Table 4.
Method | Identity (%) | CPU time (s) | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
0–20 | 20–40 | 40–70 | 70–100 | All | ||
G-INS-i | 46.75 | 82.77 | 96.30 | 98.60 | 68.85 | 16 030 |
H-INS-i | 48.22 | 83.32 | 95.83 | 98.64 | 69.70 | 15 060 |
F-INS-i | 48.00 | 83.35 | 95.83 | 98.62 | 69.61 | 9007 |
H-INS-1 | 46.13a | 82.16a | 95.42b | 98.60 | 68.27 | 9910 |
FFT-NS-i | 45.72a | 80.95a | 93.83b | 98.55 | 67.48 | 4176 |
FFT-NS-2 | 43.19a | 79.52a | 93.23b | 98.47 | 65.74 | 930.4 |
FFT-NS-1 | 40.90a | 77.50a | 93.46a | 98.59 | 63.92 | 666.2 |
TCoffee 2.02 | 45.30a | 82.36b | 95.20 | 98.62 | 67.96 | 973 600 |
PROBCONS 1.06 | 45.63b | 82.10 | 95.01b | 98.18 | 67.95 | 142 200 |
MUSCLE-i | 42.77a | 80.43a | 95.43 | 98.28 | 66.05 | 13 260 |
MUSCLE-fast | 38.44a | 76.65a | 93.42a | 97.91 | 62.44 | 544.1 |
CLUSTAL W (default) | 33.96a | 74.14a | 93.54b | 97.85 | 59.45 | 12 970 |
The highest accuracy value within each percent identity range is in bold letters.
aThe difference from the highest accuracy was found to be significant (P < 0.01) by both the Wilcoxon test and the Friedman test.
bThe Wilcoxon test showed a significant difference but the Friedman test did not. See Table 1 for command-line options for each strategy in MAFFT. Options of other programs are as follows:
TCoffee, default;
PROBCONS, default;
MUSCLE-i, muscle -maxiters 1000;
MUSCLE-fast, muscle -sv -maxiters 1 -diags1 -distance1 kbit20_3;
CLUSTAL W (default), default.