Table 2.
No. | S/D | Cathode | Membranes | Inoculation | Anode | External Resistor/Ω | OCV/mV | Power Density/mW·m−2 | Ref. | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Electrode | Modification | Electrode | Volume/mL | ||||||||
1 | D | Carbon paper | NG | Nafion 117 | Activated sludge | Carbon cloth | 100 | 1000 | 650 | 776 ± 12 | [50] |
2 | D | Glassy carbon | Fe- and N-functionalized graphene | Nafion 117 | Previous reactor | Carbon felt | ~30 | 1000 | 570 | 885 | [76] |
3 | S | Carbon paper | MnO2-NTs/graphene | Nafion 117 | Previous reactor | Carbon cloth | 60 | 1000 | 613 | 4.68 W·m−3 | [113] |
4 | S | Carbon cloth | Pt-Co/G | NO | Previous reactor | Carbon cloth | 27 | 1000 | 710 | 1378 | [135] |
5 | D | Carbon cloth | Graphene/biofilm | Nafion 117 | Anaerobic activated sludge | Carbon cloth | 10 | 1000 | 390 | 323.2 ± 21 | [60] |
6 | D | Carbon cloth | NG | NO | Previous reactor | Carbon fiber brush | 20 | 1000 | 555 | 1350 ± 15 | [71] |
7 | S | Stainless steel net | NG | - | Anaerobic sludge | Carbon brush | 200 | 1500 | 243 | 1159.34 | [79] |
8 | S | Carbon Paper | Fe-NG | CEM | Anaerobic activated sludge | Carbon felt | 40 | 500 | 242 | 1149.8 | [119] |
9 | S | Stainless steel net | MnO2/GNS | - | Anaerobic sludge | Carbon felt | 200 | 1500 | 771 | 2083 | [53] |
10 | S | Carbon cloth | α-MnO2/GO | Nafion 117 | Sewage sludge | Carbon cloth | 25 | - | 710 | 3359 | [49] |
11 | S | Stainless steel mesh | Cobalt sulfides/GO | NO | Previous reactor | Graphite fiber | 28 | 1000 | 620 | 1156 ± 18 | [140] |
12 | D | Carbon cloth | NG/CoNi-alloy | CEM | - | Carbon brush | 140 | 1000 | ~700 | 2000 | [141] |
13 | S | PANI | Graphene | NO | Residual sludge | Graphite | 1800 | 500 | 640 | 99 | [51] |
14 | D | Carbon cloth | rGO particles | Ultex CMI 7000 | Anaerobic sludge | Carbon brush | 120 | 1000 | 650 | 3.3 W·m−3 | [52] |
15 | D | Carbon paper | Graphene with Iron tetrasulfophthalocyanine. | Nafion 112 | Escherichia coli | Carbon paper | 115 | - | - | 817 | [45] |
16 | S | Carbon cloth | Graphene/Pt | NO | Escherichia coli | Carbon cloth | 75 | 1000 | ~260 | 0.159 | [18] |
17 | D | Carbon cloth | NG | - | - | Carbon fiber brush | 120 | - | 840 | 4.06 W·m−3 | [142] |
18 | D | Graphene-Au-laccase hybrid | PFSA NRE-211 | Trametes versicolor | Graphene-Au | - | - | 1160 | 1.96 mW·cm−2 | [6] | |
19 | S | Carbon paper | Graphene/PANI | - | - | - | - | - | 593 | 17.95 | [143] |
20 | D | Graphite rods | Prussian blue/graphene | Nafion 117 | Previous reactor | Graphite rods | 80 | 1000 | 530 | 15.63 W·m−3 | [144] |
In the second column, “S” is for the single-air cathode MFC and “D” is for the dual-chamber MFC including the “H style” MFC. “-” means that it is not mentioned in the research. In the fourth column, “NO” represents membrane-free, and CEM represents cation exchange membrane.