Skip to main content
. 2017 Jun 8;12(6):e0178494. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0178494

Table 3. Effects of irrigation and nitrogen application on TAA, EAA and NAA content in wheat grain in 2012/2013, 2013/2014 and 2014/2015, and interactions between irrigation and nitrogen application; summary of F significance from analysis of variance of the effects of main factors and interaction.

Treatment TAA (mg·g-1) EAA (mg·g-1) NAA (mg·g-1) EAA/TAA (%)
2012/2013 2013/2014 2014/2015 2012/2013 2013/2014 2014/2015 2012/2013 2013/2014 2014/2015 2012/2013 2013/2014 2014/2015
I0 127.29 128.98a 125.30 38.93 40.33a 38.46 88.36 88.65a 86.84 30.61 31.32b 30.75
I1 119.40 125.25b 126.18 38.08 39.73ab 38.55 81.40 85.53b 87.63 30.90 31.79a 30.66
I2 125.92 124.14b 131.30 38.85 39.36b 40.28 87.07 84.78b 91.02 31.02 31.74a 30.83
F-test ns ** ns ns * ns ns ** ns ns ** ns
N0 114.38b 115.72c 96.69c 35.56c 37.08c 30.91c 78.82b 59.64c 65.78c 31.28a 32.04a 31.98a
N180 122.84b 121.34b 134.62b 38.06bc 38.44b 40.82b 84.79b 82.90b 93.80b 31.03ab 31.71a 30.33b
N240 136.02a 133.37a 138.33a 41.41ab 41.62a 42.03a 94.72a 91.74a 96.30a 30.54b 31.21b 30.39b
N300 140.23a 134.06a 140.73a 42.80a 42.07a 42.62a 97.43a 91.99a 98.11a 30.52b 31.39b 30.29b
F-test ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** * * **
I0×N0 107.63b 136.60a 99.43b 33.46b 42.47a 31.33b 74.17b 94.13a 68.10b 31.09a 31.09b 31.52a
I0×N180 131.43a 104.27b 131.57a 40.10a 33.43b 40.13a 91.33a 70.83b 91.43a 30.51b 32.07a 30.51b
I0×N240 134.83a 137.20a 132.83a 40.90a 42.40a 40.57a 93.93a 94.80a 92.27a 30.33b 30.91b 30.54b
I0×N300 135.27a 137.87a 137.37a 41.27a 43.03a 41.80a 94.00a 94.83a 95.57a 30.51b 31.21b 30.43b
F-test ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** **
I1×N0 144.10 103.40b 94.20c 43.43 33.90b 30.07c 100.67 69.50b 64.13c 30.15 32.78a 31.92a
I1×N180 106.43 130.50a 132.43b 33.77 41.27a 40.20b 72.67 89.23a 92.23b 31.74 31.63b 30.35b
I1×N240 131.00 133.27a 138.07a 40.53 41.63a 41.77a 90.80 91.63a 96.30a 31.15 31.24b 30.25b
I1×N300 146.07 133.83a 140.03a 44.60 42.10a 42.17a 101.47 91.73a 97.87a 30.55 31.46b 30.11b
F-test ns ** ** ns ** ** ns ** ** ns ** **
I2×N0 91.40b 107.17b 96.43b 29.77b 34.87b 31.33c 61.63b 72.30b 65.10b 32.58a 32.54a 32.49a
I2×N180 130.67a 129.27a 139.87a 40.30a 40.63a 42.13b 90.37a 88.63a 97.73a 30.85b 31.43b 30.12b
I2×N240 142.23a 129.63a 144.10a 42.80a 40.83a 43.77a 99.43a 88.80a 100.33a 30.12b 31.50b 30.37b
I2×N300 139.37a 130.50a 144.80a 42.53a 41.10a 43.90a 96.83a 89.40a 100.90a 30.52b 31.49b 30.32b
F-test ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** **
Grand mean 124.23 126.13 127.60 38.62 39.81 39.10 85.61 86.32 88.50 30.84 31.62 30.75
I×N (F-test) ** ** * ** ** ** ** ** * ** ** **
CV (%) 13.15 0.84 0.87 3.37 0.19 0.22 9.71 0.68 0.68 1.10 0.20 0.14

Note: TAA: total amino acid; EAA: essential amino acid; NAA: non-essential amino acid. ns, not significant at P < 0.05;

* Significant at P < 0.05;

** Significant at P < 0.01; Data in the same column with different letters indicate a significant difference at P < 0.05.