TABLE 2.
Studies Enrolled | Country | Study Period | wk/g | CA/CP | Singleton/Twin | CP Diagnosed Age | Study Type by Original Authors | Study Quality | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
CCA in preterm CP | |||||||||
Accordino et al42 2016: 1 | Italy | 2006–2012 | 24–34 | 2/26: 6/142 | Singleton | 1 y | Retrospective | Good | PPROM and PTL |
Manuck et al43 2014 | United States | 1997–2004 | <34 | 62/459: 161/1312 | Both | 2 y | Second RCT | Good | Same cohort as in ref 25 |
Skrablin et al44 2008 | Croatia | 1999–2001 | <37 | 7/35: 3/35 | Both | >2 y | Case-control | Good | |
Neufeld et al45 2005: 1 | United States | 1987–1999 | <37 | 33/247: 9/180 | Singleton | ≤6 y | Case-control | Fair | |
Takahashi et al46 2005 | Japan | 1990–1998 | 22–33 | 3/30: 17/150 | Both | 4 y | Retrospective cohort | Good | |
Vigneswaran et al47 2004: 1 | Australia | 1984–1994 | <1500 g | 10/82: 27/207 | Singleton | 5 y | Case-control | Good | Minimal CP excluded |
Nelson et al48 2003: 1 | United States | 1988–1994 | <32 | 20/64: 29/107 | Singleton | 4 y | Case-control | Good | Postnatally caused CP excluded |
Jacobsson et al49 2002: 1 | Sweden | 1983–1990 | <37 | 16/148: 19/296 | Both | ≥4 y | Case-control | Good | Postnatally caused CP excluded |
Gray et al50 2001 | Australia | 1989–1996 | 24–27 | 9/30: 26/120 | Both | ≥2 y | Case-control | Good | |
Matsuda et al51 2000: 1 | Japan | 1992–1996 | 26–30 | 6/22: 19/170 | Singleton | >2 y | Case-control | Fair | Not matched |
Redline et al52 2000: 1 | United States | 1983–1991 | <1500 g | 17/60: 7/59 | Singleton | 20 mo | Case-control | Good | |
Yoon et al53 2000: 1 | Korea | 1993–1995 | ≤35 | 2/14: 7/109 | Singleton | 3 y | Cohort | Good | |
Wilson-Costello et al54 1998 | United States | 1983–1991 | <1500 g | 11/50: 6/50 | Singleton | 20 mo | Case-control | Good | |
O’Shea et al55 1998a | United States | 1978–1989 | 500–1500 g | 21/160: 10/80 | Both | 1 y | Case-control | Fair | Postnatally caused CP excluded |
O’Shea et al56 1998b: 1 | United States | 1986–1993 | 500–1500 g | 12/52: 11/110 | Singleton | 1 y | Case-control | Fair | Postnatally caused CP excluded |
Yoon et al57 1997: 1 | Korea | 1993–1995 | 26–35 | 1/8: 4/75 | Singleton | 6 mo | Retrospective cohort | Fair | May have PIH |
Cooke58 1990 | United Kingdom | 1980–1986 | <1501 g | 17/81: 6/81 | Both | 2 y | Case-control | Good | |
CCA in term/ near-term CP | |||||||||
Neufeld et al45 2005: 2 | United States | 1987–1999 | ≥37 | 7/395: 25/2675 | Singleton | ≤6 y | Case-control | Fair | |
Wu et al59 2003: 1 | United States | 1991–1998 | ≥36 | 15/106: 9/215 | Singleton | >15 mo | Case-control | Good | Postnatally caused CP excluded |
Grether and Nelson60 1997: 1 | United States | 1983–1985 | ≥2500 g | 5/46: 5/378 | Singleton | 3 y | Case-control | Good | Postnatally caused CP excluded |
HCA in preterm CP | |||||||||
Accordino et al42 2016: 2 | Italy | 2006–2012 | 24–34 | 8/26: 57/142 | Singleton | 1 y | Retrospective | Good | PPROM and PTL |
Huetz et al33 2016 | France | 2008–2011 | 24–34 | 4/17: 32/179 | Singleton | 2 y | Cohort | Good | |
Horvath et al61 2012 | Hungary | 2000–2010 | <1500 g | 7/11: 36/130 | NA | >1 y | Cohort | Fair | |
Redline et al62 2007 | United States | 1992–1995 | <1000 g | 8/18: 61/111 | Singleton | 8 y | Cohort | Good | |
Vigneswaran et al47 2004: 2 | Australia | — | <1500 g | 22/54: 56/150 | Singleton | 5 y | Case-control | Good | |
Nelson et al48 2003: 2 | United States | 1988–1994 | <32 | 31/64: 58/107 | Singleton | 4 y | Case-control | Good | Postnatally caused CP excluded |
Jacobsson et al49 2002: 2 | Sweden | 1983–1990 | <37 | 10/28: 6/45 | Both | >4 y | Case-control | Good | |
Matsuda et al51 2000: 2 | Japan | 1992–1996 | 26–30 | 8/22: 61/170 | Singleton | >2 y | Case-control | Good | Not matched |
Redline et al52 2000: 2 | United States | 1983–1991 | <1500 g | 37/60: 35/59 | Singleton | 20 mo | Case-control | Good | |
Yoon et al53 2000: 2 | Korea | 1993–1995 | ≤35 | 10/12: 44/105 | Singleton | 3 y | Cohort | Good | |
O’Shea et al56 1998b: 2 | United States | 1986–1993 | 500–1500 g | 14/21: 17/28 | Singleton | 1 y | Case-control | Fair | Postnatally caused CP excluded |
Yoon et al57 1997: 2 | Korea | 1993–1995 | 26–35 | 6/7: 33/75 | Singleton | 6 mo | Retrospective cohort | Fair | May have PIH |
HCA in term/ near-term CP | |||||||||
Wu et al59 2003: 2 | United States | 1991–1998 | ≥36 | 5/19: 1/9 | Singleton | >15 mo | Case-control | Good | |
Grether and Nelson60 1997: 2 | United States | 1983–1985 | ≥2500 g | 3/46: 3/378 | Singleton | 3 y | Case-control | Good | Postnatally caused CP excluded |
CCA/HCA in preterm CP | |||||||||
Costantine et al63 2007 | United States | 1993–2002 | 500 g–1 kg | 11/19: 8/38 | NA | 18–22 mo | Case-control | Good |
PIH, pregnancy-induced hypertension; PPROM, premature rupture of membranes; PTL, preterm labor.