Table 3. Characteristics of identified resources.
Abbreviations: RCDP – Rapid cycle deliberate practice STAT – Simulation team assessment tool MCAF – Megacode checklist assessment form NRPE – Neonatal resuscitation performance evaluation DASH – Debriefing assessment for simulation in healthcare
Study Characteristic | # of studies | Study IDs | |
Study Design | Randomized control trial | 3 | [30-32] |
Pretest-posttest | 5 | [25, 33-36] | |
Mixed | 1 | [37] | |
Pilot | 1 | (Lemke, et al., 2014) | |
Not yet defined | 1 | (Gross, et al., 2016) | |
Instructor guide | 4 | [38-41] | |
Participants | Pediatric residents | 5 | [25, 30-31, 36] (Gross, et al., 2016) |
Pediatric emergency fellows | 1 | [34] | |
Nurses | 1 | [35] | |
Inter-professional teams | 4 | [32-33, 37] (Lemke, et al., 2014) | |
Intervention | RCDP | 10 | [25, 30-33, 35-37] (Lemke, et al. 2014) (Gross, et al., 2016) |
RCDP and traditional simulation | 1 | [34] | |
Comparison | Traditional simulation | 7 | [30-32, 36-37] (Lemke, et al. 2014) (Gross et al., 2016) |
Standard of Practice | 1 | [25] | |
RCDP without "rewind" | 1 | (Gross, et al., 2016) | |
None | 3 | [33-35] | |
Outcomes | Qualitative evaluations | 4 | [31, 33-35] |
STAT tool score | 2 | [30] (Lemke, et al., 2014) | |
MCAF tool score | 1 | [31] | |
NRPE tool score | 1 | [32] | |
DASH tool | 1 | [34] | |
Procedural skills checklists | 2 | [34] (Gross, et al., 2016) | |
Procedure assessment (video) | 1 | (Gross, et al., 2016) | |
Time to critical intervention | 3 | [25, 30, 32] | |
Clinical reports | 1 | [35] |