Skip to main content
. 2017 May 18;12(5):e0177848. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0177848

Table 1. Cost-effectiveness of APPLE schools.

YEARS WITH EXCESS WEIGHT YEARS WITH OBESITY YEARS WITH CHRONIC DISEASE QALYs
SCENARIO Incremental Cost* Incremental Effect* ICER Incremental Effect* ICER Incremental Effect* ICER Incremental Effect* ICER
Discount = 3%—Base results
1 1963.2 -1.26 1,555 -1.15 1,709 -0.14 14,218 0.06 33,421
2 1963.2 -1.04 1,880 -0.95 2,065 -0.11 17,185 0.05 40,396
3 1963.2 -1.82 1,081 -1.65 1,187 -0.20 9,878 0.08 23,216
Discount = 0%
1 1988.0 -1.52 1,312 -1.36 1,464 -0.26 7,599 0.07 28,530
2 1988.0 -1.25 1,586 -1.12 1,770 -0.22 9,185 0.06 34,485
3 1988.0 -2.18 911 -1.95 1,017 -0.38 5,279 0.10 19,819
Discount = 1%
1 1979.6 -1.42 1,398 -1.28 1,552 -0.21 9,534 0.07 30,102
2 1979.6 -1.17 1,689 -1.06 1,876 -0.17 11,524 0.05 36,386
3 1979.6 -2.04 971 -1.84 1,078 -0.30 6,624 0.09 20,911
Discount = 2%
1 1971.3 -1.33 1,479 -1.21 1,633 -0.17 11,742 0.06 31,761
2 1971.3 -1.10 1,787 -1.00 1,974 -0.14 14,192 0.05 38,390
3 1971.3 -1.92 1,027 -1.74 1,135 -0.24 8,158 0.09 22,063
Discount = 4%
1 1955.2 -1.20 1,629 -1.10 1,779 -0.12 16,954 0.06 35,037
2 1955.2 -0.99 1,968 -0.91 2,150 -0.10 20,492 0.05 42,350
3 1955.2 -1.73 1,131 -1.58 1,236 -0.17 11,779 0.08 24,339
Discount = 5%
1 1947.4 -1.15 1,698 -1.06 1,844 -0.10 19,938 0.05 36,590
2 1947.4 -0.95 2,053 -0.87 2,229 -0.08 24,099 0.04 44,227
3 1947.4 -1.65 1,180 -1.52 1,281 -0.14 13,852 0.08 25,417

*per 10 children (1 from each of the 10 grade 5 cohorts).

Scenarios: 1-The annual decline in obesity is maintained for the 2 intervention years then remains at the level reached in 2 years for another 8 years; 2- After the two intervention years, the effect starts waning by 5% per year; 3- The annual decline in obesity is maintained for 4 years then remains at the level reached in 4 years for another 6 years