1.63*
50 82.15±1.17 81.84±1.44* 81.82±1.68*
100 78.92±1.35* 78.75±1.54* 78.59±1.73*
Tulsi Joha 0 100.00±1.85 100.00±1.48 100.00±1.72
25 95.40±1.77* 95.27±1.64 94.94±2.10*
50 81.80±1.68* 81.78±1.98 81.74±1.64*
100 76.84±1.69* 76.73±1.36* 76.40±1.43*
Joymati 0 100.00±1.42 100.00±1.98 100.00±1.58
25 95.80±1.71 94.55±1.29 92.81±1.69*
50 79.41±1.31* 78.49±1.73* 77.18±1.54*
100 71.34±1.42* 70.36±1.76* 68.70±1.53*

Data presented are mean ± S.E. (n = 10).

Significant mean difference between control and stress plants were significant at P < 0.05 (*) by Tukey test.