Skip to main content
. 2017 Jun 19;12(6):e0179403. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0179403

Table 2. Fixed and random effects for the linear mixed model that measures the effect of the parameterization used on the accuracy.

The front-ends under consideration are MFCC (intercept), LDA1, LDA2, NMF_CC, H_CC + G_NMF and the combinations MFCC + H_CC + G_NMF and NMF_CC + H_CC + G_NMF. The inclusion of the first derivatives is indicated with the suffix “+ Δ‘”. For the fixed effect (parameterization), the classification rate ([%]) estimates, standard errors and t-values are shown. The statistical significance at p < 10−4 is marked with ***, p < 10−3 is marked with ** and p < 0.05 is marked with *. For the random effects (bird species and fold), variances and standard deviations are reported.

Fixed effects:
Estimate Std. Error t value
Intercept 69.623 4.633 12.800 ***
LDA1 −12.636 1.681 −7.519 ***
LDA2 −3.433 1.681 −2.043 *
NMF_CC 1.897 1.681 1.129
H_CC + G_NMF −3.141 1.681 −1.869
MFCC + Δ 3.070 1.681 1.827
NMF_CC + Δ 5.963 1.681 3.549 ***
MFCC + H_CC + G_NMF 4.070 1.681 2.422 *
NMF_CC + H_CC + G_NMF 4.280 1.681 2.547 *
MFCC + H_CC + G_NMF + Δ 4.393 1.681 2.614 **
NMF_CC + H_CC + G_NMF + Δ 6.119 1.681 3.641 ***
Random effects:
Groups Variance Std. Dev.
Species 236.884 15.391
Fold 1.871 1.368
Residual 101.668 10.083
Number of obs: 792, groups: Species, 12; Fold, 6