Table 1.
ICD codes | CPT codes | Laboratory data | Medication records | Clinical documentation | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Recall | Medium | Poor | Medium | Inpatient: High Outpatient: Variable |
Medium |
Precision | Medium | High | High | Inpatient: High Outpatient: Variable |
Medium high |
Query method | Structured | Structured | Mostly structured | Structured, text queries, and natural language processing | Text queries, natural language processing, rarely structured |
Strengths | Easy to query Serves as a good first pass of disease status |
Easy to query High precision |
Value depends on test High data validity |
Can have high validity and marker of severity | Best record of what providers thought |
Weaknesses | Disease codes are often used for screening Accuracy is hindered by billing realities and clinic workflow |
Most susceptible to missing data errors Influenced by patient and payer factors |
Normal ranges and units may change over time Aligning labs can be challenging |
Often requires interfacing inpatient and outpatient records Medications prescribed are not necessary taken |
Requires natural language processing May suffer from significant cut and paste May be self-contradictory |
Has been used in PheWASs to date | Yes (often) | No | Limited | No | In pilot studies |
Current challenges in PheWASs | Transitioning from ICD9 to ICD10 in the United States | Missing data | Aligning across sites and identifying normal values | Combining brand and generic names Mapping different forms (ophthalmic versus intravenous) |
Extracting robust sets of concepts from notes |
With the advent of the meaningful-use requirements and linked incentive payments from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, adoption of EHRs capable of logging each of the data types shown in this table has increased significantly; US adoption rates of certified EHRs currently exceed 90% for large hospitals (55). Abbreviations: CPT, Current Procedural Terminology; ICD, International Classification of Diseases; ICD9/10, International Classification of Diseases ninth and tenth editions, respectively; PheWAS, phenome-wide association study.