Table 1.
Description of included studies.
| Study and Year | N | Dementia severity | Intervention | Outcome measures | Group vs. individual therapy | Prescribed vs. individualized music | Active vs. passive music intervention |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Clark et al., 1998 | Total N: 18 T/C: 9/9 | Severe (MMSE) | Experimental group: 10 baths with favorite music during bathing, distributed on a 2 weeks period | Agitation checklist | Individual | Individualized | Passive |
| Control group: Standard care (no music during bathing) | |||||||
| Janata, 2012 | Total N: 38 T/C: 19/19 | Moderate to severe (MMSE) | Experimental group: session length (min): 25/65; Frequency (times/week): 84/12; Music streaming for several hours per day (two times in the morning and two times in the evening) each day for 12 weeks | CMAI | Individual | Individualized | Passive |
| Control group: Standard care | |||||||
| Lin et al., 2011 | Total N: 100 T/C: 49/51 | Moderate to severe (MMSE) | Experimental group: session length (min): 30; Frequency (times/week): 12/6; Two times a week for 6 weeks | MMSE | Group | Individualized | Passive |
| Control group: Standard care | |||||||
| Raglio et al., 2008 | Total N: 59 T/C: 30/29 | Moderate to severe (CDR) | Experimental group: session length (min): 30; Frequency (times/week): 30/16; Three cycles of 10 MT sessions within a period of 16 weeks | NPI | Group | Individualized | Active |
| Control group: standard care | |||||||
| Raglio et al., 2010 | Total N: 60 T/C: 30/30 | Severe (MMSE) | Experimental group: session length (min): 30; Frequency (times/week): 36/12; Three cycles of 12MT sessions each, Three times a week for 12 weeks | NPI | Group | Not mentioned | Active |
| Control group: standard care | |||||||
| Raglio et al., 2015 | Total N: 120 T/T/C: 31/32/35 | Moderate to severe (CDR and MMSE) | Experimental group: session length (min): 30; Frequency (times/week): 20/10; Twice a week for 10 weeks | NPI | Individual and group | Individualized | Active and passive |
| Control group: Standard care | |||||||
| Remington, 2002 | Total N: 34 T/C: 17/17 | Mild to severe | Four groups were used to test the effect of a 10 min exposure to either calming music, hand massage, or calming music and hand massage simultaneously, or no intervention (control). Only data from the music group and control group were used in the analysis. | CMAI | Individual | Prescribed | Passive |
| Experimental group: 1 session with 10 min music intervention | |||||||
| Control group: standard care | |||||||
| Ridder et al., 2013 | Total N: 42 T/C: 21/21 | Moderate to severe (MMSE and GDS) | Experimental group: session length (min): 30; Frequency (times/week): 12/6; Two times a week for 6 weeks | CMAI | Individual | Prescribed | Active |
| Control group: standard care | |||||||
| Sakamoto et al., 2013 | Total N: 39 T/C: 13/13/13 | Severe (MMSE) | Experimental group: session length (min): 30; Frequency (times/week): 10/10; Once a week for 10 weeks | BEHAVE-AD | Individual | Individualized | Active and passive |
| Control group: standard care | |||||||
| Sung et al., 2006a | Total N: 57 T/C: 32/25 | Moderate to severe (GDS) | Experimental group: session length (min): 30; Frequency (times/week): 12/6; Two times a week for 6 weeks | CMAI | Group | Individualized | Active |
| Control group: standard care | |||||||
| Sung et al., 2006b | Total N: 36 T/C: 18/18 | Moderate to severe (GDS) | Experimental group: session length (min): 30; Frequency (times/week): 8/4; Two times a week for 4 weeks | CMAI | Group | Individualized | Active |
| Control group: standard care | |||||||
| Sung et al., 2012 | Total N: 55 T/C: 27/28 | Mild to moderate (MMSE) | Experimental group: session length (min): 30; Frequency (times/week): 12/6; Two times a week for 6 weeks | CMAI | Group | Individualized | Active |
| Control group: standard care |
T/C, treatment/control group; MMSE, mini mental state examination; CDR, clinical dementia rating; GDS, global deterioration scale.