Table 3.
Method | Dataset | TWIs | TWIf | CPU | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
fD (%) | Improvement | fD (%) | Improvement | time (s) | ||
G-INS-i | ||||||
TWI+0 | 20.73a | — | 41.68b | — | 232.1 | |
TWI+20 | 27.38 | +6.65c | 47.00b | +5.32c | 747.4 | |
TWI+50 | 29.58 | +8.85c | 51.11 | +9.43c | 1724 | |
H-INS-i | ||||||
TWI+0 | 23.36 | — | 42.78 | — | 154.1 | |
TWI+20 | 26.30a | +2.94c | 47.40 | +4.62c | 467.0 | |
TWI+50 | 27.87a | +4.51c | 50.29b | +7.51c | 1102 | |
F-INS-i | ||||||
TWI+0 | 22.03a | — | 43.21 | — | 155.8 | |
TWI+20 | 25.80a | +3.77c | 47.12 | +3.91c | 405.1 | |
TWI+50 | 27.25a | +5.22c | 47.59a | +4.38c | 882.8 | |
H-INS-1 | ||||||
TWI+0 | 18.28a | — | 38.20a | — | 30.29 | |
TWI+20 | 22.48a | +4.20c | 43.81a | +5.61c | 144.6 | |
TWI+50 | 24.77a | +6.49c | 45.76a | +7.56c | 460.6 | |
FFT-NS-i | ||||||
TWI+0 | 18.16a | — | 37.46a | — | 124.1 | |
TWI+20 | 21.64a | +3.48c | 40.88a | +2.29c | 303.8 | |
TWI+50 | 22.76a | +4.60c | 44.85a | +7.49c | 565.6 | |
FFT-NS-2 | ||||||
TWI+0 | 12.89a | — | 30.27a | — | 19.41 | |
TWI+20 | 16.14a | +3.25c | 33.59a | +3.32c | 44.54 | |
TWI+50 | 17.49a | +4.60c | 37.08a | +6.87c | 77.36 | |
PROBCONS 1.06 | ||||||
TWI+0 | 22.06 | — | 44.48 | — | 234.0 | |
TWI+20 | 22.79a | +0.73d | 43.81a | −0.67 | 1747 | |
TWI+50 | 22.53a | +0.47 | 44.86a | +0.38 | 6889 | |
MUSCLE-i 3.41 | ||||||
TWI+0 | 15.67a | — | 36.38a | — | 382.3 | |
TWI+20 | 17.98a | +2.31c | 36.68a | +0.30 | 999.9 | |
TWI+50 | 19.61a | +3.94c | 38.17a | +1.79c | 2152 | |
TCoffee 2.02 | ||||||
TWI+0 | 21.80b | — | 44.20 | — | 1378 | |
TWI+20 | 22.81a | +1.01c | 44.56b | +0.36c | 13 900 | |
TWI+50 | 21.85a | +0.05d | 45.18a | +0.98c | 82 200 | |
CLUSTAL W 1.83 | ||||||
TWI+0 | 12.76a | — | 34.28a | — | 31.52 | |
TWI+20 | 11.72a | −1.04 | 33.59a | −0.69 | 152.7 | |
TWI+50 | 12.91a | +0.15 | 34.95a | +0.67 | 458.8 |
See the footnote of Table 2.