Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2018 Jun 1.
Published in final edited form as: Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol. 2017 Feb 16;52(6):761–776. doi: 10.1007/s00127-017-1351-7
First author Type of publication Deaf individuals Language exposure Intervention (if applicable) Mental health/behavioral outcomes
Altshuler 1971 USA Clinical observations (16 years total) 1,000 New York State inpatients and outpatients General lack of language exposure during early development Schizophrenia prevalence comparable to general population, impulsive/aggressive behaviors, less depressive symptoms
Altshuler 1986 USA Literature review Literature review General lack of language exposure during early development Schizophrenic presentation different in deaf individuals, impulsive/aggressive behaviors common
Anderson 2011 USA Quantitative study of trauma prevalence 100 deaf female college students 75 ASL, 21 English, 4 other Deaf females approximately two times as likely to experience interpersonal victimization and trauma as hearing females
Anderson 2016 USA Qualitative study of deaf-unique trauma experiences 17 deaf trauma survivors ASL Some trauma experiences overlap with general population, others are unique to deaf people (i.e., lack of communication with family)
Barker 2009 USA Analysis of language and behavior problems 188 families with implanted, deaf children compared to 97 families with hearing children Spoken English Cochlear implant Implanted children evidenced more behavior problems, oral language deficits, and parent-child communication than hearing children
Barnett 2011 USA Literature review and commentary Literature review and commentary Limited access to environmental information Low health literacy and health disparities exist in Deaf sign language populations
Basilier 1964 Norway Theoretical review Theoretical review General lack of language exposure during early development Associates general experience of deafness with a “deaf personality structure” and stresses a need for specialized psychiatric services
Black 2006 USA Archival analysis of clinical records 64 discharged deaf inpatients 75% of deaf inpatients classified as “language deprived” or “dysfluent due to language deprivation” Deaf inpatients more likely to present associated behavior issues with language deprivation than a psychotic disorder diagnosis
Cooper 1976 England Literature review Literature review Differences in psychiatric presentation depending on hearing loss onset and severity Highlights “problems of behavior and maladjustment related to deafness” as most common disorders in psychiatric literature as well as general knowledge deficits especially with early onset
Denmark 1971 England Literature review Literature review Highlights relationship between deafness and psychiatry relating to impoverished language exposure Personality development of deaf child described as “developmental retardation,” risk of general knowledge deficits
Denmark 1972 England Describes process and barriers in establishing psychiatric unit for deaf people 109 deaf inpatients at time of publication Inpatients generally had poor language exposure, and “educational retardation” Staff communication in sign language beneficial for treatment, hired teacher for social skills training Highlights psychiatric diagnosis as complex and time-consuming, describes patients as impulsive and lacking skills
Fellinger 2012 Austria Literature review Literature review Connects poor language abilities with behavioral and psychosocial problems Generally suggests prevalence of mental and behavioral health issues in deaf people to be elevated compared to general population, highlights lack of access to treatment
Gaines 2009 USA Analysis of language and learning challenges in hearing adolescent inpatients 34 adolescent hearing inpatients Generally had native language exposure but poor language skills Concrete skills development, rather than traditional talk therapies Poor language skills associated with psychiatric disorders and inpatient hospitalization in hearing adolescents
Giddan 1996 USA Study of speech and language deficits prevalence in preadolescent hearing inpatients 55 preadolescent hearing inpatients Native language exposure but clear speech and language deficits 60% of admitted inpatients had speech and language deficits, most prevalent in those with anxiety and aggressive conduct disorder
Glickman 2007 USA Case study of deaf inpatient with language dysfluency Deaf inpatient (“Juanita”) Little to no education or sign language exposure In-depth description of language dysfluency features connected to language deprivation
Glickman 2009a USA Literature review and commentary Literature review and commentary Offers diagnostic criteria for “language deprivation with deficiencies in behavioral, emotional, and social adjustment” Highlights social causes of language deprivation, potential co-morbidity of language deprivation with various behavioral diagnoses
Hauser 2010 USA Literature review and commentary Literature review and commentary Highlights dinner table syndrome and general worldly knowledge deficits Deaf individuals at risk for physical and mental health issues, less health literacy and knowledge
Horton 2010 USA Study of sign language ability, cognition and functional status in deaf outpatients with schizophrenia 34 deaf outpatients with schizophrenia Earlier sign language exposure associated with greater functional outcomes Better language ability appears to improve functional outcomes of deaf individuals with schizophrenia
Huber 2011 USA Quantitative study of mental health status 32 deaf adolescents with cochlear implant, 212 hearing adolescents Spoken language Cochlear implant Implanted children more likely to experience peer problems, signing ability may have a relationship with emotional problems
Kitson 1990 England Literature review and commentary Literature review and commentary General lack of language exposure during early development Suggests that increased prevalence of mental health issues in deaf people is related to spoken-language policy in their education
Lane 1976 USA Literature review and commentary A hearing feral child, the Wild Boy of Aveyron Raised by animals, delayed exposure to language Described as “feral” and not being able to behave appropriately according to social norms
Long 1993 USA Literature review and commentary Literature review and commentary Delayed language exposure creates “traditionally underserved” deaf individuals Limited communication skills, difficulty maintaining employment without support, poor socio-emotional skills, inability to live independently
McKee 2015 USA Quantitative study of health literacy assessment 166 deaf individuals and 239 hearing individuals Health literacy was correlated with reading literacy 48% of deaf participants had inadequate health literacy, 6.9 times more likely than hearing individuals
Pollard 2014 USA Quantitative study of intimate partner violence 308 deaf individuals from Rochester, 162 deaf individuals from national sample, 1,906 hearing individuals from Monroe County, NY Ranging language experiences Deaf individuals more likely to experience emotional abuse and forced sex from their partner than hearing individuals
Pollard 1998 USA Literature review and commentary Literature review and commentary Generally highlights delayed language exposure in deaf mental health population Describes language dysfluency as separate from psychotic symptoms
Rainer 1966 USA Report of comprehensive mental health services for the deaf in New York State Literature review and commentary Generally highlights delayed language exposure in deaf mental health population Highlights deaf patients not fitting existing diagnostic criteria, discusses “Primitive Personality Disorder” existing in the deaf mental health population
Schenkel 2014 USA Study of maltreatment and trauma prevalence 147 deaf college students, 317 hearing college students Ranging language experiences Deaf participants more at risk for maltreatment and trauma experiences, general knowledge deficits as well
Sinkkonen 1994 Finland Dissertation study 379 deaf students, 234 hearing students Early exposure for deaf children with signing hearing parents Found no difference in mental health prevalence between signing deaf and hearing children
Stevenson 2010 USA Quantitative study of language development and behavior problems 120 children with hearing loss, 63 hearing children Spoken English (signing children excluded from analyses) Cochlear implant in some participants Children with hearing loss had higher behavior problems, level of problems were highest among those children with least developed language
Thacker 1994 England Quantitative study of sign language use in schizophrenic patients 30 schizophrenic and 7 maniac deaf adults British Sign Language as primary means of communication Formal communication disorder can occur in sign language
van Gent 2011 USA Quantitative study of psychosocial risk factors 68 deaf adolescents Spoken Dutch Deaf adolescents at risk for self-esteem issues, emotional problems, and hearing peer rejection
Vernon 1969 USA Book chapter focusing on hearing loss sociological and psychological factors Literature review and commentary Discusses delayed language exposure in deaf population Generally suggests intelligence of deaf people to be comparable to hearing people, highlights social causes of deaf people’s lagging achievement in multiple developmental and educational areas from delayed language exposure
Vernon 1997 USA Literature review and commentary Literature review and commentary Severely delayed language exposure Suggests “Primitive Personality: Surdophrenia” and potential diagnostic criteria for especially deaf individuals with language deprivation who are placed in the legal system
Vernon 1968 USA Literature review and commentary Literature review and commentary Discusses the deaf population as generally language-delayed Delayed language exposure leads to defensive mechanisms, lack of insight, psychological immaturity, impulsiveness, higher incidence of certain psychiatric disorders
Weiler 2013 USA Case study Deaf inpatient (“D.S.”) Complex history with incomplete language records and potential brain-based issues from pre-natal rubella Risperidone, divalproex sodium Physical aggression, paranoia, thought disorganization, learning difficulties, minimal language skills