Table 2.
Guinea, Conakry | Uganda, Kitgum | Uganda, Arua | Kenya, Homa Bay | Cameroun, Douala | DRC, Baraka | Total | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Sensitivity; 95% CI | |||||||
Determine | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 99.7–100 |
Uni-Gold | 100; 98.3–100 | 96.2; 77.9–99.5 | 100; 98.3–100 | 99.6; 96.8–99.9 | 100; 98.3–100 | 99.6; 96.8–99.9 | 99.5; 98.1–99.9 |
Genie Fast | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 99.6; 96.8–99.9 | 100; 99.8–100 |
Vikia | 100; 98.3–100 | 96.2; 77.9–99.5 | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 99.5; 96.7–99.7 | 99.6; 96.8–99.9 | 99.6; 98.1–99.9 |
STAT-PAK | 100; 98.3–100 | 96.2; 77.9–99.5 | 100; 98.3–100 | 99.6; 96.8–99.9 | 99.5; 96.7–99.7 | 100; 98.3–100 | 99.5; 98.1–99.8 |
INSTI | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 99.7–100 |
SD Bioline | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 99.6; 97.0–99.9 | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 99.7–100 |
First Response | 100; 98.3–100 | 96.2; 77.9–99.5 | 99.1; 96.6–99.8 | 100; 98.3–100 | 97.7; 94.5–99.0 | 96.8; 93.5–98.5 | 98.8; 97.7–99.4 |
Specificity; 95% CI | |||||||
Determine | 99.0; 97.7–99.6 | 93.1; 88.8–95.8 | 94.4; 90.6–96.8 | 94.4; 91.0–96.5 | 92.4; 88.8–94.9 | 91.9; 87.8–94.7 | 93.9; 92.6–95.0 |
Uni-Gold | 99.2; 94.7–99.9 | 98.2; 95.2–99.3 | 96.9; 93.7–98.5 | 99.0; 96.9–99.7 | 97.8; 94.7–98.8 | 96.5; 93.3–98.2 | 97.8; 96.9–98.5 |
Genie Fast | 97.5; 93.9–99.0 | 93.5; 89.4–96.1 | 88.0; 83.1–91.6 | 96.5; 93.5–98.1 | 95.2; 91.7–97.2 | 95.7; 92.5–97.6 | 94.1; 92.7–95.3 |
Vikia | 99.0; 97.7–99.6 | 96.8; 93.4–98.5 | 96.3; 93.0–98.1 | 96.9; 94.1–98.4 | 97.5; 95.1–98.8 | 96.8; 93.8–98.4 | 97.2; 96.2–97.9 |
STAT-PAK | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 99.9; 99.5–100 | 98.6; 96.2–99.5 | 99.6; 98.3–99.9 | 99.9; 99.7–100 | 99.7; 99.4–99.9 |
INSTI | 98.0; 94.1–99.3 | 96.3; 92.8–98.2 | 90.4; 85.8–93.6 | 96.8; 94.0–98.3 | 84.9; 79.8–88.9 | 80.4; 74.8–85.0 | 90.6; 88.9–92.0 |
SD Bioline | 99.7; 98.7–99.9 | 98.6; 95.8–99.5 | 95.6; 92.0–97.6 | 96.8; 94.0–98.4 | 98.7; 96.2–99.6 | 96.6; 93.4–98.3 | 97.6; 96.5–98.4 |
First Response | 98.0; 94.1–99.3 | 90.4; 85.7–93.6 | 77.0; 71.1–82.0 | 85.3; 80.6–89.0 | 99.8; 98.5–100 | 93.2; 89.1–95.8 | 90.4; 88.7–91.8 |
Positive predictive value; 95% CI | |||||||
Determine | 97.5; 94.4–98.9 | 63.4; 50.6–74.5 | 72.3; 60.5–81.7 | 91.6; 86.7–94.8 | 85.4; 79.2–90.0 | 51.8; 40.5–62.9 | 82.0; 78.6–85.0 |
Uni-Gold | 98.1; 87.5–99.7 | 86.3; 70.0–94.5 | 84.4; 71.6–92.0 | 98.4; 95.1–99.5 | 94.7; 89.1–97.5 | 71.2; 55.6–83.0 | 92.6; 89.7–94.7 |
Genie Fast | 94.0; 86.0–97.5 | 65.0; 51.9–76.2 | 57.3; 47.3–66.8 | 94.5; 90.1–97.0 | 90.3; 83.9–94.3 | 66.8; 52.5–78.5 | 82.5; 78.8–85.6 |
Vikia | 97.5; 94.4–98.9 | 78.3; 62.8–88.5 | 82.0; 69.5–90.1 | 95.2; 91.0–97.5 | 94.7; 89.7–97.3 | 73.0; 57.5–84.3 | 90.7; 87.8–93.0 |
STAT-PAK | 100; 98.4–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 99.6; 97.0–99.9 | 97.7; 94.0–99.1 | 99.1; 96.3–99.8 | 98.7; 96.1–99.6 | 99.0; 97.9–99.5 |
INSTI | 95.1; 86.4–98.3 | 76.6; 61.7–97.0 | 61.9; 51.2–71.5 | 94.5; 90.1–97.0 | 74.7; 67.5–80.8 | 30.7; 24.3–37.8 | 74.6; 71.1–77.9 |
SD Bioline | 99.2; 96.7–99.8 | 89.5; 73.6–96.3 | 79.0; 66.5–87.8 | 95.1; 90.8–97.4 | 97.3; 91.9–99.1 | 71.7 55.9–83.5 | 92.0; 88.7–94.4 |
First Response | 95.1; 86.4–98.3 | 54.5; 43.3–65.2 | 41.8; 34.3–49.6 | 80.6; 74.9–85.3 | 99.5; 96.7–99.9 | 55.2; 42.4–67.3 | 73.9; 70.3–77.3 |
Negative predictive value; 95% CI | |||||||
Determine | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.2–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.6–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.4–100 | 100; 99.7–100 |
Uni-Gold | 100; 98.4–100 | 99.5; 96.8–99.9 | 100; 98.3–100 | 99.7; 98.1–100 | 100; 98.5–100 | 100; 99.7–100 | 99.9; 99.5–100 |
Genie Fast | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.2–100 | 100; 98.2–100 | 100; 98.6–100 | 100; 98.4–100 | 100; 99.7–100 | 100; 99.9–100 |
Vikia | 100; 98.3–100 | 99.5; 96.7–99.9 | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.6–100 | 99.8; 98.5–100 | 100; 99.7–100 | 99.9; 99.5–100 |
STAT-PAK | 100; 98.4–100 | 99.5; 96.8–99.9 | 100; 98.4–100 | 99.7; 98.1–100 | 99.8; 98.5–100 | 100; 98.7–100 | 99.9; 99.5–100 |
INSTI | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.2–100 | 100; 98.6–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 100; 99.7–100 |
SD Bioline | 100; 98.4–100 | 100; 98.3–100 | 99.9; 99.5–100 | 100; 98.6–100 | 100; 98.5–100 | 100; 98.6–100 | 100; 99.9–100 |
First Response | 100; 98.3–100 | 99.5; 96.5–99.9 | 99.8; 99.3–100 | 100; 98.4–100 | 99.0; 97.5–99.6 | 99.7; 99.4–99.9 | 99.7; 99.3–99.9 |