Skip to main content
. 2017 Mar 31;11:239–247. doi: 10.2174/1874325001711010239

Table 4.

Summary of study findings that reshaped the management of radial head fractures.

Method of treatment discussed Authors Population Summary of key findings
Radial head resection Hall et al. [24] Case series: 42 patients evaluated for elbow or forearm problems after radial head resection. 7 patients (17%) were diagnosed with posterolateral rotational instability of the elbow.
Non-operative Akesson et al. [20] 49 patients treated non-operatively for Mason type-IIa radial head fractures. 6 patients had delayed radial head excision for poor outcome. 40 of the 49 patients (82%) had no subjective complaints after non-operative treatment. Injured elbows had significantly lower ROM and higher degenerative changes compared to non-injured elbows but this was thought to be clinically insignificant by the authors.
Herbertsson et al. [25] Retrospective study: 100 patients treated non-operatively, with radial head resection, or with ORIF for Mason type-II or III radial head and neck fractures. Mean follow-up was 19 years. 77 of the 100 patients had no symptoms at follow-up. Mean ROM deficits were minor (2 degree flexion, 3 degree extension, and 3 degree supination deficits). 19 patients had primary radial head excision while 9 patients had a secondary procedure performed due to residual pain.
ORIF Ring et al. [19] Retrospective study: 56 patients treated with ORIF for intra-articular radial head fracture. 14 out of 15 patients with Mason Type-3 comminuted radial head fractures with at least 3 articular fragments had unsatisfactory results (based on failure of fixation or nonunion requiring radial head excision, a fair or poor result with the system of Broberg and Morrey, or recovery of < 100 degrees of forearm rotation).
RHA Yan et al. [27] RCT: 39 patients with Mason type-3 radial head fractures and associated terrible triad injuries of the elbow RHA group had a significant shorter surgery duration, fewer post-surgical complications, and better clinical outcomes compared to the ORIF group.
Chen et al. [26] RCT: 45 patients with unstable, multi-fragmented fractures of the radial head treated with either ORIF or RHA Better outcome scores and lower complication rates among the RHA group compared to the ORIF group.