Table 1.
Study | Participants | Description of LBP/determination of a previous episode | Outcome measure (e.g. survey) | # that developed LBP in follow up year |
---|---|---|---|---|
Adams et al [29] |
n = 403 Mean age (yr) = 27 Population = Health care workers Gender = 92% F Region: United Kingdom |
History of LBP: n = 141 Pain free at baseline: not stated |
Self-administered postal questionnaire, n = 399 (1% percent lost in follow up period) | n = 159 (39.5%) first time LBP |
Biering-Sorensen et al [30] |
n = 928 Mean age (yr) = not stated, range 30-60 Population = community members Gender = 52% F Region: Denmark |
History of LBP: not stated Pain free at baseline: not stated |
Self-administered postal questionnaire or telephone, n = 920 (1% percent lost in follow up period) | n = 170 (M), 185 (F) [recurrence or persistence of LBP]; n = 28 (M), 30 (F) [first time LBP 6.3%] |
Feldman et al [31] |
n = 810 Mean age (yr) = 14.1 Population = Adolescent students Gender = 47% F Region: Canada |
History of LBP: n = 125 Pain free at baseline: not stated |
Self-administered questionnaire, n = 502 (38% lost in follow up period) | n = 65 developed first time LBP (17.2%)) |
Fortin et al [40] |
n = 99 Mean age (yr) = 47.3 Population = Monozygotic twins Gender = 0% F Region: Finland |
History of LBP: 68 Pain free at baseline: not stated |
Numeric pain scale, n = 98 (1% lost in follow up period) | n = 68 (recurrence or persistence of LBP, 69.4%) |
Gibbons et al [32] |
n = 130 Mean age (years) = 48 Population = Twins Gender = 0% F Region: Finland |
History of LBP: n = 85 (in past year) Pain free at baseline: yes |
Telephone, n = 128 (2% lost in follow up period) | n = 13 developed first time LBP (out of 43 that reported no history of LBP at baseline, 30.2%)); n = not reported for those 85 participants that declared a history of LBP in 12/12 before baseline testing |
Kanchanomai et al [33] |
n = 684 Mean age (years) = 19.4 Population = University students Gender = 74% F Region: Thailand |
History of LBP: n = 0 (in past 3 months) Pain free at baseline: yes |
Self-administered questionnaire, n = 524 (23% lost in follow up period) | n = 160 (23.4%) developed first time LBP |
Kountouris et al [34] |
n = 23 Mean age (years) = 24 Population = Elite fast bowlers Gender = 0% F Region: Australia |
History of LBP: n = not stated Pain free at baseline: yes |
Sports Medicine Physician and MRI, n = 23 (0% lost in follow up period) | n = 18 developed first time LBP (72.3%) |
Kujala et al [35] |
n = 138 Mean age (years) = not stated, range 10.3-13.3 Population = athletes and non-athletes Gender = not stated, 56% F at follow up Region: Finland |
History of LBP: n = 28 (in past year) Pain free at baseline: not stated |
Self-administered postal questionnaire, n = 119 (14% lost in follow up period) | n = 24 (11 recurrence of LBP [39.3%], 13 first time LBP [11.8%) |
Luoto et al [36] |
n = 167 Mean age (years) = not stated Population = blue and white collar workers Gender = 56% F Region: Finland |
History of LBP: n = 0 (in past year) Pain free at baseline: yes |
Nordic questionnaire, n = 126 (25% lost in follow up period) | n = 33 developed first time LBP (19.8%) |
Milgrom et al [37] |
n = 395 Mean age (years) = 18 Population = infantry recruits Gender = 0% F Region: Israel |
History of LBP: n = 0 Pain free at baseline: not stated |
Physical examination, n = not clear how many were lost in follow up period | n = 40 developed first time LBP (10.1%) |
Nissinen et al [39] |
n = 859 Mean age (years) = 12.8 Population = School children Gender = 48% F Region: Finland |
History of LBP: n = 0 (in past year) Pain free at baseline |
Self-administered standardised pain questionnaire, n = 859 (0% lost in follow up period) | n = 151 developed first time LBP (17.6%) |
Van Nieuwenhuyse et al [38] |
n = 823 Mean age (years) = 26 Population = workers at health care and distribution facilities Gender = 60% F Region: Belgium |
History of LBP: n = 337 (in past year) Pain free at baseline: n = 688 (4 of the participants with history of LBP reported LBP at baseline) |
Self-administered questionnaire, n = 692 (16% lost in follow up period) | n = 34 developed first time LBP (out of 355 that reported no history of LBP at baseline, 9.6%), n = 52 (out of 337 that reported LBP in 12/12 before testing, 15.4%) |
F female, M male, LBP low back pain