Altshuler 1971 USA |
Clinical observations (16 years total) |
1,000 New York State inpatients and outpatients |
General lack of language exposure during early development |
|
Schizophrenia prevalence comparable to general population, impulsive/aggressive behaviors, less depressive symptoms |
Altshuler 1986 USA |
Literature review |
Literature review |
General lack of language exposure during early development |
|
Schizophrenic presentation different in deaf individuals, impulsive/aggressive behaviors common |
Anderson 2011 USA |
Quantitative study of trauma prevalence |
100 deaf female college students |
75 ASL, 21 English, 4 other |
|
Deaf females approximately two times as likely to experience interpersonal victimization and trauma as hearing females |
Anderson 2016 USA |
Qualitative study of deaf-unique trauma experiences |
17 deaf trauma survivors |
ASL |
|
Some trauma experiences overlap with general population, others are unique to deaf people (i.e., lack of communication with family) |
Barker 2009 USA |
Analysis of language and behavior problems |
188 families with implanted, deaf children compared to 97 families with hearing children |
Spoken English |
Cochlear implant |
Implanted children evidenced more behavior problems, oral language deficits, and parent-child communication than hearing children |
Barnett 2011 USA |
Literature review and commentary |
Literature review and commentary |
Limited access to environmental information |
|
Low health literacy and health disparities exist in Deaf sign language populations |
Basilier 1964 Norway |
Theoretical review |
Theoretical review |
General lack of language exposure during early development |
|
Associates general experience of deafness with a “deaf personality structure” and stresses a need for specialized psychiatric services |
Black 2006 USA |
Archival analysis of clinical records |
64 discharged deaf inpatients |
75% of deaf inpatients classified as “language deprived” or “dysfluent due to language deprivation” |
|
Deaf inpatients more likely to present associated behavior issues with language deprivation than a psychotic disorder diagnosis |
Cooper 1976 England |
Literature review |
Literature review |
Differences in psychiatric presentation depending on hearing loss onset and severity |
|
Highlights “problems of behavior and maladjustment related to deafness” as most common disorders in psychiatric literature as well as general knowledge deficits especially with early onset |
Denmark 1971 England |
Literature review |
Literature review |
Highlights relationship between deafness and psychiatry relating to impoverished language exposure |
|
Personality development of deaf child described as “developmental retardation,” risk of general knowledge deficits |
Denmark 1972 England |
Describes process and barriers in establishing psychiatric unit for deaf people |
109 deaf inpatients at time of publication |
Inpatients generally had poor language exposure, and “educational retardation” |
Staff communication in sign language beneficial for treatment, hired teacher for social skills training |
Highlights psychiatric diagnosis as complex and time-consuming, describes patients as impulsive and lacking skills |
Fellinger 2012 Austria |
Literature review |
Literature review |
Connects poor language abilities with behavioral and psychosocial problems |
|
Generally suggests prevalence of mental and behavioral health issues in deaf people to be elevated compared to general population, highlights lack of access to treatment |
Gaines 2009 USA |
Analysis of language and learning challenges in hearing adolescent inpatients |
34 adolescent hearing inpatients |
Generally had native language exposure but poor language skills |
Concrete skills development, rather than traditional talk therapies |
Poor language skills associated with psychiatric disorders and inpatient hospitalization in hearing adolescents |
Giddan 1996 USA |
Study of speech and language deficits prevalence in preadolescent hearing inpatients |
55 preadolescent hearing inpatients |
Native language exposure but clear speech and language deficits |
|
60% of admitted inpatients had speech and language deficits, most prevalent in those with anxiety and aggressive conduct disorder |
Glickman 2007 USA |
Case study of deaf inpatient with language dysfluency |
Deaf inpatient (“Juanita”) |
Little to no education or sign language exposure |
|
In-depth description of language dysfluency features connected to language deprivation |
Glickman 2009a USA |
Literature review and commentary |
Literature review and commentary |
Offers diagnostic criteria for “language deprivation with deficiencies in behavioral, emotional, and social adjustment” |
|
Highlights social causes of language deprivation, potential co-morbidity of language deprivation with various behavioral diagnoses |
Hauser 2010 USA |
Literature review and commentary |
Literature review and commentary |
Highlights dinner table syndrome and general worldly knowledge deficits |
|
Deaf individuals at risk for physical and mental health issues, less health literacy and knowledge |
Horton 2010 USA |
Study of sign language ability, cognition and functional status in deaf outpatients with schizophrenia |
34 deaf outpatients with schizophrenia |
Earlier sign language exposure associated with greater functional outcomes |
|
Better language ability appears to improve functional outcomes of deaf individuals with schizophrenia |
Huber 2011 USA |
Quantitative study of mental health status |
32 deaf adolescents with cochlear implant, 212 hearing adolescents |
Spoken language |
Cochlear implant |
Implanted children more likely to experience peer problems, signing ability may have a relationship with emotional problems |
Kitson 1990 England |
Literature review and commentary |
Literature review and commentary |
General lack of language exposure during early development |
|
Suggests that increased prevalence of mental health issues in deaf people is related to spoken-language policy in their education |
Lane 1976 USA |
Literature review and commentary |
A hearing feral child, the Wild Boy of Aveyron |
Raised by animals, delayed exposure to language |
|
Described as “feral” and not being able to behave appropriately according to social norms |
Long 1993 USA |
Literature review and commentary |
Literature review and commentary |
Delayed language exposure creates “traditionally underserved” deaf individuals |
|
Limited communication skills, difficulty maintaining employment without support, poor socio-emotional skills, inability to live independently |
McKee 2015 USA |
Quantitative study of health literacy assessment |
166 deaf individuals and 239 hearing individuals |
Health literacy was correlated with reading literacy |
|
48% of deaf participants had inadequate health literacy, 6.9 times more likely than hearing individuals |
Pollard 2014 USA |
Quantitative study of intimate partner violence |
308 deaf individuals from Rochester, 162 deaf individuals from national sample, 1,906 hearing individuals from Monroe County, NY |
Ranging language experiences |
|
Deaf individuals more likely to experience emotional abuse and forced sex from their partner than hearing individuals |
Pollard 1998 USA |
Literature review and commentary |
Literature review and commentary |
Generally highlights delayed language exposure in deaf mental health population |
|
Describes language dysfluency as separate from psychotic symptoms |
Rainer 1966 USA |
Report of comprehensive mental health services for the deaf in New York State |
Literature review and commentary |
Generally highlights delayed language exposure in deaf mental health population |
|
Highlights deaf patients not fitting existing diagnostic criteria, discusses “Primitive Personality Disorder” existing in the deaf mental health population |
Schenkel 2014 USA |
Study of maltreatment and trauma prevalence |
147 deaf college students, 317 hearing college students |
Ranging language experiences |
|
Deaf participants more at risk for maltreatment and trauma experiences, general knowledge deficits as well |
Sinkkonen 1994 Finland |
Dissertation study |
379 deaf students, 234 hearing students |
Early exposure for deaf children with signing hearing parents |
|
Found no difference in mental health prevalence between signing deaf and hearing children |
Stevenson 2010 USA |
Quantitative study of language development and behavior problems |
120 children with hearing loss, 63 hearing children |
Spoken English (signing children excluded from analyses) |
Cochlear implant in some participants |
Children with hearing loss had higher behavior problems, level of problems were highest among those children with least developed language |
Thacker 1994 England |
Quantitative study of sign language use in schizophrenic patients |
30 schizophrenic and 7 maniac deaf adults |
British Sign Language as primary means of communication |
|
Formal communication disorder can occur in sign language |
van Gent 2011 USA |
Quantitative study of psychosocial risk factors |
68 deaf adolescents |
Spoken Dutch |
|
Deaf adolescents at risk for self-esteem issues, emotional problems, and hearing peer rejection |
Vernon 1969 USA |
Book chapter focusing on hearing loss sociological and psychological factors |
Literature review and commentary |
Discusses delayed language exposure in deaf population |
|
Generally suggests intelligence of deaf people to be comparable to hearing people, highlights social causes of deaf people’s lagging achievement in multiple developmental and educational areas from delayed language exposure |
Vernon 1997 USA |
Literature review and commentary |
Literature review and commentary |
Severely delayed language exposure |
|
Suggests “Primitive Personality: Surdophrenia” and potential diagnostic criteria for especially deaf individuals with language deprivation who are placed in the legal system |
Vernon 1968 USA |
Literature review and commentary |
Literature review and commentary |
Discusses the deaf population as generally language-delayed |
|
Delayed language exposure leads to defensive mechanisms, lack of insight, psychological immaturity, impulsiveness, higher incidence of certain psychiatric disorders |
Weiler 2013 USA |
Case study |
Deaf inpatient (“D.S.”) |
Complex history with incomplete language records and potential brain-based issues from pre-natal rubella |
Risperidone, divalproex sodium |
Physical aggression, paranoia, thought disorganization, learning difficulties, minimal language skills |