Skip to main content
. 2017 Jun 1;12(6):e0178546. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0178546

Table 1. List of analysed pesticides (alphabetical order), their chemical class, agricultural role and method validation results for both LC-MSMS and GC-ECD.

      Beeswax Honeybees Honey LOD μg/kg LOQ μg/kg
No. Pesticide Chemical Class Role %recovery %RSD %recovery %RSD %recovery %RSD
1 Acetamiprid neonicotinoid I 47.2 5.4 119.8 11.1 56.3 2.4 0.003 0.010
2 Azoxystrobin strobilurin F 85.5 8.8 136.3 8.7 58.0 13.0 0.003 0.010
3 Deltamethrin pyrethroid I 94.1 5.8 x x x x 0.116 0.387
4 Boscalid anilide F 61.0 6.1 118.1 7.0 73.3 11.5 0.015 0.050
5 Carbendazim carbamate F 50.8 3.7 67.7 10.5 38.8 6.8 0.003 0.010
6 Carbofuran carbamate I 59.9 4.0 102.4 4.6 55.9 7.3 0.015 0.050
7 Chlorpyrifos organophosphate I 81.7 4.6 54.4 5.1 60.3 15.7 0.015 0.050
8 Clofentezine tetrazine I 63.8 3.6 80.1 6.9 78.3 16.6 0.030 0.100
9 Cyflufenamid amide F 48.2 2.5 61.3 7.9 68.0 15.7 0.015 0.050
10 Cypermethrin pyrethroid I 112.3 7.1 x x x x 0.588 1.959
11 Cyprodinil anilinopyrimidine F 59.8 6.2 52.20 5.9 56.1 6.1 0.003 0.010
12 Difenoconazole azole F 94.7 3.3 62.3 10.2 77.6 14.0 0.003 0.010
13 Dimethoate organophosphate I 39.6 7.1 92.2 10.5 46.8 12.6 0.030 0.100
14 Endosulfan organochlorine I 82.2 9.7 x x x x 0.055 0.184
15 Fenitrothion organophosphate I 61.3 6.4 366.9 66.0 80.7 17.4 0.150 0.500
16 Fenoxycarb carbamate I 71.9 2.5 89.6 9.4 67.8 12.6 0.003 0.010
17 Imidacloprid neonicotinoid I 55.2 15.9 111.2 19.3 50.9 8.2 0.030 0.100
18 Iprodione dicarboximide F 50.0 2.9 94.9 12.6 72.6 5.5 0.150 0.500
19 Malathion organophosphorus I 94.3 6.6 154.9 14.0 84.3 21.3 0.030 0.100
20 Metalaxyl xylalanine F 79.3 1.5 101.0 5.5 74.0 9.8 0.015 0.050
21 Methomyl carbamate I 110.0 5.6 111.5 13.3 133.1 4.5 0.018 0.059
22 O,P' -DDT organochlorine I 62.5 4.4 x x x x 0.118 0.629
23 P,P' -DDD organochlorine I 74.4 4.4 x x x x 0.056 0.187
24 P,P' -DDE organochlorine I 57.1 7.3 x x x x 0.056 0.187
25 P,P' DDT organochlorine I 63.6 4.3 x x x x 0.056 0.186
26 Penconazole azole F 82.1 7.9 99.7 4.0 73.6 12.3 0.003 0.010
27 Permethrin pyrethroid I 112.7 7.0 x x x x 0.554 1.847
28 Piperonyl-butoxide unclassified I 61.7 4.5 96.5 4.5 83.0 22.4 0.030 0.100
29 Pirimicarb carbamate I 56.1 25.2 104.7 6.3 56.3 4.8 0.003 0.010
30 Profenofos organophosphorus I 56.6 3.3 70.2 8.9 70.6 13.4 0.003 0.010
31 Pyraclostrobin strobilurin F 67.2 3.1 93.0 3.4 72.7 17.9 0.015 0.050
32 Tebuconazole azole F 79.6 2.9 114.2 23.4 75.2 12.5 0.003 0.010
33 Tebufenozide diacylhydrazine I 72.1 13.9 118.1 24.8 90.3 12.4 0.030 0.100
34 Thiram dimethyldithiocarbamate F 60.3 7.9 53.6 0.7 98.5 29.8 0.030 0.100
35 Thiamethoxam neonicotinoid I 73.8 6.8 109.5 16.4 98.1 17.4 0.150 0.500
36 Trifloxystrobin strobilurin F 54.8 1.7 66.7 7.3 77.1 17.2 0.003 0.010

Symbol interpretation; x = hive product was not analysed; F = Fungicide and I = Insecticide