Skip to main content
. 2017 May 9;12(5):e0176090. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0176090

Table 1. Characteristics and quality of included studies.

Study Gest weeks Design Steroid type Primary outcomes Adjusted variables Quality of study NOS#
Selection Comparability Outcome
Carlo 2011 22–25
Pros. Beta or Dexa Mortality and neurodevelopmental impairment at 18–22 months Maternal age, hypertension or preeclampsia, rupture of membranes >24 hrs and delivery mode, multiple births, neonatal gender, and centre. **** ** ***
Hayes 2008 23 Retro. Beta or Dexa Neonatal mortality Maternal age, race, plurality, antibiotic administration at delivery, route of delivery, and neonatal gender and birth weight. **** ** ***
Manktelow
2009
23–32 Pros. Beta or Dexa Neonatal mortality Not adjusted **** * ***
Mori 2011 22–33 Retro. Beta or Dexa Respiratory distress, Mortality, CLD, IVH and NEC. Maternal age, parity, multiplicity, GDM, hypertension, PROM, mode of and place of delivery, neonatal gender, birth weight. **** * ***
Guinsburg 2016 23–33+6 Pros. Not mentioned Unfavourable neonatal outcome Maternal and neonatal morbidity variables **** ** ***
Bajwa 2011 23–32 Pros. Not mentioned Neonatal mortality Neonatal gender and growth restriction. **** ** ***
Guthrie 2003 23–34 Retro. HC or Dexa NEC Neonatal birth weight, Apgar score at 5 minutes, caesarean delivery, exposure to indomethacin **** ** ***
Bader 2010 23–26 Pros. Not mentioned Neonatal mortality Maternal ethnicity, infertility treatment, plurality, hypertensive disorders amnionitis, neonatal birth weight and gender. **** ** ***

#NOS: New castle Ottawa scale.

*: The number of stars indicate score as per NOS.

Data from Park et al.

Pros- Prospective, Retro- Retrospective, Beta- Betamethasone, Dexa- Dexamethasone, HC- Hydrocortisone- Chronic lung disease, NEC- Necrotising enterocolitis, IVH- Intraventricular Haemorrhage, PVL- Periventricular Leukomalacia, GDM- Gestational diabetes mellitus, PROM- Prolonged rupture of membrane.