Table 1. Summary of studies using tES assumed to target PAC for the investigation of speech and non-speech auditory perception (non-speech studies are marked with an asterisk).
Study | population | N | Method | “Active” electrode | “Reference” electrode | Protocol | Timing | Outcome | Control |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Marques et al. (2014) | Healthy | 24 | tDCS | T3/T4 (corr. to T7/T8) | Right deltoid muscle | 20 min. of 2 mA | Online | Bilateral cathodal (but not anodal) tDCS decreases McGurk effect | Sham (same subjects) |
Heimrath, Fischer, et al. 2016 | Healthy | 13 | tDCS | T7/T8 | Cz | 22 min. of 1.5 mA | Online | Bilateral cathodal (but not anodal) tDCS improves phonetic categorisation | Sham (same subjects) |
Neuling, Rach, Wagner, Wolters, and Herrmann (2012)* | Healthy | 16 | otDCS | T7/T8 | n/a | DC of 1 mA + 10 Hz AC of 0.425 mA (mean), 2 × 21 min. | Online | Detection of non-speech target tones embedded in noise depends on phase of the imposed current | No control |
Riecke, Formisano, et al. (2015)* | Healthy | 14 | tACS | T7/T8 | Cz | 4 Hz, 0.8 mA (mean), 39.6 min. | Online | Detection of click trains depends on phase of the imposed current | Sham (same subjects) |
Riecke, Sack, et al. (2015)* | Healthy | 20 | tACS | T7/T8 | Cz | 4 Hz, 0.8 mA (mean), 40 min. | Online | Time required to segregate non-speech target sounds from background sounds depends on tACS phase | Sham (same subjects) |
Rufener, Zaehle, et al. (2016) | Healthy | 21 (+17 for no stim.) | tACS | T7/T8 | n/a | 40 Hz, 1.1 mA (mean), 18 min. | Offline | 40-Hz (but not 6-Hz) tACS impairs learning performance in phonetic categorisation task | No stimulation, control frequency |
Rufener, Oechslin, et al. (2016) | Healthy | 25 | tACS | T7/T8 | n/a | 40 Hz, 1.38 mA (mean), 8 min. | Online | Replicate previous study and show that results are reversed for older listeners | Control frequency |
Note: Stimulation methods (tDCS/tACS/otDCS and electrode locations) are illustrated in Figure 1.