Skip to main content
. 2017 May 17;8:887. doi: 10.3389/fmicb.2017.00887

Table 3.

Effect of different concentration of distillery sludge leachate on seedling growth of Phaseolus mungo L.

Concentration (%) Germination (%)
Relative toxicity (%)
Radical length (cm)
Germination index
Phytotoxicity (%)
Stress tolerance index
Untreated Treated Untreated Treated Untreated Treated Untreated Treated Untreated Treated Untreated Treated
1 100 @ 0.00± 100 @ 0.00 00 @ 00 ± 00 @ 0.00 1.9 @ 0.04 ± 2.00 @ 0.01ˆa 0.95 @ 0.10± 1.0 @ 0.08ˆa 5.0 @ 0.01 ± 00 @ 00ˆns 0.95 @ 0.02± 1.00 @ 0.01ˆns
2.5 90 @ 0.00 ± 100 @ 0.00 10 @ 0.00 ± 00 @ 00 0.75 @ 0.02± 2.00 @ 0.02ˆa 0.33 @ 0.02± 1.0 @ 0.01ˆa 62.50 @ 2.77± 00 @ 00ˆa 0.37 @ 0.01± 1.00 @ 0.04ˆa
5.0 78 @ 0.00 ± 90 @ 0.00 22 @ 0.00 ± 10 @ 0.00 0.50 @ 0.04± 1.9 @ 0.02ˆa 0.19 @ 0.00± 0.85 @ 0.00ˆa 75 @ 2.98 ± 5.0 @ 1.4ˆa 0.25 @ 0.03± 0.95 @ 0.00ˆa
10 NG 85 @ 0.00 NG 15 @ 0.00 NG 1.1 @ 0.01ˆa NG 0.46 @ 0.00ˆa NG 45 @ 1.2ˆa NG 0.55 @ 0.00ˆa
Control 100 @ 00 ± 100 @ 00 00 @ 00 ± 00 @ 00 2.00 @ 0.10± 2.00 @ 0.18ˆns 00 @ 00 ± 00 @ 00 00 @ 00 ± 00 @ 00 00 @ 00 ± 00 @ 00

NG, no germination was observed; All the values are means of triplicate (n = 3) ± SD. The statistical significance between the values of untreated to their respective treated samples was evaluated by one-way ANOVA. aSignificant level p < 0.001. nsNon-significant level p > 0.05. Control; tap water.