Abstract
The urban presence of flying-foxes (pteropid bats) in eastern Australia has increased in the last 20 years, putatively reflecting broader landscape change. The influx of large numbers often precipitates community angst, typically stemming from concerns about loss of social amenity, economic loss or negative health impacts from recently emerged bat-mediated zoonotic diseases such as Hendra virus and Australian bat lyssavirus. Local authorities and state wildlife authorities are increasingly asked to approve the dispersal or modification of flying-fox roosts to address expressed concerns, yet the scale of this concern within the community, and the veracity of the basis for concern are often unclear. We conducted an on-line survey to capture community attitudes and opinions on flying-foxes in the urban environment to inform management policy and decision-making. Analysis focused on awareness, concerns, and management options, and primarily compared responses from communities where flying-fox management was and was not topical at the time of the survey. While a majority of respondents indicated a moderate to high level of knowledge of both flying-foxes and Hendra virus, a substantial minority mistakenly believed that flying-foxes pose a direct infection risk to humans, suggesting miscommunication or misinformation, and the need for additional risk communication strategies. Secondly, a minority of community members indicated they were directly impacted by urban roosts, most plausibly those living in close proximity to the roost, suggesting that targeted management options are warranted. Thirdly, neither dispersal nor culling was seen as an appropriate management strategy by the majority of respondents, including those from postcodes where flying-fox management was topical. These findings usefully inform community debate and policy development and demonstrate the value of social analysis in defining the issues and options in this complex human–wildlife interaction. The mobile nature of flying-foxes underlines the need for a management strategy at a regional or larger scale, and independent of state borders.
Keywords: Bat, Flying-fox, Hendra virus, Urban, Wildlife, Management
Highlights
-
•
A minority of community members were directly impacted, suggesting the need for a more targeted management approach.
-
•
Dispersal or culling were not seen as an appropriate management strategies by the majority of respondents.
-
•
Up to 20% of respondents wrongly believed that flying-foxes pose a direct Hendra virus infection risk to humans.
-
•
Additional risk communication is needed to address misunderstandings and misconceptions of health risks.
Introduction
Flying-foxes are nomadic fruit- and blossom-eating bats (family Pteropodidae) that forage by night and roost in arboreal colonies by day. Some Australian species can weigh up to 1 kg, with a wing-span of 1.2 m. Contemporary colonies generally comprise thousands or tens of thousands of bats, although historically, colonies of hundreds of thousands or millions of bats have been recorded [1], [2], [3]. They are protected under state and/or national legislation. In eastern Australia, flying-foxes have become increasingly urbanised in the last 20 years, putatively reflecting landscape change in both rural and urban environments. Paradoxically, food resources have increased in urban and peri-urban environments as a result of human demographic and lifestyle changes, but decreased in rural environments predominantly as a result of natural habitat loss associated with land-use change [4], [5], [6], [7], [8]. While small colonies in remnant urban and peri-urban bushland are generally tolerated, the influx of larger numbers of flying-foxes (most often associated with the large-scale nomadic movements of little red flying-foxes (Pteropus scapulatus)) often precipitates some community angst [9]. The reasons for this are broadly twofold: firstly, nuisance and loss of social amenity, and secondly, health concerns [10]. The former is a consequence of the noise, soiling and smell typically attendant with large numbers of flying-foxes; the latter primarily reflects public concern about bat-mediated zoonotic diseases such as Hendra virus and Australian bat lyssavirus, both of which have caused sporadic human fatalities. In fruit-growing areas, an additional trigger for public concern is the threat of crop damage and associated economic loss. Thus, local authorities and state wildlife authorities are increasingly asked to approve the dispersal or modification of flying-fox roosts to address expressed concerns [11], yet the scale of this concern within the community, and the veracity of the basis for concern are often unclear. The situation highlights the frequently complex nature of human, wildlife and ecosystem interactions, and the need for information-based decision-making. In this context, we conducted a survey to capture community attitudes and opinions about flying-foxes in the urban environment to inform community debate and to support management policy and decision-making. This paper presents the key survey findings.
Methods
Study population
Our target study population was the residents of the eastern Australian state of Queensland where flying-fox management is topical. While we accepted responses from other Australian states, our analysis included responses from Queensland only.
Survey delivery and sample selection
We presented the survey in an on-line format using the Survey MonkeyTM platform, but also advertised the availability of paper copies. The on-line platform was configured to prevent multiple responses from the same device. The survey ran from 27 August to 12 October, 2012. It was promoted by the Queensland government via conventional media release and social media in weeks one and six, and via multiple radio and print media interviews in the intervening period. A number of horse industry and wildlife interest groups posted the survey URL on their official websites. Respondents were self-selected.
Questionnaire
We posed 37 questions within four sections, capturing respondent demographics, flying-fox knowledge, opinions and concerns, and management options. Questions were typically closed, though we provided opportunity for respondents to make additional comment on key questions. A number of questions allowed assessment of potential selection bias. The questionnaire was trialled on about 30 individuals from a cross-section of the community to assess comprehension and clarity, and refined accordingly prior to commencement of the survey.
Analysis
The analysis focused on awareness, concerns, and management options. We were primarily interested in comparing responses from communities where flying-fox management was and was not topical at the time of the survey. The former were defined as post-codes that had sought, been granted, or had an existing damage mitigation permit (DMP) to disperse or modify a roost from the state wildlife authority in the six months prior to the end of the survey. In addition, we explored the role of some demographic variables. Response percentages were rounded to the nearest whole number. Respondents who declined to answer a question were excluded from the denominator in percentage calculations. The chi square statistic was used to examine statistical significance at the 95% confidence level. Chi square values were rounded to one decimal place.
Ethics
The survey and questionnaire were reviewed by the Human Research Ethics Committee of Queensland Health, and approved as a low/negligible impact process (HREC Reference number: HREC/12/QHC/24). Respondents were required to indicate informed consent by clicking a button to access the on-line questionnaire, and again to submit their completed questionnaire. The survey did not target minors, and the content was deemed not to pose harm or risk to minors, thus we did not specifically request informed consent from the next of kin, caretakers, or guardians on behalf of any minors enrolling.
Results
We analysed 2744 responses from Queensland respondents (Fig. 1). There was no statistically significant difference in respondent demographic characteristics between DMP and non-DMP postcodes (Table 1).
Fig. 1.
Location and number of survey responses by postcode. Postcodes that contained roosts for which damage mitigation permits had been sought, granted or existed in the six months prior to the end-date of the survey are indicated by red toning.
Table 1.
Respondent demographic characteristics.
| Characteristic |
Category |
Number (%) of respondents |
||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total | DMP postcode | Non-DMP postcode | ||
| Gender | ||||
| Male | 993 (36) | 269 (39) | 724 (35) | |
| Female | 1751 (64) | 420 (61) | 1331 (65) | |
| Age in yearsa | ||||
| < 16 | 10 (1) | 4 (1) | 6 (1) | |
| 16–34 | 544 (20) | 123 (18) | 421 (20) | |
| 35–54 | 1191 (43) | 305 (44) | 886 (43) | |
| > 55 | 999 (36) | 257 (37) | 742 (36) | |
| Years at current address | ||||
| < 1 | 143 (5) | 36 (5) | 107 (5) | |
| 1–5 | 685 (25) | 156 (23) | 529 (26) | |
| 6–10 | 528 (19) | 119 (17) | 409 (20) | |
| > 10 | 1388 (51) | 378 (55) | 1010 (49) | |
| Highest formal education | ||||
| High school | 515 (19) | 141 (20) | 374 (18) | |
| TAFE/trade | 570 (21) | 153 (22) | 417 (20) | |
| University | 1555 (56) | 363 (53) | 1192 (58) | |
| Other | 104 (4) | 32 (5) | 72 (4) | |
| DMP postcode status | ||||
| 2744 (100) | 689 (25) | 2055 (75) | ||
There was no statistically significant difference between DMP and non-DMP postcodes for any variable.
Respondent age categories were collapsed from seven (Q. 17 in the questionnaire) to five to facilitate analysis.
Awareness
Respondent sources of information and perceived reliability of sources are presented in Table 2. Eighty-six percent rated their general knowledge of flying-foxes as high (25%) or moderate (61%). Flying-fox knowledge did not vary with DMP postcode status, but respondents aged less than 35 years, and respondents whose highest formal education was high school, were more likely to indicate a lower level of knowledge (χ2 = 22.0, p < 0.001 and χ2 = 4.96, p = 0.026 respectively). Eighty-two percent rated their general knowledge of Hendra virus as high (22%) or moderate (60%). Hendra virus knowledge did not vary with DMP postcode, but respondents aged less than 35 years, and male respondents, were more likely to indicate a lower level of knowledge (χ2 = 7.41, p = 0.006 and χ2 = 6.49, p = 0.011 respectively). Additional data on respondent awareness and knowledge are presented in Table 3. About 1500 respondents provided additional comments. Recurring themes sympathetic to flying-foxes were media misinformation and scaremongering about risks, increased urban presence reflecting human changes, and the important ecological/biodiversity role of flying-foxes. Recurring themes critical of flying-foxes were severe loss of amenity of residential parks and yards, disease concerns, and bats given preferential consideration over humans.
Table 2.
Respondent sources of information on flying-fox issues and perceived reliability of sources.
| Information source |
Number (%) of respondents accessing source |
Number (%) of respondents reporting source as reliablea |
||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total | DMP postcodes | Non-DMP postcodes | Chi-square value, p value | Total | DMP postcodes | Non-DMP postcodes | Chi-square value, p value | |
| State govt | 1780 (65) | 444 (64) | 1336 (65) | ns | 1967 (72) | 489 (71) | 1478 (72) | ns |
| Internet | 1257 (46) | 323 (47) | 934 (45) | ns | 751 (27) | 206 (30) | 545 (27) | ns |
| Wildlife group | 1241 (45) | 274 (40) | 967 (47) | 11.1, 0.001 | 1646 (60) | 380 (55) | 1266 (62) | 8.95, 0.003 |
| Local council | 967 (35) | 275 (40) | 692 (34) | 8.80, 0.003 | 1217 (44) | 312 (45) | 905 (44) | ns |
| Private vet | 512 (19) | 111 (16) | 401 (20) | 3.94, 0.047 | ||||
| Horse industry | 282 (10) | 77 (11) | 205 (10) | ns | 688 (25) | 201 (29) | 487 (24) | 8.23, 0.004 |
| Friends/family | 202 (7) | 55 (8) | 147 (7) | ns | ||||
| Radio & TVb | 167 (6) | 71 (10) | 96 (5) | 28.6, < 0.001 | 623 (23) | 195 (28) | 428 (21) | 16.4, < 0.001 |
| Newspapers | 162 (6) | 57 (8) | 105 (5) | 9.29, 0.002 | 271 (10) | 92 (13) | 179 (9) | 12.5, < 0.001 |
| Social media | 117 (4) | 35 (5) | 82 (4) | ns | 103 (4) | 25 (4) | 78 (4) | ns |
| Unsure | 39 (1) | 9 (1) | 30 (1) | ns | ||||
Percentage of respondents answering ‘Mostly reliable’. The information sources of ‘Private vet’, ‘Friends & family’, and ‘Unsure’ were not included in the question.
Responses for radio and for television on source of information and reliability of information (Q. 8 and Q. 20 in the questionnaire) were combined to facilitate analysis.
Table 3.
Respondent awareness and knowledge of flying-foxes and Hendra virus.
| Topic |
Number (%) of respondents replying in the affirmative |
|||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total | DMP postcodes | Non-DMP postcodes | Chi-square value, p value | |
| Thought the ecological role of flying-foxes was importanta | 1977 (72) | 448 (65) | 1529 (74) | 22.6, < 0.001 |
| Reported a flying-fox roost in their neighbourhood | 592 (22) | 227 (33) | 365 (18) | 70.3, < 0.001 |
| Reported flying-foxes feeding in their garden | 1348 (49) | 295 (43) | 1053 (51) | 14.7, < 0.001 |
| Thought that flying-fox numbers were increasing | 906 (33) | 300 (44) | 606 (29) | 46.1, < 0.001 |
| Thought it likely or highly likely they could contract Hendra virus from flying-foxes | 380 (14) | 134 (20) | 246 (12) | 24.0, < 0.001 |
Number (%) of respondents who thought that the ecological role of flying-foxes was as important as, or more important than that of other wildlife.
Concerns
Respondent concerns about flying-foxes are presented in Table 4. Fifty-seven percent indicated that flying-foxes caused concern in their community, with male respondents more likely to respond so (χ2 = 30.3, p = < 0.001). Thirty-nine percent indicated that flying-foxes had caused them concern personally, with male respondents again more likely respond so (χ2 = 35.8, p = < 0.001). DMP postcode respondents were also more likely to respond in the affirmative to these two questions, and more likely to be concerned that flying-foxes might affect water quality, damage property, create noise, generate smell and cause disease. They were also more likely to be concerned if flying-fox numbers were increasing.
Table 4.
Respondent concerns about flying-foxes.
| Nature of concern |
Number (%) of respondents replying in the affirmative |
||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total | DMP postcodes | Non-DMP postcodes | Chi-square value, p value | ||
| Thought flying-foxes cause concern in their community | 1552 (57) | 485 (70) | 1067 (52) | 71.6, < 0.001 | |
| Flying-foxes had caused personal concern | 1058 (39) | 325 (47) | 733 (36) | 28.8, < 0.001 | |
| Were very concerned that flying-foxes | |||||
| Affect water quality | 534 (20) | 194 (29) | 340 (17) | 45.2, < 0.001 | |
| Damage property | 573 (21) | 200 (30) | 373 (18) | 38.0, < 0.001 | |
| Create noise | 537 (20) | 213 (31) | 324 (16) | 75.6, < 0.001 | |
| Generate smell | 606 (22) | 244 (36) | 362 (18) | 97.6, < 0.001 | |
| Cause disease | 924 (35) | 294 (44) | 630 (32) | 33.9, < 0.001 | |
| Would be concerned if flying-fox numbers were increasing | 1124 (41) | 341 (49) | 783 (38) | 27.7, < 0.001 | |
Management options
Forty-one percent of respondents supported dispersal as an appropriate flying-fox management strategy unequivocally (17%) or sometimes (24%), with male respondents and DMP postcode respondents more likely to do so (χ2 = 51.2, p = < 0.001 and χ2 = 20.5, p = < 0.001 respectively). Fifty-seven percent thought that dispersed flying-foxes were unlikely (36%) or highly unlikely (21%) to stay in a new location; 31% were unsure. Seventy-one percent thought it likely (41%) or highly likely (30%) that they would move to another town where they might cause similar issues; 18% were unsure. Twenty-eight percent said they would be less likely to support dispersal as a management strategy if it could result in an increase in flying-fox numbers in their town; 23% indicated similarly if it could mean an increase in numbers in another town. Respondent opinion on the decision-making process for roost dispersals is presented in Table 5. In addition, there was broad consensus that the process should be more inclusive and faster. DMP postcode respondents were less likely to support a dispersal option that required state government approval (43% vs 53%) and more likely to support an option that required local council approval (27% vs 19%).
Table 5.
Respondent support for stakeholder group involvement in flying-fox dispersal decision-making process.
| Stakeholder group |
Number (%) of respondents supporting involvement |
|||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total | DMP postcodes | Non-DMP postcodes | Chi-square value, p value | |
| State government or Biosecurity agency | 1997 (86) | 492 (85) | 1505 (86) | ns |
| Independent scientific experts | 1900 (84) | 452 (82) | 1448 (85) | ns |
| Local council | 1636 (75) | 447 (78) | 1189 (74) | nsa |
| Affected local residents | 1597 (74) | 431 (78) | 1166 (72) | 5.63, 0.018 |
| Wildlife groups | 1497 (72) | 340 (67) | 1157 (73) | 7.09, 0.008 |
| All local residents | 1181 (59) | 328 (66) | 853 (57) | 10.9, 0.001 |
Approaching statistical significance (x2 = 3.65 p = 0.056).
Forty-two percent of respondents thought culling was an appropriate management strategy unequivocally (28%) or sometimes (14%), with male respondents and DMP postcode respondents more likely to think so (χ2 = 60.6, p = < 0.001 and χ2 = 25.3, p = < 0.001 respectively). Additional opinion on flying-fox management strategies are presented in Table 6. About 1200 respondents provided additional comments on management options. The majority favoured alternatives to dispersal and culling, with suggestions including establishing food resource precincts away from urban areas, not allowing residential construction close to existing roosts, financial rebates for residents directly affected, dispersal of roosts in backyards, and sustainable harvesting of flying-foxes.
Table 6.
Respondent supporta for alternative management options in hypothetical management scenarios.
| Management scenario |
Management option |
Number (%) of respondents expressing support |
|||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total | DMP postcodes | Non-DMP postcodes | Chi-square value, p value | ||
| Flying-foxes feeding in an orchard | Exclusion netting | 1469 (56) | 339 (52) | 1130 (58) | 7.18, 0.007 |
| Culling | 667 (25) | 191 (29) | 476 (24) | 6.00, 0.014 | |
| Dispersal | 254 (10) | 76 (12) | 178 (9) | ns | |
| Do nothing | 105 (4) | 23 (4) | 82 (4) | ns | |
| Tree lopping | 20 (1) | 7 (1) | 13 (1) | ns | |
| Flying-foxes roosting in a town park | Do nothing | 1051 (40) | 218 (33) | 833 (43) | 18.2, < 0.001 |
| Dispersal | 574 (22) | 177 (27) | 397 (20) | 12.6, < 0.001 | |
| Culling | 568 (22) | 167 (25) | 401 (21) | 6.96, < 0.001 | |
| Exclusion netting | 149 (6) | 34 (5) | 115 (6) | ns | |
| Tree lopping | 119 (5) | 34 (5) | 85 (4) | ns | |
| Flying-foxes roosting in a school ground | Culling | 692 (26) | 207 (32) | 485 (25) | 11.2, < 0.001 |
| Dispersal | 670 (26) | 180 (27) | 490 (25) | ns | |
| Do nothing | 471 (18) | 106 (16) | 365 (19) | ns | |
| Tree lopping | 321 (12) | 68 (10) | 253 (13) | ns | |
| Exclusion netting | 279 (11) | 66 (10) | 213 (11) | ns | |
| Flying-foxes roosting in a backyard | Dispersal | 593 (23) | 179 (27) | 414 (21) | 10.3, < 0.001 |
| Culling | 585 (22) | 172 (26) | 413 (21) | 7.23, < 0.001 | |
| Do nothing | 545 (21) | 108 (16) | 437 (22) | 10.4, < 0.001 | |
| Tree lopping | 415 (16) | 99 (15) | 316 (16) | ns | |
| Exclusion netting | 271 (10) | 55 (8) | 216 (11) | nsb | |
The number (%) of respondents indicating ‘Unsure’ were 104 (4), 151 (6), 172 (7), and 199 (8) respectively.
Approaching statistical significance (x2 = 3.79, p = 0.052).
Discussion
Community surveys have been used effectively to elaborate public perceptions and behaviour regarding bat-human interactions [12], [13]. With no practical sampling frame available, and with alternatives such as random digit dialling prohibitively expensive, we used an on-line survey tool. Notwithstanding the potential for selection bias with this methodology [14], we believe the wide and diverse promotion of the survey, the large sample size, and the statistically similar demographic characteristics of the DMP and non-DMP postcode respondents allow us to validly compare community attitudes and opinions across the two groups. Given the apparent mixed community sentiment regarding flying-foxes in urban environments, a likely source of selection bias could be response-stacking, where ‘pro’ or ‘anti’ bat respondents are systematically mobilised. However, the responses to a number of questions suggest that the impact of any stacking is equal and opposite, resulting in washout of any bias [15]. For example, nearly 40% of respondents indicated that flying foxes had caused them personal concern. This response is not consistent with a net over-representation of ‘pro’ bat respondents. Similarly, 45% of respondents identified ‘wildlife group’ as a source of information, a response not consistent with an over-representation of ‘anti’ bat respondents. DMP postcodes comprised 10% of all postcodes from which responses were received, yet DMP respondents represent 25% of total respondents. While postcode area and population vary, we would expect similar variation in both DMP and non-DMP postcodes, thus these figures suggest a greater participation rate in DMP postcodes, not unexpected given the likely topicality of flying-fox management in these postcodes. Based on Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) data indicating that the gender ratio in Queensland approaches unity [16], females are over-represented in the survey sample. Similarly, the ABS age profile for Queensland residents (52% > 35 years) indicates that older residents are over-represented. While neither is unique to this survey [17], [18], [19], and neither necessarily impacts external validity, generalisation of the findings should be mindful of these features.
Awareness
A majority of respondents expressed moderate to high levels of knowledge about flying-foxes, consistent with the predominant source of information being the authoritative state government. Interestingly, while the internet was a secondary source of information, its reliability was heavily discounted. Notably, few respondents identified social media as an important source of reliable information.
Less than a quarter of all respondents reported a flying-fox colony in their neighbourhood, indicating more broadly that a minority of community members are likely directly impacted by the potential negative impacts of urban roosts. Indeed, the figure may be an over-estimate, given the likely DMP respondent over-representation. Interestingly, DMP respondents were less likely to report flying-foxes foraging in their garden, suggesting that the presence of an urban roost may not necessarily translate to increased flying-foxes foraging in urban gardens, but rather in urban and peri-urban remnant vegetation.
Nearly three-quarters of all respondents thought the ecological role of flying-foxes was important, including a majority of DMP postcode respondents. Similarly, a majority of respondents did not believe flying-fox numbers were increasing.
Our questions on potential health issues were contained to Hendra virus because of the high public profile of the associated disease from media coverage of cases and from active communication strategies by animal and public health authorities [20], [21]. All human cases of Hendra virus have resulted from direct and close contact with infected horses [22], and there is no evidence to suggest flying-fox to human transmission, yet 14% of respondents thought it likely or highly likely that they could contract Hendra virus directly from flying-foxes. This finding suggests the need for on-going communication from public health authorities regarding Hendra virus exposure risk. The figure approaches 20% for DMP respondents, and the magnitude of this misunderstanding may explain at least in part the stronger anti-flying fox sentiment from this sector.
Concerns
As expected, respondents from DMP postcodes were more likely to indicate that flying-foxes caused community concern than respondents from non-DMP postcodes. Yet less than half reported flying-foxes causing them personal concern, and only about a third were concerned about potential direct negative impacts. Further, DMP respondents expressed net neutral concern with respect to a hypothetical increase in flying-fox numbers. These findings indicate that while there is heightened concern in DMP postcodes, those concerns are not held by the majority of DMP respondents. There clearly will be aggrieved individuals, most plausibly those living in close proximity to a flying-fox roost. There is also a gender perspective evident, with male respondents more likely to indicate concern. This may reflect greater frustration felt by males at being constrained from direct action by regulation. Additional comments support this interpretation in that they frequently expressed anger and resentment at the perception that flying-foxes were being put before people, reflected in the legislative protections afforded flying-foxes and the complexity of the formal damage mitigation process. Comments also expressed frustration and resentment that roosts immediately adjacent to residential areas resulted in faecal soiling and smell that prevented families using their yards, damaged property and negatively impacted property values, the latter preventing respondents from selling and moving.
That more respondents were concerned about potential health impacts than any other potential direct negative impacts is not surprising given the number of emerging diseases associated with bats in recent years, and the several human deaths in Queensland from Hendra virus and Australian bat lyssavirus [22], [23], [24], [25]. Perceived disease risk was also a recurring theme in additional comments. While the consequences of infection with such agents can be dire, the likelihood of infection is low, and can be mitigated with simple measures [26]. Public health, livestock health and wildlife authorities strive to communicate this information, but our findings suggest that some community members are not receiving or not believing this message. This interpretation is supported by the related finding (discussed above) that a substantial minority of respondents thought it likely or highly likely that they could contract Hendra virus directly from flying-foxes. The figure in DMP postcodes is nearly double that in non-DMP postcodes (above), suggesting additional factors are influencing risk perception. At an individual level, it is plausible that the proximity of the perceived threat causes belief in expert advice to waiver; at a community level, where emotions can become inflamed and arguments polarised, it is equally plausible that misinformation or misrepresentation play a role. This interpretation is supported by Degeling and Kerridge [27] who argue the potential for media and vested interest groups to inaccurately shape public concern and opinion about Hendra virus risk. Mainstream media typically portrays the anger and frustrations of negatively impacted individuals or groups, thereby engendering a general public and political perception that flying-foxes are negatively perceived by most. Misunderstanding, misinformation and scare-mongering were recurring themes in additional comments, with many respondents believing that media and interest groups overstated potential disease risks and understated potential ecological benefits of flying-foxes.
Management options
Neither dispersal nor culling was seen as appropriate management strategies by the majority of respondents, both DMP and non-DMP. There was broad recognition that dispersal is a temporary measure, and that flying-foxes dispersed from one community are likely to end up in another [28]. Recognition of the limited effectiveness of dispersal and culling was also evident in responses to the hypothetical management scenarios, where for three of the four scenarios, majority opinion was fairly equally divided between ‘dispersal’, ‘culling’ and ‘do nothing’. For the fourth (flying-foxes foraging in an orchard), exclusion netting was favoured by half the respondents. ‘Tree lopping or removal’ received modest support in the ‘colony in the backyard’ and ‘colony in the school ground’ scenarios.
There was strong support for the decision-making process for dispersals to be more inclusive, with both DMP and non-DMP respondents believing that independent scientific experts and wildlife groups should also participate. This finding, combined with the lack of consensus on the management scenarios suggests that many respondents feel that existing options are inadequate. Two key findings – that a limited number of people are directly negatively impacted, and that dispersal or culling are not popular or effective strategies – suggest the need for a more targeted, management option for urban settings. Additional comments on management options argued for the planting and maintenance of dedicated food resource precincts for flying-foxes, and for pre-emptive town-planning decisions preventing residential encroachment on existing roost locations, and ensuring future remnant urban bushland patches are large enough to avoid potential conflict.
There have been two notable roost dispersals that have been effective long-term: the Melbourne Botanical Gardens colony, commenced in 2003 [29], [30], and the Sydney Royal Botanical Gardens colony, commenced in 2012 [31]. Both sought to relocate a colony to another location nearby, rather than disperse per se, both continue to require on-going monitoring and disturbance at the original location to avoid re-establishment, and both required substantial initial and on-going expense. In contrast, multiple attempts to disperse a colony in the NSW town of Maclean over a 10 year period have been spectacularly unsuccessful, with an escalation of the scale of negative community impact (as the original roost fragmented) and a compounding of the management and economic consequences [32].
Conclusion
The study outputs demonstrate the value of social analysis in defining the issues and options in this complex human–wildlife interaction scenario. Our finding that a substantial minority of respondents mistakenly believe that flying-foxes pose a direct infection risk to humans suggests that misunderstanding, miscommunication or misinformation is a real issue, and highlights the need for additional risk communication strategies. Our finding that only a minority of community members are directly impacted by urban roosts suggests that targeted management options should receive more consideration. The latter is supported by the finding that neither dispersal nor culling was seen as appropriate management strategy by the majority of respondents, including those from DMP postcodes. More broadly, the mobile nature of flying-foxes underlines the need for a management strategy at a regional or larger scale, and independent of state borders.
While the focus of this study has been community perspectives on flying-foxes in the urban environment in Australia, the approach and insights gained could readily apply to complex human–wildlife scenarios anywhere. Fundamentally, such scenarios require a broad ‘one health’ approach.
Acknowledgements
We thank colleagues at the Queensland Centre for Emerging Infectious Diseases (QCEID) and at Animal Biosecurity and Welfare, Biosecurity Queensland for assistance in developing and trialling the survey questionnaire, and for comments on the manuscript. The survey was promoted by the Biosecurity Queensland media communications group. The authors would like to thank individuals and groups who promoted the survey to Queensland communities via word of mouth, social media and internet, and all the community members who participated in the survey. This research was supported by the State of Queensland, the State of New South Wales and the Commonwealth of Australia under the National Hendra Virus Research Program.
References
- 1.Hall L., Richards G. Krieger Publishing; 2000. Flying Foxes Fruit and Blossom Bats of Australia. [Google Scholar]
- 2.Churchill S. 2nd ed. Allen & Unwin; Sydney, Australia: 2008. Australian Bats. [Google Scholar]
- 3.Hall L. Steve Parish Publishing; Queensland: 2009. A Wild Australia Guide: Bats. [Google Scholar]
- 4.Plowright R., Foley P., Eby P., Dobson A., Field H., Foley J. Urban habituation, ecological connectivity and epidemic dampening: the emergence of Hendra virus from flying foxes (Pteropus spp.) Proc. R. Soc. B. 2011;278(1725):3703–3712. doi: 10.1098/rspb.2011.0522. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 5.Markus N., Hall L. Foraging behaviour of the black flying-fox (Pteropus alecto) in the urban landscape of Brisbane, Queensland. Wildl. Res. 2004;31(3):345–355. (PubMed PMID: ISI:000222311500014) [Google Scholar]
- 6.Roberts B.J. Griffith University; Brisbane, Australia: 2005. Habitat characteristics of flying fox camps in south-east Queensland. (BSc Honours Thesis) [Google Scholar]
- 7.Roberts B.J., Catteral C.P., Eby P., Kanowski J. Latitudinal range shifts in Australian flying-foxes: a re-evaluation. Austral Ecol. 2012;37:12–22. [Google Scholar]
- 8.Shilton L., Latch P.J., McKeown A., Pert P., Westcott D. Landscape-scale redistribution of a highly mobile threatened species, Pteropus conspicillatus (Chiroptera, Pteropodidae), in response to Tropical Cyclone Larry. Austral Ecol. 2008;33:549–561. [Google Scholar]
- 9.Helbig K. The Courier Mail. 2012. On the issue of flying foxes in Charters Towers, the party that shoots first may get the vote. http://www.couriermail.com.au/news/queensland/on-the-issue-of-flying-foxes-in-charters-towers-the-party-that-shoots-first-may-get-the-vote/story-fnbt5t29-1226293154980 (Accessed 20/03/14). [Google Scholar]
- 10.Kerr J. Redland City Bulletin. 2014. Council to swoop on bats. http://www.baysidebulletin.com.au/story/2155050/council-to-swoop-on-bats (Accessed 20/03/14). [Google Scholar]
- 11.Anon . 2014. Council to Move Bats Out of Lissner Park. http://www.charterstowers.qld.gov.au/home/-/asset_publisher/9u1O/content/council-to-move-bats-out-of-lissner-park (Accessed 20/03/14). [Google Scholar]
- 12.Young M.K., El Saadi D., McCall B.J. Preventing Australian bat lyssavirus: community knowledge and risk perception of bats in South East Queensland. Vector Borne Zoonotic Dis. 2014;14(4):284–290. doi: 10.1089/vbz.2013.1414. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 13.Paterson B.J., Butler M.T., Eastwood K., Cashman P.M., Jones A., Durrheim D.N. Cross sectional survey of human–bat interaction in Australia: public health implications. BMC Public Health. 2014;14:58. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-14-58. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 14.Eysenbach G., Wyatt J. Using the Internet for surveys and health research. J. Med. Internet Res. 2002;4(2):e13. doi: 10.2196/jmir.4.2.e13. (PMCID: PMC1761932) [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 15.Gove W., McCorkel J., Fain T., Hughes M. Response bias in community surveys of mental health: systematic bias or random noise? Soc. Sci. Med. 1976;10:497–502. doi: 10.1016/0037-7856(76)90118-9. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 16.Australian Bureau of Statistics . 2011. Population by Age and Sex, Regions of Australia. [Google Scholar]
- 17.Curtin R., Presser S., Singer E. The effects of response rate changes on the index of consumer sentiment. Public Opin. Q. 2000;64:413–428. doi: 10.1086/318638. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 18.Moore D.L., Tarnai J. Evaluating nonresponse error in mail surveys. In: Groves R.M., Dillman D.A., Eltinge J.L., Little R.J.A., editors. Survey Nonresponse. John Wiley & Sons; New York: 2002. pp. 197–211. [Google Scholar]
- 19.Smith W.G. Does Gender Influence Online Survey Participation?: A Record-linkage Analysis of University Faculty Online Survey Response Behavior. 2008. http://filesericedgov/fulltext/ED501717pdf Available at: (Accessed 21/11/2014)
- 20.Biosecurity Queensland What is Hendra virus. The Dept of Agriculture, Forestry & Fisheries. Queensland Government, Brisbane, Australia. 2014. http://www.daff.qld.gov.au/animal-industries/animal-health-and-diseases/a-z-list/hendra-virus/general-information/what-is-hendra-virus (Accessed 28/12/14)
- 21.Queensland_Health Topic: Hendra virus infection: Queensland Health, Queensland Government. 2013. http://access.health.qld.gov.au/hid/InfectionsandParasites/ViralInfections/hendraVirusInfection_fs.asp (Accessed 24/04/14)
- 22.Mahalingam S., Herrero L.J., Playford E.G., Spann K., Herring B., Rolph M.S. Hendra virus: an emerging paramyxovirus in Australia. Lancet Infect. Dis. 2012;12(10):799–807. doi: 10.1016/S1473-3099(12)70158-5. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 23.Allworth A., Murray K., Morgan J. A human case of encephalitis due to a Lyssavirus recently identified in fruit bats. Commun. Dis. Intell. 1996;20(24):504. [Google Scholar]
- 24.Hanna J.N., Carney I.K., Smith G.A., Tannenberg A.E.G., Deverill J.E., Botha J.A. Australian bat lyssavirus infection: a second human case, with a long incubation period. Med. J. Aust. 2000;172(12):597–599. doi: 10.5694/j.1326-5377.2000.tb124126.x. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 25.Francis J.R., Nourse C., Vaska V.L., Calvert S., Northill J.A., McCall B. Australian Bat Lyssavirus in a child: the first reported case. Pediatrics. 2014;133:e1063–e1067. doi: 10.1542/peds.2013-1782. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 26.Biosecurity Queensland Reducing the risk of horses becoming infected with Hendra virus: Dept Agriculture and Fisheries, Brisbane, Australia. 2013. https://www.daf.qld.gov.au/animal-industries/animal-health-and-diseases/a-z-list/hendra-virus/general-information/reducing-the-risk-for-horses (Accessed 24/04/14)
- 27.Degeling C., Kerridge I. Hendra in the news: public policy meets public morality in times of zoonotic uncertainty. Soc. Sci. Med. 2013;82:156–163. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2012.12.024. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 28.Roberts B.J., Catterall C.P., Eby P., Kanowski J. Long-Distance and Frequent Movements of the Flying-Fox Pteropus poliocephalus: Implications for Management. PLoS ONE. 2012;7(8):e42532. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0042532. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 29.Anon . 2009. Yarra Bend Park Flying-fox Campsite: Review of the Management Plan. http://www.depi.vic.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0006/205953/Flying_Fox_Management_Plan_Review.pdf (Accessed 20/03/14). [Google Scholar]
- 30.Anon . 2009. Yarra Bend Park Flying-fox Campsite: Review of the Scientific Research. http://www.depi.vic.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0009/205956/Flying_Fox_Scientific_Research.pdf (Accessed 20/03/14). [Google Scholar]
- 31.2013. Royal Botanic Gardens of Sydney. Flying-fox Relocation. http://www.rbgsyd.nsw.gov.au/welcome/feature_stories/previous_feature_stories2/flying-fox_relocation (Accessed 20/03/14). [Google Scholar]
- 32.Roberts B.J., Eby P., Catterall C.P., Kanowski J., Bennett G. The outcomes and costs of relocating flying-fox camps: insights from the case of Maclean, Australia. In: Law B., Eby P., Lunney D., Lumsden L., editors. Symposium on the Biology and Conservation of Australasian Bats Sydney, Australia. 2007. pp. 277–287. [Google Scholar]

