Table 3.
Strategies to address multiple-level barriers to recruitment and retention of individuals with SMI and DM in a behavioral RCT
Barrier by Level | Procedural/methodological strategies | Personnel strategies |
---|---|---|
Macro Level | ||
Weather | Re-schedule assessments, postpone group sessions until most severe weather passed. | |
Providers not referring patients | Study presented annually to new medical trainees, and to faculty at regular meetings | Primary care provider co-investigators served as “Recruitment Champions” to promote referrals |
Potential subjects unaware of study | Flyers at community mental health centers and throughout community | CTSA Community Outreach |
Mediator Level | ||
Transportation difficulty | Provided roundtrip bus tickets, validated parking, Scheduled assessments on days that participants had existing clinic appointment | |
Stigma | Letters mailed to individuals referred to a study of DM, with no mention of SMI | Discuss SMI as a chronic disease similar to DM |
Micro-level | ||
Phone disconnected | Use EHR to update contact information, repeated call attempts, contact authorized secondary contact person, mail letters to participants requesting that they contact the study staff | |
Chronic physical health problem | Scheduled assessments around participants existing clinic appointments, flexible scheduling of assessments, telephone assessments if needed, assessment scheduling window of +/− 2 weeks of target date | |
Schedule conflicts | Flexible appointment times to accommodate participant's schedule, scheduled assessment around participants existing clinic appointments, scheduling window allowing +/− 2 weeks of target date for assessment. | |
Acute health issues | Reschedule assessment | |
Mental health issues | Refer to a mental health provider, If necessary, conduct assessment by phone; | Continuity of experienced, dedicated, empathetic and encouraging study staff |
Disagreed with SMI diagnosis | Explanation of SMI and DM as chronic illnesses, did not focus on specifics of mental health diagnosis | Social support from study team members |
Financial | $25.00 stipend for assessment visits, round trip bus pass or parking validation, flexible scheduling for assessments to allow for jobs, provided diabetic-appropriate snacks which participants may not have been able to afford at assessment visits and TTIM sessions | |
Stigma | For those attending the TTIM intervention, hearing PEs and participants discuss SMI helped those who were initially reluctant to join the discussions | |
Stress from family or living circumstance | Flexible scheduling | Social support from study team members; Problem identification and solving skills and practice for TTIM intervention participants. |
Cultural or language barrier | Encourage questions, PEs were of diverse backgrounds | Bi-lingual Spanish/English research assistant for participants more comfortable conversing in Spanish.* Project staff were trained and had on-going discussions with the team regarding cultural competency and awareness. |
Ability to speak and understand English was an inclusion requirement because the TTIM intervention was only available in English