Skip to main content
. 2017 Mar 7;174(1):241–257. doi: 10.1104/pp.16.01940

Table III. ANOVA statistics from linear mixed-effects models for traits measured in the field experiment.

For each trait, the growth stage of measurement was treated as a fixed effect, and cultivar identity was treated as a random effect to partition phenotypic variance to within and between cultivars. Trait abbreviations are as in Table II. Min and Max are the minimum and maximum trait values. Model degrees of freedom are type III Satterthwaite approximates. Variance components were estimated by partitioning variance within and between cultivars with REML. Significance levels are as follows: n.s., P > 0.05, and ***, P < 0.001 after adjusting for multiple comparisons. Effects were not estimated for gs-co2, since it is a direct transformation of gs.

Trait Range
Growth Stage, Fixed Effect
Variance Component
Variance Attributed to Cultivar
Min Max F2,78-86 P Cultivar Residual
%
α 0.815 0.955 59.5 *** 8.007 × 10−5 3.445 × 10−4 18.86
SPAD 25 54.8 129.1 *** 4.291 11.848 26.59
AN 7.8 33.4 3.0 n.s. 4.84 18.08 21.12
gs 0.0988 0.585 35.2 *** 8.88 × 10−4 7.29 × 10−3 10.86
gs-co2 0.0618 0.365
gm 0.39 2.42 8.7 *** 0.0178 0.1357 11.60
gm/gs-co2 0.445 1.389 33.4 *** 0.00 2.186 × 10−2 0.00
Ci-Cc 62.0 229.8 14.0 *** 76.91 553.91 12.19
AN/gs 41.5 114.0 67.1 *** 0.00 116 0.00
δ13C −31.31 −26.2 107.8 *** 0.1842 0.3746 32.96
Jcal 95.0 300.4 1.1 n.s. 346.7 2164.3 13.81
Narea 0.380 3.163 55.5 *** 9.855 × 10−3 0.1702 5.47
Nmass 1.937 5.891 19.9 *** 0.00 0.4463 0.00
LT 0.145 0.3025 39.8 *** 1.602 × 10−5 6.741 × 10−4 2.32
LD 0.105 0.281 184.2 *** 1.355 × 10−4 5.387 × 10−4 20.10
LMA 19.6 80.8 147.4 *** 5.001 67.21 6.93
LDMC 0.172 0.374 244.6 *** 1.308 × 10−4 5.5574 × 10−4 19.01