Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2017 Jun 5.
Published in final edited form as: Electroanalysis. 2016 Jun 7;28(11):2644–2658. doi: 10.1002/elan.201600183

Table 2.

Comparative summary of approaches for multiplex electrochemical detection of cancer biomarker proteins

Approach Label Biomarkers Detection Limit Linear Range Ref.
Amperometry HRP-Ab2 IL-8 7.4 pg/mL 0.01–12.5 ng/mL [54]
HRP-Anti fluorescein IL-8-mRNA 3.9 fM 0.005–50 pM
MWNT-HRP-Ab2 IL-8 8 pg/mL 8–1000 pg/mL [55]
PSA 5 pg/mL 5–000 pg/mL
MP-HRP-Ab2 PSA 0.23 pg/mL 0.225–5 pg/mL [87]
IL-6 0.30 pg/mL 0.3–20 pg/mL
HRP-Ab2 CEA 1.1 µg/L 1.1–188 µg/L [57]
AFP 1.7 µg/L 1.7–250 µg/L
β-hCG 1.2 IU/L 1.2–256 IU/L
CA 125 1.7 kIU/L 1.7–334 kIU/L
ALP-Ab2 AFP 1.4 ng/mL 75–300 ng/mL [76]
Ferritin 7.0 ng/mL 50–200 ng/mL
CEA 1.2 ng/mL 12.5–100 ng/mL
hCG-β 1.8 ng/mL 12.5–100 ng/mL
CA 15-3 0.7 U/mL 75–300 ng/mL
CA 125 1.2 U/mL 12.5–100 ng/mL
CA 19-9 1.0 U/mL 25–100 ng/mL
HRP-Ab2 CEA 0.2 ng/mL 0.2–200 ng/mL [85]
CA 15-3 5.2 U/mL 5.2–100 U/mL
Ab2-MB-HRP IL-6 5 fg/mL 5–1000 fg/mL [88]
IL-8 10 fg/mL 10–1000 fg/mL
VEGF 5 fg/mL 5–1000 fg/mL
VEGF-C 50 fg/mL 50–1500 fg/mL
Ab2-MB-HRP IL-6 5 fg/mL 5–2500 fg/mL [89]
IL-8 7 fg/mL 7–3750 fg/mL
Ab2-MB-HRP IL-6 18 fg/mL 0.018–4.5 pg/mL [50]
TNF-α 10 fg/mL 0.01–12 pg/mL
CRP 15 fg/mL 0.015–11 pg/mL
IL-1β 40 fg/mL 0.04–22 pg/mL
Square Wave Voltammetry AuNR-HRP-Ab2 p53392 5 pM 0.01–20 nM [59]
p5315 20 pM 0.05–20 nM
p5346 30 pM 0.1–50 nM
p53 10 pM 0.05–20 nM
NSC-Ab2 CA 125 0.08 mU/mL 0.0001–100 U/mL [98]
CA 199 0.10 mU/mL 0.0001–100 U/mL
Cyclic voltammetry AuNR-HRP-Ab2 PSA 0.1 ng/mL 0.1–10 ng/mL [60]
IL-6 5 pg/mL 5–1000 pg/mL
PSMA 0.8 ng/mL 0.8–400 ng/mL
NiFe2O4-SiO2-Ab2 AFP < 0.5 µg/L 2–180 µg/L [84]
CEA < 0.5 µg/L 1.5–200 µg/L
CA 125 < 0.5 µg/L 3.2–60 kU/L
CA 15-3 < 0.5 µg/L 2.5–240 kU/L
NGC-McAb2 CEA 0.06 pg/mL 0.0001–100 ng/mL [97]
AFP 0.08 pg/mL 0.0001–100 ng/mL

NSC – Nanoporous silver chitosan; ngNGS – Nanoporous gold chitosan; MP – Superparamagnetic particle