Skip to main content
. 2017 May 17;12(5):e0177121. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0177121

Table 4. Meta-analysis of Group A studies: Neurocognitive performance for deployed Gulf War veterans compared to non-deployed Gulf-era veterans.

Domains/Individual Tests # of Studies Analyzed Model Type Standardized Mean Difference Wald 95% CI Wald p-value
Visuospatial
 Block Design2 4 random -1.39 -2.45, -0.33 0.01
Executive Function
 Digit Span–Backward2 3 fixed -0.17 -0.25, -0.09 <0.001
 Trail-making Test, part B1,2 5 random 0.36 0.20, 0.51 <0.001
Attention
 Trail-making Test, part A1,2 5 random 0.10 0.03, 0.18 0.008
 Digit Span–Forward3 3 random -0.07 -0.14, 0.01 0.10
Learning and Memory
 CVLT Trials 1–5 4 random -0.09 -0.17, -0.02 0.02
 CVLT Short Delay 4 random -0.21 -0.43, 0.01 0.07
 CVLT Long Delay 4 random -0.12 -0.26, 0.02 0.10
 CVLT Recognition3 3 random -0.21 -0.29, -0.13 <0.001
 WMS4 Immediate Recall3 3 fixed -0.15 -0.33, 0.02 0.08
 WMS4 Delayed Recall 3 random -0.20 -0.50, -0.10 0.20
Motor
Finger Tapping–Dominant 4 fixed -0.03 -0.11, 0.04 0.38
Finger Tapping–Non-Dominant 4 random -0.05 -0.12, 0.03 0.24
Grooved Pegboard–Dominant1 3 random 0.10 -0.55, 0.76 0.75

1 positive SMD represents worse performance

2 remains statistically significant in bias assessment

3 no longer statistically significant in bias assessment

4 WMS, Logical Memory